The push back against testing in schools is all over the news lately, with protests across the country by parents and educators who believe schools are spending way too much time not only testing, but prepping for tests, to the exclusion of all subjects other than the few that are tested.
Among the tests kids take at MPS are three rounds of computerized MAP (Measures of Academic Progress) testing, which is given soon after the school year begins to benchmark kids' abilities and again in winter and spring to map progress.
Starting at third grade (through eighth, and then again in 10th), there is the state test, which until this year has been the WKCE (Wisconsin Knowledge and Concepts Examinations). That will be replaced next year with online Smarter Balanced Testing. These are the tests the Feds look at to rate what it deems to be progress.
This year, nearly all second graders in the district took a Cognitive Abilities Test, dubbed CogAT, that was mandated to ensure that kids at the highest levels are receiving a sufficiently challenging education.
Here is what an MPS Power Point says of the CogAT:
CogAT is a norm referenced assessment that measures "learned reasoning abilities"
- Verbal Battery: assesses ability to use search, retrieval and comparison processes
- Quantitative Battery: assesses ability to reason about patterns and relationships
- Non Verbal Battery: assesses ability to reason with novel questions that use spatial and figural content
Let's be honest, it's basically an IQ test, even if it's not called that or scored the same way.
Just under 6,000 kids at 109 of MPS' 110 elementary schools took part in the testing (103 using paper and pencil and six online). I wonder not only which school was exempted – and why – but if kids in other gifted and talented programs, like the one at Victory School, for example, were tested.
And why kids at schools like the seven Montessoris, which already differentiate for all kids, had to take it is unclear.
The district got the results of the tests on Feb. 14, and schools got them a couple weeks ago, and are sharing them with families. Over spring break, some parents – the ones whose kids scored highest – began to get letters at home from Central Services with their kids' results.
The results, by the way, showed that 53 MPS second graders qualify for Mensa. Of those kids, 28.3 percent have an IEP and/or qualify for free or reduced lunch.
Overall, 52.3 percent of kids testing in the "average" range, 27.4 in the "below average" stanines and 13 percent were "above average."
According to a district Power Point last month, "principals, APs and instructional coaches were trained on how to read their CogAT data and plan for GT interventions (and) instructional coaches or principals will hold second and third grade level meetings to discuss data and plan educational opportunities for GT students by mid-March."
Next year, the students identified as gifted and talented by the test, as well as by MAP scores and teacher observations, "will be flagged in the new student identification system" for the upcoming school year and, apparently, in subsequent grades.
I'm curious, what are your thoughts on the CogAT testing? Do you think it will serve its intended purpose?
Is that purpose worth adding another test to the regimen of three MAP tests, WKCE, etc.?
Is the CogAT measuring what is already sufficiently measured via MAP tests?
Has your school sent home results yet? How were the scores communicated?
Has there been push back from families and school staff?
Should kids know the results? Will kids discuss their results among themselves? (Of course they will. On MAP testing days, the kids come home knowing not only their own results but the results of all their friends, regardless of whether or not they understand the scoring system.)
Share using the talkback feature below, comment on Facebook or send me an email.
No Talkbacks for this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Bobby Tanzilo
Published July 28, 2014
In honor of Downtown Employee Appreciation Week -- and the start of State Fair -- I offer up this little quiz. Be the first to post a talkback with correct answers to the questions accompanying all five images and you'll win a pair of State Fair tickets.
Published July 28, 2014
This week more than 1,000 arborists from around the country will take root in Milwaukee for the International Society of Arboriculture (ISA) Conference, Aug. 2-6 at the Wisconsin Center and Mount Mary University.
Published July 25, 2014
This morning, like many of you, I heard retired baseball manager Tony LaRussa on NPR's "Morning Edition" talking about his induction this weekend in the the Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown. He suggested Mark McGwire should be inducted into the Hall of Fame but with an asterisk. As a manager who benefited from McGwire's performance, should LaRussa's plaque have an asterisk, too?
Published July 25, 2014
In May 2011, I wrote about the Milwaukee Public Library's recently installed green roof, which boasted not only a couple rows of solar panels, but 33,000 square feet of rainwater capturing and temperature moderating plants. Back then, the plants were in but they were little more than seedlings, so the roof didn't look very green. This week, I stopped in to check on the progress.
Published July 24, 2014
Now that Lee School -- which closed in 2009 -- is back in the news, it seemed like a good time to finally get a look at this vintage schoolhouse I've long been eager to see.
Published July 22, 2014
Today, I visited the Milwaukee Public Library's beautiful Central Library to do research for a couple upcoming stories. While I was there, I asked to see the dome...
Published July 22, 2014
If you want the ultimate new perspective on the city, the best place to get it is on the lake. Unless you're a Lake Michigan boater, looking at the city from out on the water is a rare treat. Sailing on the S/V Denis Sullivan, which makes its summer home at Discovery World is an incomparable way to enjoy that view. But, while on board, you can also chip in some elbow grease and help the crew raise the sails.
Published July 18, 2014
Festa Italiana is putting a new spin on its wine offerings this year, with a trio of tents along the lakefront walk that salute the diversity and quality of Italy's regions, from the north down to the south.
Published July 17, 2014
The Urban Habitat exhibit at the Milwaukee Public Museum was a popular one -- and one that remains embossed in the minds of many Milwaukeeans -- but maybe folks didn't quite realize it at the time.
Published July 16, 2014
Every week I drive past this place on 21st and Highland and it catches my eye. Though I haven't stopped and knocked on the door yet, I've been doing a little digging to see what I can find about the church at 1102 N. 21st St.