It would be a parents' nightmare to discover that the son that they’ve raised for six years wasn’t actually their own, but in fact, someone else’s. That's the revelation at the center of Japanese writer-director Hirokazu Koreeda’s latest, "Like Father, Like Son," Wednesday night's Milwaukee Film members screening for the month of April.
Two 6-year-old boys are switched at birth and given to the wrong families, who must now decide what to do. This nightmarish and unshakable "switched at birth" twist has been done in films before, but not as beautifully observed as this picture, which focuses on the parental crisis and the familial ties that bind.
Koreeda, known for his other masterworks such as "Nobody Knows," "Still Walking" and "I Wish," returns with another drama that dominantly focuses on familial themes. In 2004’s "Nobody Knows," a 12-year-old must take care of his younger siblings after they’re left to fend for themselves inside an apartment. "Still Walking" (2008) is a drama about a family grieving the death of a loved one. 2011’s "I Wish" follows a separated family following a divorce.
"Like Father, Like Son" leads itself down a similar humanistic narrative path, expanding beyond clichés and melodrama for a more quiet, grounded approach in reality.
The film opens with Ryota (Masaharu Fukuyama) and Midori (Machiko Ono), a well off, upper-class couple sitting alongside their son Keita. As they stare into the camera, school officials ask them a series of questions. Keita is reserved and behaved for his young age, sitting politely and answering questions articulately – or at least, as much a 6-year-old can be considered articulate, as if he’s putting on a performance of sorts.
In fact, they are actually putting on a performance. Their fabricated answers are only to help their chances as they’re being interviewed as part of an entrance exam to a seemingly elite school. After all, Ryota and Midori want what they think is best for Keita.
Although the family is obviously well off just by observing their modern, upscale apartment, their dynamic is a bit cold. Ryota spends much of his time working while the obedient Midori spends most of her time at home. When he’s home, however, he helps mold Keita through piano lessons and limited playtime through a routine. Their calmness and routine, however, is interrupted by a phone call from the country hospital where Keita was born, a call that turns their lives upside down.
For reasons revealed later in the film, Keita was swapped at birth with another boy, Ryusei (Shogen Hwang), their actual son. The news leads to a bit of inner turmoil as they’re confronted with their own parental shortcomings. With the assistance of the hospital, they arrange a meeting with the other parents, Yukari (Yoko Maki) and Yudai (Riri Furanki), who were also unaware of the news.
Koreeda deliberately paces the film with a bit of ease and observation, choosing to focus on the two families and their differences as they attempt to make important decisions. Once the two families and their differences are established, however, Koreeda interestingly shifts the attention solely towards both Keita and Ryusei and their newfound lives in completely new environments with new parents. They essentially become strangers in a strange land, as apparent through their uneasy transition shown in the second half of the film.
It was also interesting to watch the two families who couldn’t be anymore different, both socially and economically. While Ryota and Midori are more formal, Yukari and Yudai are portrayed as a disordered, quirky working-class couple. Besides raising Ryusei, they also have two other young children who cramp together in a small, disheveled apartment that’s nearby Yudai's store, where he spends his time fixing appliances.
It’s clear that Yukari and Yudai are genuine parents, making ends meet however they can. However, this isn’t as apparent to Ryota, who is disappointed to find out that a low-class family raised his real son. He sees the situation as a matter of business and requests to raise both children, but Yukari and Yudai refuse and become offended. It’s only after this point that they agree on a gradual custody exchange over weekends.
With no other clear-cut solution as to whether they should simply swap children at the request of the hospital or not, the two families meet as they try to figure out the future and what’s best for their children and themselves.
While the story focuses on the difference between the two families, much of the focus is geared towards Ryota and his own personal difficulties. Fukuyama, a Japanese singer/songwriter as well as an actor, portrays Ryota with depth and complexity.
By the end of "Like Father, Like Son", Koreeda masterfully brings up the question: Is it blood that connects a mother and father with their child, or is it time and nurture? This, of course, springs forward the "nature vs. nurture" debate in the film. Blood ties are obviously important, especially throughout different cultures. However, time and nurture with the child cannot be ruled out as a resulting factor of what imprints a child.
This debate can and will go on forever, but Koreeda manages to give some kind of an answer, leading to a somewhat poignant and blurry conclusion.
No Talkbacks for this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Colton Dunham
Published Oct. 11, 2014
It's a tough act to balance comedy and drama ... especially if you're balancing themes of suicide and familial estrangement with humor and heart. Director Craig Johnson ("True Adolescents") finds just the right balance for the dramedy "The Skeleton Twins," mixing heartache with hilarity, and giving "Saturday Night Live" alums Kristen Wiig and Bill Hader time to flex their dramatic muscles as estranged suicidal siblings who reunite and find commonality.
Published Oct. 10, 2014
School by school, 4th through 6th grade students, teachers and chaperones filed into the theatre and took their seats in the main house of the Oriental Theatre, waiting to be taken away by the beautifully crafted Spanish-language animated film "AninA." The screening was held as part of Milwaukee Film's education screenings during the film festival.
Published Oct. 9, 2014
In the Mexican comedy "We Are The Nobles," there's a scheme at its center that forces riches, or in this case three spoiled rich 20-somethings, into working rags to prove a point that they'll hopefully learn from. It's a breezy foreign affair with a satirical nibble rather than a bite.
Published Oct. 6, 2014
Indie dramedies about a 20-something in flux seems to peek its head out every week or so. There are some that are undoubtedly great and rise above, as in the case with last year's "Frances Ha," but with over-saturation, it just gets easier to forget and not necessarily forgive. Much to my delight, however, Susanna Fogel's "Life Partners" is a small-scale and genuinely sweet comedy about two 20-something women and their platonic friendship.
Published Oct. 3, 2014
It seems inevitable that comparisons will be made between Tayla Lavie's superb dark comedy "Zero Motivation" and films such as Robert Altman's 1970 classic "M.A.S.H.," which depicted the antics of a Korean War-era outpost. This comparison makes sense, considering both films center on characters that utilize hi-jinks and clash with one another to keep their sanity during the time of war that lurks in the background.
Published Oct. 1, 2014
"Life is Easy With Eyes Closed," which has won 6 Goya awards (which is the Spanish equivalence to the Oscars) may be a wee-bit predictable, but as mentioned before, like in any road film, sometimes the journey is more important than the destination, which itself is heartwarmingly satisfying to the highest degree.
Published Oct. 1, 2014
The Union Theatre, on the second floor of UW-Milwaukee's Student Union, 2200 E. Kenwood Blvd., has a full slate of films on its October schedule that shouldn't be missed.
Published Sept. 28, 2014
Despite losing its pace near the end, "Stray Dog" is a fascinating documentary and quite the accomplishment for Debra Granik, who goes beyond making just a simple portrait of an ordinary man.
Published Sept. 28, 2014
Despite its flaws, the Irish comedy "Life's A Breeze" has a heart the size of a mattress. It has good intentions to delight rather than displease. It's not as satisfying as, say, finding a million Euros stuffed inside of a mattress, but I'll settle nonetheless.
Published Sept. 22, 2014
This past Saturday, Sept. 20, a friend and I deemed ourselves "urban explorers" for the day. We hopped onto the green line (a proper urban adventure isn't complete without some form of public transportation, right?), ventured from the East Side to Downtown where we visited various landmarks that had their doors wide open for the general public as part of Doors Open Milwaukee.