I can think of a couple films off the top of my head that end up taking this route: A woman, usually the film’s protagonist, unexpectedly finds out she’s pregnant and she seriously considers having an abortion (for about a few minutes in the film, usually). But, instead, she decides to go through with the pregnancy by the end of the film. This display of morality is supposed to make the audiences feel all warm and fuzzy inside, making us root and emotionally melt for the protagonist.
Having the topic of abortion in a film, especially a comedy, is a risky move simply because it's never been done before so matter-of-factly, to my knowledge at least. That was until I saw Gillian Robespierre's feature film debut "Obvious Child," which premiered earlier this year at the Sundance Film Festival and is now playing at the Downer Theatre.
The film – with the help of Robespierre’s unabashed writing and directing, and an endearing and absolutely hilarious performance by Jenny Slate ("Parks & Recreation," "The Kroll Show") – takes those "risky" expectations and tosses them out of the window. Even by not playing it safe, the film solidly delivers as a heartwarming comedy that’s at times raunchy and awkward in all the right and amusing ways, and at other times, sweet and genuinely thoughtful.
Slate is Donna Stern, a directionless, 20-something stand-up comic who routinely performs at a Brooklyn dive bar. I’d use "perform" lightly, because she actually just stands in front of the crowd and talks about her life; mostly about her sex life, her Jewish looks and daily panty stains. She even manages to throw in a fart joke for good measure. Talking about her sex life so openly and candidly to a room full of strangers doesn’t sit well with her boyfriend, who later tells Donna in the bar’s unisex bathroom that he’s having an affair with her best friend.
This news, of course, devastates her, leading to an all-night drinking binge inside of her tiny apartment and a mental breakdown making her appear more maniacal than anything else. Oh, and not only did her boyfriend dump her, she also loses her job at an independent bargain bookstore.
Shortly after a disastrous and drunken stand-up routine that ventures into quips about the Holocaust, Donna meets Max (Jake Lacy), a straight-laced business graduate student who looks like he doesn’t belong anywhere close to the dive, hipster-friendly bar that Donna and her gay friend Joey (Gabe Liedman) frequent. Introducing herself by spitting out the hilarious and nonsensical line, "You’re really lasering into me with your pee pee missiles," Donna charms Max into getting sloppy drunk with her.
They seem like they would be polar opposites, but they click, laughing at one another after he accidentally farts in her face while they both urinate against a building and amusing each other by dancing in their underwear inside of his apartment. By the end of the night, of course, they have sex, an act that sets the rest of the film in motion when Donna unexpectedly becomes pregnant.
She realizes that having a baby at this point in her life would lead to disastrous results; she doesn’t nearly have enough money to support a child, let alone that she isn’t nearly as emotionally ready to go through with the pregnancy. She decides the best option would be to have an abortion – on Valentine’s Day of all days – but withholds from telling Max while she struggles to handle the messiness of life.
"Obvious Child," which is adapted from Robespierre’s 2009 short film of the same title, manages to find just the right balance of comedic and dramatic tone. Robespierre infuses the film with a heartfelt feel that’s elevated by her naturalistic sensibilities as a writer and director. As the film triggers a small shift from sweetness to seriousness in the third act, it confirms Robespierre’s ability to balance the comedy with the drama with ease.
Besides effortlessly balancing the tone, Robespierre also did an exceptional job establishing Donna’s relations with the various people in her life, including her mother (Polly Draper) who wants Donna to put her SAT scores to good use, her supportive father (Richard Kind), her roommate Nellie (Gaby Hoffman) and, of course, Max. There’s no doubt that this is an impressively strong feature debut for a writer and director that’s going to be hard to ignore down the road.
Jenny Slate’s charming and charismatic performance also elevates the film. Besides her most obvious talent of being unique and hilarious, she’s even more surprising during the quieter, dramatic moments later on in the third act.
Jake Lacy – best known for his role as Pete in NBC’s "The Office" – is especially good as Max, a nice guy who not only pee farts, but also tries hard to forge a relationship with Donna by asking her out, amusingly oblivious to the news that is being kept from him and her weariness of taking things any further. Hoffman, who recently had a role in this past season of HBO’s "Girls," is unusually normal in this as Nellie, who coaches her along. David Cross even makes a brief, creepy appearance as a fellow comedian who invites Donna over to his pad to "talk," but he has another agenda in mind.
