The best burger in New Berlin?
I was amused and intrigued to get an e-mail, out of the blue, from an old colleague I've seen twice in the last 15 years. Joe is a mentor from before I even launched OnMilwaukee.com, and apparently, he's quite the beef enthusiast.
"Can I buy you the best burger in New Berlin?" he asked.
That invitation to catch up with an old friend, not to mention score a free lunch, was too good to pass up, so today I made the 25-minute drive to Matty's Bar & Grille, 14460 W. College Ave.
I'm not sure if I've ever ordered another hamburger in New Berlin, so I can't say definitively if it was the best. But I'd stack it alongside the best burgers I've had in Milwaukee, so it's very possible that it is.
Matty's hangs its hat on what it calls the "Smokehouse burger," a combination of Angus beef infused with their own smoked brisket. Starting the this month, they unveiled a different burger of the day, complete with a "Kopp's Custard" style list to take home. Today's burger, for example, was "The Firehouse," consisting of Havarti and provolone cheese, spicy ham, jalapeños, pepperoncini, ketchup, mayo and fresh dill on an Italian roll.
I opted to create my burger, if only to participate in their "burger creation contest." When I saw their list of artisan cheeses, I opted for a burger with a Asiago blend from Sheboygan with caramelized onions, avocado slices and Cajun sauce.
It was pretty great, though a little less salty than some of my other favorites like Kopp's or Oscar's. And whether I win the contest or not, I shall call my creation the OnMilwaukee.com Burger. Ask for it by name (but be prepared that no one will know what you're talking about).
Milwaukee is a town of many, many great burgers, so I'm not sure I'd drive all the way across town for this one (though apparently, their pizza is great, too). I liked the ambience and good service, however; and if I found myself tooling around the southwestern suburbs, I'd definitely stop back. If you're in the neighborhood, you should give Matty's a try, too.
How old are you Jimmy J. - you sound like my 7 year old. HaHa That Smokehouse Burger may be too mature for your taste buds today JJ, but you'll acquire the taste. They are great! Easily the best.
I'll take Jimmys free burger, New Berlin is'nt that far. HAHAHA!
Haha, thanks but no... it wouldn't be worth my drive time. If I'm ever out in New Berlin I'll try to remember to give you a try though. I wasn't trying to down your business so much as mock the comparison of "best in very small place"... if I hear you're the best in Waukesha County, that's going in the right direction.
I do like a tasty burger! I might have to drive to New Berlin myself next week to try one. Thanks for the tip!
Jimmy Jones you just won yourself a free Smokehouse burger at Matty's so you can have a opportunity to judge from first hand experience. Email me at firstname.lastname@example.org to get instructions on how to redeem. Cheers!
Show me the other Talkback
6 comments about this article.
Post a comment / write a review.
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.