Almost blue: tasting Wisconsin cheeses with a hint of blue
Have a cow, man. Why not? After all, it's Dairy Month here at OnMilwaukee.com. Join us all month long as we explore all things that make you go "Moo" and celebrate America's Dairyland during the Dairy Days of Summer! Brought to you by OnMilwaukee.com and the Wisconsin Milk Marketing Board.
"Almost blue, almost doing things we used to do..."
I found myself humming this Elvis Costello gem while sampling a range of Wisconsin cheeses (and butter) this weekend. While I'm not a huge fan of overly pungent, blue- and green-veined cheeses, Wisconsin cheesemakers are taking classics and putting a blue spin on them. And the results, to my palate, are sumptuous.
My favorite of the bunch is Roelli's interpretation of an English farmstead acid crumbly cheese, named for Gravity Hill, which isn't far from Roelli's in Shullsburg. This crumbly, white, nutty cow's milk cheddar has a hint of tang and a nice firmness.
It's very similar to another satisfying cheddar blue from Roelli. The Dunbarton Blue is air cured in the cellar and also blends the nuttiness of an English cheddar with the piquant taste of a blue.
Also in the family is Roelli's Red Rock, a cheddar blue that will look more familiar to Wisconsinites, with its American-style yellow color, riven with earthy blue veins. Aging adds a depth and complexity that makes this a remarkable cheese.
Note that all three of these cheddars are subtly blue. Give them a try even if you think you don't like blue cheese. They'll come as a revelation.
Also check out Hook's Blue Paradise. It's a double cream blue, so it's smooth and creamy and rich, but, again, it's just a touch blue, so it's flavor is balanced, with a piquancy that is not at all overwhelming.
Now, Larry's Market Blue Cheese Bacon Butter, isn't a cheese and it doesn't come from a creamery, but, rather, is created right at Larry's Brown Deer location.
This light, creamy concoction blends unsalted butter, buttermilk blue cheese, chives and bits of Nueske's bacon, creating a versatile product that can be used as a spread with crackers or crostini, slathered atop a burger for extra tang, or even tossed with pasta as a creamy sauce.
While I've transitioned to butter, I'll take a moment to sing the praises of the Farmhouse Kitchens Hand Rolled Butter, from La Crosse. This "log" of direct-from-the-churn, hand-rolled butter comes wrapped, old style, in paper.
Unroll it to find a dense, sweet, creamy butter that it so rich in flavor, fans of industrially manufactured butter might only barely recognize it.
Talkbacks
![]() |
No Talkbacks for this article. Post your comment/review now |
Facebook comments
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Bobby Tanzilo
Former Color Truth frontman Steinbach finds the road back
Published May 19, 2013
It's been a long time since we've heard from Zach Steinbach. Nearly five years ago Steinbach fronted The Color Truth, a Milwaukee band that seemed poised to take the next step with its big, melodic, poppy rock and roll. The band fizzled out a couple years back, leaving Steinbach a bit lost. But now, he's back. He's got a band, and he's got a new solo record. More, than anything, he says, he's got a new lease on a musical life.
Let's put the "front" back in Front Street
Published May 16, 2013
For a variety of reasons, I've been thinking about Front Street, which now seems so ironically named, fronting as it does onto nothing and serving as the ultimate definition of a Milwaukee "backstreet." In my mind, I see something much different that can be seen on the block today.
New Eric & Magill song debuts
Published May 15, 2013
Milwaukee's Eric & Magill, who released an EP called "Two Travelers" in February, will follow it up with a second full-length record this summer. Ryan Weber and Eric Osterman release "Night Singers" on July 23. You can hear the song, "Baggage and Clothes" now.
Brush up on your McCartney this week, Milwaukee
Published May 15, 2013
With a return by Paul McCartney on tap this summer at Miller Park, the arrival of "Rockshow," is well-timed. The film, which screens at the Bayshore iPic at 8 p.m. on Thursday, May 16, and at 2 p.m. on Sunday, May 19, was filmed on the same 1975-76 U.S. tour that led to Paul McCartney & Wings' triple-live album, "Wings Over America."
Enemy Star goes supernova
Published May 14, 2013
Local hard rock outfit Enemy Star has called it quits, according to guitarist and founder Paris Ortiz, who wrote in today to say the band will play two final gigs this weekend, including one at Club Anything with a special surprise guest.
Biden to Milwaukee student: People love chocolate
Published May 13, 2013
This morning, Jenny Aicher, a teacher at Downtown Montessori in Bay View, wrote to share some big news on campus. A student in her class received a handwritten note from Vice President Joe Biden.
Fish fry: Double Eagle Pub
Published May 13, 2013
"One of Milwaukee's best kept secrets ... if you can find the Double Eagle Pub, you will enjoy the Double Eagle Pub!"
Vinyl resurgence breathes life into record shop business
Published May 13, 2013
We asked Ken Chrisien at Acme and Dan DuChaine at Rushmor - both in Bay View - and Luke Lavin at Bull's Eye, on the East Side, about how the recession affected the business, about Record Store Day and more. Their answers might surprise you.
Urban Spelunking: Prospect Mall renovation
Published May 10, 2013
A plan emerged last year to bring new life to the Prospect Mall on the East Side. Developer Robert Joseph is tearing the building - erected in 1912 as a Pierce-Arrow automobile dealership - down to the bones to create first floor retail and parking, with a four-story residential tower perched diagonally on the roof. We got a peek inside yesterday.
First look: The revamped Horse & Plow
Published May 9, 2013
The bowling alleys are long gone, but the loss has never affected the popularity of The Horse & Plow pub in The American Club at Kohler. The subterranean pub and grille was especially bustling during a recent Tuesday visit as the lunch service drew a mix of locals, resort guests and - because the weather was good - golfers to the eatery, which recently got a bit of a facelift.
Like Us
Follow Us










