Ruminations on the modern report card
I admit I was kind of excited when my eldest child started getting report cards. I'm pretty sure I wasn't so excited to get my own as a kid and I know for sure I wasn't eager to share my high school reports with my parents.
But, recently, my kids and I looked at – and chuckled over – my grade school report cards. They were heavy card-stock affairs that had handwritten notes and the boxes were ticked by hand in pen (I love that the checks from each year's marking periods were often in random, different color pens).
They not only felt personal, they were personal. On my fourth grade end-of-year report card, my teacher wrote (and I paraphrase), "I loved being a part of the Tanzilo family for another year." (Alas, a more common, recurring note, read something like, "Robert could show better self control in class.")
Now, my kid's report cards are computer print-outs. There is, of course, a personal note from the teacher, which is the most useful part of the multi-page report, offering the most insight into how my child is doing on a day-to-day basis.
Otherwise, two pages are computer-ticked boxes covering a variety of subjects and performance parameters. Another page covers MAP (Measures of Academic Progress) test results, expressed in not-so-clear numbers and bar graphs. A few other sheets are a letter from the principal, an explanation of the cards and suggestions for practice in subjects requiring further practice.
There is a wealth of information, and I'm happy to say that all of it is good news and I understand most of it, though parents less engaged in public education might find it a little more challenging.
But, a computer print-out still feels a little cold compared to the handwritten report cards of my youth.
Talkbacks
KMo | Feb. 5, 2013 at 3:02 p.m. (report)
Bobby,
I am also an MPS parent and just read my kid's report card last night. What I find most maddening is trying to interpret the politics of "progressing" vs. "proficient" scores. It seems as though my child's test scores (97-99 percentile) are inconsistent with her progress in the classroom and I'm wondering whether the way in which educators are evaluated is affecting the evaluations, i.e., whether the educator must demonstrate consistent improvement across time and if a student does not improve such as when she starts at a proficient level, there is some push back. I hope I am wrong about this but wouldn't be surprised.
| Rate this: |
mygreendoor | Feb. 4, 2013 at 8:48 a.m. (report)
bobby this is but one of the things wrong with public education (and not MPS per se). A child shouldn't be reduced to a "wealth of information". Kids are more than just data. And a report card shouldn't be some anonymous computer generated thing based on numbers and test scores. It should be what you had as a kid - a clear indication that a teacher was able to have a personal interaction with both the child and his family. And my goodness - a parent shouldn't have to be intimately involved in public education just to decipher their kid's report card! It sickens me how public education has reduced a child to his test scores and the data that can be gleaned from him.
| Rate this: |
![]() |
2 comments about this article. Post your comment/review now |
Facebook comments
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Bobby Tanzilo
Luminescent new MOWA lets Wisconsin artists shine
Published May 24, 2013
Difficult as it is to imagine now that I've seen the place, I was almost a bit worried I might have trouble spotting the new Museum of Wisconsin Art on my first visit recently. Turns out there's no way I could miss Hammel Green & Abrahamson architect Jim Shields' luminescent West Bend building, the pointed prow of which seems to make a statement by aiming itself not southeast toward Milwaukee, but northwest, toward the broader expanse of the state.
Inspired by Aimee Mann, Ben Smith salutes The Bronze Fonz
Published May 23, 2013
More melodious love for the Bronze Fonz has arrived from afar. Yesterday, West Chester, Pa.-based singer and songwriter Ben Smith wrote to share one of his tunes with us. It's one that pays homage to the Bronze Fonz, says Smith.
Traveling Slugger show steps up to bat at Miller Park
Published May 23, 2013
If Discovery World's recent "Baseball - Innovations That Changed the Game" exhibit caught your attention, head over to Miller Park as the Brewers tackle the Pirates this weekend, May 24-26. In the stadium's concourse, you'll find a traveling interactive experience created specifically for this series at Miller Park by the Louisville Slugger Museum & Factory in Louisville, Ky.
Krause's pamphlet considers the junction of comedy and politics
Published May 22, 2013
It seems, at the outset, like an unexpected marriage: "The acts of thinking comedically and behaving democratically share enough analogous elements that an extended comparison between the two makes each much clearer." But, Milwaukee writer and musician Adam Krause sat down at the intersection of Comedy and Politics to have a think and the result is "The Revolution Will Be Hilarious," which in a mere 41 pages makes a cogent and, in the end, startlingly simple point.
Getting to the bottom of Bay View
Published May 21, 2013
A group of students from MPS' Bay View and Bradley Tech High Schools is working in concert with Discovery World to excavate a lost block of homes in Bay View this weekend.
Scouting the Sherbrooke fish fry
Published May 21, 2013
After a big renovation and a quiet relaunch, Shepherd's on North in Wauwatosa has now been officially re-christened "The Sherbrooke," and I stopped in recently on a Friday to scout the fish fry.
Pabst's enduring pavilion faces extinction
Published May 20, 2013
Thanks to Erik Larson's 2003 bestseller, "The Devil in the White City," yet another generation is fascinated by the 1893 Chicago World's Fair: Columbian Exposition. Despite its enduring - in itself somewhat surprising - popularity, little remains of this by all accounts stunning little temporary city. One survivor serves as the entrance and gift shop to The Pabst Mansion, 2000 W. Wisconsin Ave., and it is in increasingly desperate condition.
The coolest record of the '60s folk revival was made in Milwaukee
Published May 20, 2013
As part of "The Avant Garde Coffee House Project" exhibit currently on view, there's a glass-topped case with some posters and a record. It's a pretty nondescript thing, frankly, with a black and white photo and some not especially artful text. But that little record - "Blues, Rags and Hollers," by folk blues trio Koerner, Ray & Glover - made a big bang when it was released in June 1963. And it was made in Milwaukee.
Former Color Truth frontman Steinbach finds the road back
Published May 19, 2013
It's been a long time since we've heard from Zach Steinbach. Nearly five years ago Steinbach fronted The Color Truth, a Milwaukee band that seemed poised to take the next step with its big, melodic, poppy rock and roll. The band fizzled out a couple years back, leaving Steinbach a bit lost. But now, he's back. He's got a band, and he's got a new solo record. More, than anything, he says, he's got a new lease on a musical life.
Let's put the "front" back in Front Street
Published May 16, 2013
For a variety of reasons, I've been thinking about Front Street, which now seems so ironically named, fronting as it does onto nothing and serving as the ultimate definition of a Milwaukee "backstreet." In my mind, I see something much different that can be seen on the block today.
Like Us
Follow Us










