I can't honestly say I didn't see it coming.
In fact, when we learned at our school that MPS would trim funding for K3 by about a third for the upcoming year, some parents – including me – even discussed whether or not it was possible to ask families who could afford to pay for 3-year-old kindergarten to do so.
The state does not fund K3 education, meaning it is entirely board-funded in Milwaukee. However, the board now funds just under 75 percent and schools must make up the rest themselves.
This was in January, before the governor's budget proposal was announced. Among the changes made to the district budget after the grim news emerged from Madison was a proposed cut to busing for regular education K3 and K4 students.
That idea was met with resistance from families, teachers and board members. However, it is illegal for MPS to charge for transportation. So the idea of a fee for the bus, based on ability to pay, was quickly quashed.
During the discussion of these issues in May, the Board of School Directors Strategic Planning and Budget committee instead took a different approach and discussed the idea of a fee for K3 on a sliding scale, based on the ability to pay.
I shouldn't have been surprised, and yet I was.
Most board members and Superintendent Thornton have spoken on the record about their support for and the importance of early education. And anyone paying attention knew that Dr. Thornton was working behind the scenes to try and find ways to avoid even that initial 30 percent cut to K3 funding.
I should make it clear that the fee was not a done deal as it was worded in the amendment. That amendment stated that money for K3 and K4 transportation would be reinstated and that the superintendent would investigate a fee. But it sure sounded like the fee was coming and that it was only the amount that needed investigating.
I'll say here that I might be willing to pay a fee, which likely would be nothing like what I pay for day care and I know from experience that kids learn a lot in K3. It is definitely NOT day care. My child is reading and writing at a level at least a year, maybe two, ahead of where I was at the same age. And it is clearly due to the work he did in K3 and K4.
There are, however, two things that concern me.
First – and Dr. Thornton and a number of board members made this point, too, at that committee meeting – fees can be a slippery slope. You institute one fee and it becomes easier to justify a few more and on and on and on.
In a district in which 80 percent of kids are in poverty, this is untenable. Will poorer families be stressed about the fees and be scared away from early childhood education? Will families that can afford the fees get the sense they're subsidizing everyone else and leave the district?
Since K3 education is not universal in the district, I could understand the argument that the folks who use it should help fund it (beyond our funding of it already via our taxes).
By the same token, though, not everyone uses special education resources, attends a specialty school like a language immersion or gets an IB diploma, either. Should those families pay more? And so goes the slippery slope of fee-dom...
Second, I'm a little uneasy about the idea of imposing a fee on one thing to pay for something else. The discussion at that committee meeting was plain. We can't charge and say it's for transportation, but we can charge for K3 and not say that it's for transportation.
The morning after that meeting, I chatted with the school board's Meagan Holman, who assured me I had misunderstood – though others, including an MPS administrator told me they'd heard exactly what I had. The main point, she assured me, was that transportation was back.
Of course, like her, I celebrate that fact. Because while I don't agree that driving kids around town is the best use of money or time, the K3 programs are often at specialty schools like the Montessoris or early education schools like 68th Street and Starms. Remove the transportation option and you deny those opportunities to kids who don't live nearby.
In a city like Milwaukee, to deny access to transportation is to support segregated schools.
When the budget passed on Tuesday night, the amendment passed, too, and K3 fees on a sliding scale became, if not a done deal, then at the very least, a distinct possibility.
I wasn't at the meeting, but someone who was there told me that Dr. Thornton said that if unexpected money should come from the state, it would go first to fund SAGE class size reduction efforts and then to eliminate K3 fees.
So, I went back to Holman and asked, in an email, what's up...
"When we passed that amendment, after lengthy debate, as a body we added that there be some funding source (for transportation), developed by the administration," Holman responded, talking about the earlier committee meeting.
"Since that time, we have learned from the budget staff that to even come close to bridging this gap, the families of just 250 K3 students, which is what remains of those not participating in FRPL (Free and Reduced Price Lunch) program, would be called upon to provide significant personal contributions far beyond what I believe any of us intended at the time of our deliberations."
