The fun and the challenges of reviewing a band you don't love
We review a lot of shows at OnMilwaukee.com, but we really kick it into overdrive during Summerfest. In addition to every Marcus Amphitheater act, we also cover a ton of the side stage shows.
Usually, when it comes to writing reviews, our staff picks bands we like to see. And that makes it easy. When you know all the words to every song, and if you've seen the band live before, writing a concert review is just transcribing all the thoughts that were in your head, anyway.
But it doesn't always work that way. While Summerfest has something for everyone, we can't all review the bands we want to see the most, since it does the reader little good to have five reviews of one Marcus act, and zero of another. Occasionally, we have to bite the bullet, take one for the team and review a band that we either like just a little, or sometimes not at all.
This year, my three Summerfest reviews are Hall & Oates, Katy Perry and Britney Spears. I wouldn't call myself a fan of any of them, although I don't particularly dislike them, either. Obviously, I was most familiar with Hall & Oates' work (yes, I owned their greatest hits album), but for Perry and Spears, I know only what I've heard on the radio and out and about.
When you don't know, or don't especially care to know a band's set list, it's true, you do have to work harder. But you are also free to focus on different parts of the concert when you're not singing along and cheering like everyone else (being a concert reviewer, at least at OnMilwaukee.com, isn't like sitting in the Miller Park press box – you're not banned from clapping and enjoying the experience).
When I see Perry tonight, I will focus on the set, the attitude of the crowd and how she sounds, compared to the radio. Same goes for Spears: Will she be lip-syncing? Will she mail it in? How will the audience react?
Really, I write about these things when I'm seeing my favorite band, too, but it's easier to be totally objective when you don't really care about what you're listening to. Not that being objective is necessarily the goal of a concert review – to me, the best concert reviews are the ones that either make the readers feel like they were there; or if they were, it reaffirms what they saw and fills in the blanks from what they missed.
So I'm telling you before the next two reviews run after the shows tonight and Saturday: I'm far more interested in the spectacle surrounding Katy Perry and Britney Spears than if they play my favorite songs by them. Because even though some of their music is catchy, I don't think I could name any favorites.
And that doesn't mean I will take them any less seriously than if they were a Radiohead or Beck or Dandy Warhols show.
These kinds of reviews present their own challenges, but they're also a writing exercise that helps sharpen our skills. Just like previous Summerfest shows I reviewed that I could've lived without, like Steve Miller, Eric Clapton or Kid Rock, I'm still excited to go.
Every big show review is a popular article on OnMilwaukee.com, and I'm ready for the challenge to cover the bands I don't care about as if they were a Beatles reunion.
Talkbacks
mug89 | July 11, 2011 at 6:39 p.m. (report)
I agree 100% on your Brewer thoughts. I dont think they are a team that is ready to win a World Series; I am by no means a baseball expert just a fan. I do enjoy going to the games and feel it is money well spent and I will continue to go! #gobrewers
Summerfest.Hmmmm I use to take a vacation for the run of Summerfest. I was one of those guys that went every day, not this year. This year I only went 2 days. I am not a fan of the new schedule (open on Wednesday close on Monday) there were only a few bands I wanted to see this year. For me part of the fun of going to Summerfest was finding a new band I like. I just did not want to go allot this year. Still Summerfest is a great event and over all is well run. Some change I would like to see is more of Milwaukees craft beer available (Coors light available come on whats Milwaukee about that?) and maybe a Milwaukee Food Truck Day on the grounds.
| Rate this: |
dukefame | July 7, 2011 at 3:58 p.m. (report)
While I can agree with some of the sentiment in this blog, I do have a major problem with local music/art critics who are afraid to criticize things they review. Far too often the critic will go to the end of the earth to praise anything local, when in actuality there needs to be more weeding out of what is exemplary. I'm fairly sure David Fricke, Robert Christgau and Jim DeRogatis don't/didn't always spin everything positively...
| Rate this: |
mistertony25 | July 7, 2011 at 1:44 p.m. (report)
If I went to see Katy Perry, I'd focus on the "set" too. HEEYYY-OOOHHHHH!!!!
| Rate this: |
![]() |
3 comments about this article. Post your comment/review now |
Facebook comments
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Andy Tarnoff
TV loyalty
Published May 17, 2013
I watched the series finale of "The Office" last night, but before I did, I had to blow through the previous five episodes gathering dust on my DVR. In the end, it was worth the night of marathon television, but when I think about the entire final season of "30 Rock," also unwatched on my DVR, I wonder when I'll get around to it.
