In a forthcoming edition of Lake Effect, NPR's Dan Harmon and I discuss pizzerias -- what makes a good pizzeria, what makes a good pizza?
And for me, it's about personal taste to some degree. Some people like thick crust, some like thin, some loved stuffed pizzas (for me it depends on the day). Do you like canned or fresh mushrooms? What about the sauce-should it be bitter or sweet?
And do we aim traditional with a Margherita pizza with basil and slices of tomatoes, or skew more cosmopolitan with goat cheese and carmelized onions? Let's face it, there's a lot to be said on certain craving days for a basic cheese, sausage, mushroom and onion, especially when the sausage is chock full of fresh fennel seeds.
But one of my all time favorite pizzas is in my hometown of Wisconsin Rapids. There's not a lot in Wisconsin Rapids, so make sure you're heading up there to golf, visit the cranberry bogs or buzz through on your way to the Dairy State Cheese Factory (more to come on that in another writing); but there's a pizzeria called Portesi's Fine Foods, 4110 8th St., right smack in the middle of town, that's worth a stop.
It's become a family holiday tradition to get takeout from Portesi's on the first night of our visit. Scott and I both are addicted to the cracker-thin crust and the fact that it takes them over an hour just to build one of these freshly homemade pies.
Portesi's has been around since 1961, so we aren't the first people to stumble upon it, but the truly addictive nature of its pizzas ensures that we won't be the last, either.
I love that the pizzas still come in the same presentation they did when I was a kid -- lovingly sliced on a round of cardboard with the tiny plastic tripod to hold the paper surrounding them, and that that same cardboard doesn't contain a lick of grease once you've eaten the last slice. If you're anywhere in the vicinity, take the trek down Highway 13 and check this place out.
One final note-this is not the same Portesi's that has pizzas in the frozen section of your grocery store. You can only get it in good old Wisconsin Rapids. Go Raiders.
1 comment about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Amy L. Schubert
Published Oct. 21, 2010
Triskele's is gearing up for the changing seasons with a fresh batch of specials.
Published Oct. 18, 2010
As far as restaurants go, few deliver the consistency of Calderone Club, the family-owned Downtown Milwaukee hangout known for terrific pizza and more.
Published Aug. 30, 2010
Trocadero, 1758 N. Water St., underwent a major facelift earlier this year which not only changed the interior and patio, but pulled out much of the French influence from the menu and pulled in the trademarks that Diablos Rojos Restaurant Group has built into its CafĂ© Hollander and CafĂ© Centraal locations.
Published Aug. 16, 2010
Ordering prime rib can be hit or miss when dining out. At Ward's House of Prime, 540 E. Mason St., there's little need to worry. The upscale but low-key steakhouse gets things right.
Published Aug. 9, 2010
A first weekday lunch visit brought excellent sandwiches, but a weekend stop at Port of Call had different results.
Published Aug. 2, 2010
It may not be a true gastropub, but The Dubliner offers diners a meal that's well above average bar fare.
Published July 26, 2010
A trip to Jerry's Old Town in Germantown won't leave patrons confused; ribs are the featured attraction.
Published July 23, 2010
The Thursday-night storm brought childhood memories to Amy Schubert.
Published July 19, 2010
Those looking for a non-alcoholic offering out on the town don't have many choices.
Published July 19, 2010
Sometimes when you visit a restaurant after being away for some time, you run into the "not what I remembered" curse; you remember places and food as being far superior to what you actually experience upon your return visit. That was not the case upon visiting Emperor of China.