Holman made a motion to change the wording of the amendment to read that the administration "may" impose a fee. She also said that the idea of a fee, at least for the moment, seems dead for a number of reasons.
"Taken with the fact that, to my knowledge, we don't have an opinion from the city attorney as to whether charging a fee would be legal, that K3 students who could not afford the fee would not be able to find alternate preschool seats at this point in the calendar year, and that no mechanism for collecting the fee or maintaining billing records without additional personnel or staff time has been developed, I hope that the administration will study this and come back to us with a plan."
From what I hear on Vliet Street, there is no desire to institute a fee for early education, and so, on the surface of it, at least, it looks as if Holman is right that the issue seems dead at the moment.
It's unfortunate that this discussion even has to take place and I credit the board and the administration for not taking the discussion lightly. I do, however, encourage them to continue to tread with caution into the treacherous mountain region of Fee-land.
No Talkbacks for this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Bobby Tanzilo
Published Oct. 2, 2015
With such a burgeoning dining scene, it can sometimes take some effort to keep up, much less think back about how Milwaukee has become such a diners' delight. But OnMilwaukee's own dining guru, Lori Fredrich, has made it easy. Fredrich has written the first real in-depth book about Milwaukee's exciting dining scene and how it got that way.
Published Oct. 2, 2015
Milwaukee is a city rife with associations, from beer to brats, Hogs to "Happy Days." But for devoted fans of Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band, Milwaukee means only one thing: the bomb scare show - that Thursday night in October 1975 when the band's Cream City concert was halted by a bomb threat and resumed three hours later, resulting in a high-energy show unlike any other the band would ever perform. Are you loose?!
Published Sept. 29, 2015
With a string of three shows by unrivaled country megastar Garth Brooks on tap at the BMO Harris Bradley Center last week, the postponement of an anticipated 50th anniversary tour concert by The Who at the venue, and the drive to build a replacement for the BC clearing its final hurdle, it seemed like the perfect time to sit down with the Bradley Center's Director of Booking Doug Johnson to talk about the past, present and future.
Published Sept. 25, 2015
Our first stop on a long road trip east? A 15-minute drive to Bay View to board the Lake Express Ferry. The two-and-half-hour trip not only saved us navigating Chicago on a Friday morning, but was also great fun in itself. And there's definitely something to be said for arriving in Michigan ready to go with a full tank of gas.
Published Sept. 22, 2015
Milwaukee's City Plan Commission yesterday approved architects' Engberg Anderson's plan to rehab and add onto the former First German Methodist Church - later dubbed Building 23 after Pabst purchased it - at 1037 W. Juneau Ave. That means the project can now officially move forward.
Published Sept. 21, 2015
Though Kenny Baldwin was a drummer with local bands like Colour Radio and Locate Your Lips, he was most influential behind the scenes at his family's club, The Starship, and for his many years of production work at Summerfest. Beloved by everyone who knew him, Baldwin lost a long battle with cancer on Friday.
Published Sept. 18, 2015
We've all seen the Milwaukee neighborhood posters. Decades after their first appearance, these images endure. These iconic 1980s posters were created by then-city employee Jan Kotowicz and featured a long essay by historian John Gurda on the reverse. The posters have now also served as an anchor for a weighty new tome published by Historic Milwaukee Inc. The 472-page book, "Milwaukee: City of Neighborhoods," was written by Gurda and includes 11 new poster images created by the now-retired Kotowicz.
Published Sept. 17, 2015
When Milwaukee artist Ariana Huggett started to leak out images of the paintings for her upcoming show, "Old Schools" - on view Saturday and Sunday, Sept. 19-20, in conjunction with Doors Open Milwaukee, at the Material Studios + Gallery in the Third Ward - a lot of folks took notice.
Published Sept. 16, 2015
Last night, Milwaukee Public Library upped the number of Wisconsin Writers Wall of Fame inductees when it added Increase Lapham to the Badger State pantheon.
Published Sept. 16, 2015
Though the newly buffed Streets of Old Milwaukee won't open to the public until Dec. 11 - work is currently on schedule, according to museum staff - I got a peek inside this week, along with MPM's Director of Exhibits Julian Jackson.