Downtown's "secret" clothing shop sells high-end fashion at rock-bottom prices
Published May 15, 2013
Hidden in plain sight is a clothing store you have to see to believe. Frieschskys, 788 N. Jefferson St., isn't actually that special to look at. But when you step out of the elevator on the seventh floor of the nondescript office building, it doesn't take long to realize that something special does await you.
The nicest Brewers of all-time
Published May 13, 2013
Plenty is written about baseball's jerks. I've even met some of them. But rarely do people talk about how nice some players are. They may not have been the best players, but if personality counts (which it doesn't), they'd be in the Hall of Fame.
Milwaukee Talks: WISN-12 anchor and reporter Shelby Croft
Published May 9, 2013
Shelby Croft was following the playbook for most television reporters. She jumped from market to market, position to position, ultimately serving as a main anchor in Salt Lake. But Croft knew there was something more in life than market size. She moved to Milwaukee to get closer to home. She got married, had a daughter ... then got divorced. A single mom with a high-profile job, Croft's story is an interesting one.
Thoughts on the sudden death of a friend
Published May 3, 2013
Last night at about 3 a.m., I woke up to go to the bathroom. I used my phone to light my way, so as soon as my eyes adjusted, I noticed that my mom had sent me a death notice. My friend and neurosurgeon, Dr. Spencer Block - the guy who did my back surgery in 2011 - had died yesterday at age 51.
Why boo your own guys?
Published May 3, 2013
The Brewers should've won the game Wednesday, but John Axford blew a two-run lead in the eighth inning. Sitting close to the field, it was the first time I'd seen and heard the vitriol from fans around me. They booed him. A lot.
Are you Milwaukee's next rock star?
Published April 29, 2013
It's pretty thrilling to get on stage in front of a live band, facing a cheering audience, putting your personal spin on beloved cover tunes. The idea that you could win $1,000, studio recording time and a gig at Red Rock Saloon is practically gravy, right? The Red Rockstar II competition runs for four weeks in May, kicking off this Wednesday.
Perfection: The 2013 Jaguar XJ
Published April 24, 2013
If I was a less verbose writer, I could sum up the 2013 Jaguar XJ in one word: perfection. But that wouldn't make for much of a review, and after a month with the XJ that Fields Jaguar in Waukesha loaned me, I have so much more to say. I'll start with this: if you're the kind of person who can afford to spend $73,000 on a car, and you require something with four seats, this is the car you should buy. Run, don't walk, to Fields Jaguar and buy it. Now.
You can help cure cancer
Published April 24, 2013
This spring, the American Cancer Society is kicking off a massive project to sign up, track and study 300,000 adults for decades, in hopes of curing various types of cancer. It's not the first time the society has undertaken this. Cancer Prevention Study-3 (CPS-3) follows CPS-1 and CPS-2, and the results of the first two programs served to advance cancer knowledge and treatment by leaps and bounds. The Milwaukee goal for CPS-3 is 2,000 people.
Zoinks! Scooby Doo springs to life
Published April 21, 2013
It's great when a pop culture show can stay relevant long enough to be enjoyed as a kid, then enjoyed again through your kid's eyes decades later. Because Scooby Doo was around before I was born, and my daughter's finally at the age to watch the campy mystery cartoon, too, I not only didn't mind sitting through Sunday's performance of Scooby-Doo Live! Musical Mysteries at the Milwaukee Theatre - I enjoyed it almost as much as she did.
Like Us
Follow Us