While the film is billed as an abortion comedy, and while there are still quite a few laughs, the topic of abortion is handled with honesty and straight-forwardness. Robespierre doesn’t downplay the emotional ramifications, as abortion clearly isn’t a funny subject matter, even when it’s a subject of a comedy. It’s also a refreshing take because she also doesn’t allow the characters tip toe around it as if it’s some sort of a Satanist moral taboo, like in "Knocked Up," where Jonah Hill’s character couldn’t even say the word aloud, instead having to attempt to improvise a rhyming word. While many films would rather shy away from it, "Obvious Child" does not.
Some will probably dislike "Obvious Child," as seen by a walkout and two older women making it known to all of those around them how much they hated it after the screening. I felt the complete opposite: I feel that it should be celebrated that "Obvious Child" exists. We need more films just like this; films that are told not only from the under-served female perspective, but also have a lot of wit, genuine heart, and the daring fearlessness to be authentic and outside of the box when dealing with a controversial subject.
No Talkbacks for this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Colton Dunham
Published Nov. 13, 2014
UW-Milwaukee's Klotsche Center has banned sleeveless shirts because toned college students wearing them intimidate students who are new to college fitness.
Published Nov. 7, 2014
For fans of anything popular culture -- from comics, movies, games, television and celebrities -- Awesome Con is a place to embrace the potpourri of geeky awesomeness. The convention, which touts itself as an up-and-coming Comic-Con of sorts, was set to take place in Milwaukee at the Wisconsin Center from Nov. 21-23, but faced with a set of logistical challenges, the con was cancelled this past Wednesday, just weeks away.
Published Nov. 6, 2014
I've accepted the fact that people love to hate Lena Dunham. Now, to add to this ever-so-growing list of relentlessness, you might've read this online in the past couple of days: Dunham is a sex offender. Yes, rub those eyes and read again. But, come on, is she really? Nope.
Published Nov. 3, 2014
Last spring, Martin Kaszubowski and Scott Cary graduated from UW-Milwaukee's highly regarded film program with a load of ambition. They've made the leap that most students don't dare to take immediately following college: co-writing, directing and producing a feature-length film with little to no money to back them up. Recently, they launched a Kickstarter campaign for the film, titled "Christopher Darling."
Published Oct. 31, 2014
After many rewrites, "The Surface" moved into production last summer that was made up almost entirely of a Milwaukee-based crew and a cast who have certainly seen better gigs. The film, as it turns out, is one that should sink because of its absurdly inept screenplay that could've used a few more rewrites (and by rewrites, I don't mean a few kinks to sort out. I mean an entirely new screenplay altogether).
Published Oct. 27, 2014
Milwaukee's Altered Five is a quintet that knows a few a things about the blues -- a genre that, despite its name, often makes people feel good thanks to its soulful vibe. Over the last year, the band often put a little groove to its step when treading familiar turf with its own soulful, lyrical twist, especially on its latest album, "Cryin' Mercy."
Published Oct. 25, 2014
As I walked through the large wooden door entrance, the aroma inside of Pizza Man on 2597 N. Downer Ave. was so intoxicating that it made my stomach quiver. This smell of Italian bliss, of course, stayed with me throughout my visit. Near the bar stood Tony Menzel, a waiter who has worked at Pizza Man since it re-opened in the summer of 2013 following a devastating fire.
Published Oct. 25, 2014
Two nights this month, Paranormal Investigators Milwaukee hosts two guided investigation tours for the general public at the Chudnow Museum of Yesteryear, which is located on 839 N. 11th St. in Milwaukee and at the Brumder Mansion, 3046 W. Wisconsin Ave., on Friday, Oct. 31.
Published Oct. 11, 2014
It's a tough act to balance comedy and drama ... especially if you're balancing themes of suicide and familial estrangement with humor and heart. Director Craig Johnson ("True Adolescents") finds just the right balance for the dramedy "The Skeleton Twins," mixing heartache with hilarity, and giving "Saturday Night Live" alums Kristen Wiig and Bill Hader time to flex their dramatic muscles as estranged suicidal siblings who reunite and find commonality.
Published Oct. 10, 2014
School by school, 4th through 6th grade students, teachers and chaperones filed into the theatre and took their seats in the main house of the Oriental Theatre, waiting to be taken away by the beautifully crafted Spanish-language animated film "AninA." The screening was held as part of Milwaukee Film's education screenings during the film festival.