The push back against testing in schools is all over the news lately, with protests across the country by parents and educators who believe schools are spending way too much time not only testing, but prepping for tests, to the exclusion of all subjects other than the few that are tested.
Among the tests kids take at MPS are three rounds of computerized MAP (Measures of Academic Progress) testing, which is given soon after the school year begins to benchmark kids' abilities and again in winter and spring to map progress.
Starting at third grade (through eighth, and then again in 10th), there is the state test, which until this year has been the WKCE (Wisconsin Knowledge and Concepts Examinations). That will be replaced next year with online Smarter Balanced Testing. These are the tests the Feds look at to rate what it deems to be progress.
This year, nearly all second graders in the district took a Cognitive Abilities Test, dubbed CogAT, that was mandated to ensure that kids at the highest levels are receiving a sufficiently challenging education.
Here is what an MPS Power Point says of the CogAT:
CogAT is a norm referenced assessment that measures "learned reasoning abilities"
- Verbal Battery: assesses ability to use search, retrieval and comparison processes
- Quantitative Battery: assesses ability to reason about patterns and relationships
- Non Verbal Battery: assesses ability to reason with novel questions that use spatial and figural content
Let's be honest, it's basically an IQ test, even if it's not called that or scored the same way.
Just under 6,000 kids at 109 of MPS' 110 elementary schools took part in the testing (103 using paper and pencil and six online). I wonder not only which school was exempted – and why – but if kids in other gifted and talented programs, like the one at Victory School, for example, were tested.
And why kids at schools like the seven Montessoris, which already differentiate for all kids, had to take it is unclear.
The district got the results of the tests on Feb. 14, and schools got them a couple weeks ago, and are sharing them with families. Over spring break, some parents – the ones whose kids scored highest – began to get letters at home from Central Services with their kids' results.
The results, by the way, showed that 53 MPS second graders qualify for Mensa. Of those kids, 28.3 percent have an IEP and/or qualify for free or reduced lunch.
Overall, 52.3 percent of kids testing in the "average" range, 27.4 in the "below average" stanines and 13 percent were "above average."
According to a district Power Point last month, "principals, APs and instructional coaches were trained on how to read their CogAT data and plan for GT interventions (and) instructional coaches or principals will hold second and third grade level meetings to discuss data and plan educational opportunities for GT students by mid-March."
Next year, the students identified as gifted and talented by the test, as well as by MAP scores and teacher observations, "will be flagged in the new student identification system" for the upcoming school year and, apparently, in subsequent grades.
I'm curious, what are your thoughts on the CogAT testing? Do you think it will serve its intended purpose?
Is that purpose worth adding another test to the regimen of three MAP tests, WKCE, etc.?
Is the CogAT measuring what is already sufficiently measured via MAP tests?
Has your school sent home results yet? How were the scores communicated?
Has there been push back from families and school staff?
Should kids know the results? Will kids discuss their results among themselves? (Of course they will. On MAP testing days, the kids come home knowing not only their own results but the results of all their friends, regardless of whether or not they understand the scoring system.)
Share using the talkback feature below, comment on Facebook or send me an email.
No Talkbacks for this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Bobby Tanzilo
Published Aug. 16, 2014
From ugly parking structures, to dead stretches of street to a freeway that cuts like machetes, Milwaukee -- for all its vigor -- still has some problem spots. We look at some on the east side of Downtown.
Published Aug. 15, 2014
Ever since my colleague Nick Barth hipped me to the waffle dog, I've been chasing after the Eats & Treats Truck and, yesterday, I finally caught up.
Published Aug. 14, 2014
The Milwaukee Public Museum has just announced that the rattlesnake in its second floor bison hunt exhibition has fled the scene. According to the release, the snake has gone on vacation, and has apparently been in contact with museum officials.
Published Aug. 14, 2014
Milwaukee's got a knack for putting waste to good use. Consider Milorganite or, less obviously to those of us up here on the surface, the city steam system. Follow Bobby Tanzilo as he goes down into two We Energies steam tunnels beneath the streets of Downtown.
Published Aug. 11, 2014
All MPS students will now have access to free breakfast and lunch at school. Over the summer, Milwaukee Public Schools was accepted into a program, open to schools that take part in the National School Lunch and School Breakfast Programs, that allows it to offer free lunch to all students enrolled in the district.
Published Aug. 11, 2014
In my sixth summer of shopping for school supplies, how could I possibly have thought I'd just "run in" to a big box store and grab some supplies?
Published Aug. 11, 2014
New Milwaukee Public Museum Director Dennis Kois is a hometown boy who never expected to return to his native Milwaukee. We sat down to talk about coming home, what he found at the museum when he arrived and what the future will bring for a venerable Milwaukee institution.
Published Aug. 9, 2014
Built on the site of a former quarry, Hartung Park isn't huge, but it's packed with amenities. It also celebrates its silurian period history, when millions of years ago, this was a warm water inter-reef basin filled with plant and animal life.
Published Aug. 8, 2014
You can tell when folks really love their home. Ferry & Clas' Northern Trust Building, 526 E. Wisconsin Ave., is that kind of place. Its beauty is recognized and appreciated every day by the folks lucky enough to spend their time in a Milwaukee landmark.
Published Aug. 7, 2014
"The Downtown Milwaukee River ... Once a mighty stream of commerce, now seeks a new role in the life of the city." So said a 1968 report by the Milwaukee River Technical Study Committee, a 10-member group of local officials that convened for five years to assess the state of the river, look back at its history and consider its future. The report makes for interesting reading nearly 50 years later.