In the adventures of Robin Hood, it is the capricious archer who is the center of all legends, and around him swirl the Merry Men (Little John and Will Scarlett) and the evil of Prince John and the Sheriff of Nottingham and Maid Marian, whom Robin loves.
There is a way to look at this legendary story, however, through the eyes of a woman, and you can find a story with enough twists and turns to capture and hold your imagination.
That’s the case with "A Lady in Waiting," the production being staged by Theatre RED which opened Thursday night at the Soulstice Theatre and runs through Aug. 23. The play is an adaptation of the traditional story by local playwright Liz Shipe.
The story opens with Robin Hood (Zach Thomas Woods) at the edge of his beheading for crimes of murder and thievery. But before the axe can fall, we are moved in flashback to the time when this story began.
It is told by Aria, the handmaiden to Maid Marian (played by Shipe), and it is a bravura performance by Kelly Doherty, who with great good humor and grace takes us from the combativeness of her Scottish lady to the gathering of the Merry Men to the first tentative steps toward love between Robin and Marian in Sherwood Forest.
Doherty has a special ability to be funny, with a comedic timing that is enviable, and then to become stern in moments of high drama. She is a joy to behold on stage and stands out in a staging that features a number of good performances.
Jake Lesh plays the callow and treacherous Prince John with a precious air capturing all that is trouble in Nottingham. Meanwhile, Woods gives us a Robin Hood who is less crusading philanthropist and more cherubic and troubled warrior, conflicted about his place in the world.
Robin and his men, however, all take a back seat to the trials and travails of the two women, who are determined to flee to the Holy Land to rescue King Richard from prison. Their quest is the heart and soul of this story.
Shipe’s play is a wonderful nifty idea and sparkles early on with an earnest telling of a familiar story that provides a glimpse into the lives of characters we have heard of but don’t know much about.
She has a lovely way with the language, mixing the stilted phrasing of medieval English with a more informal style best used to provide some of the abundant humor in the first act. The smiles from the audience at the intermission were eloquent testimony to the joyful bounce of what they had seen so far.
But the second act became a tortuous journey through what were surprising developments, along with the long-winded speeches needed to explain what was happening. We had mistaken identities, mistaken motives, mistaken couplings, mistaken swordplay and mistaken deaths.
It all became a little too much.
What happened, I think, was that a play, telling an interesting and fun tale, suddenly began to take itself too seriously. As character after character died, they all had long and maudlin speeches about how sorry they were or how much they loved Robin or how anxious they were to join dead relatives.
Here we were jaunting along, enjoying the repartee, and suddenly we were asked to almost weep over the Hallmark Hall of Fame moments that landed like a giant anchor on the pace of the play.
Director Christopher Elst is an experienced hand, and he might well have taken Shipe aside and suggested that some judicious cutting of the script might be appropriate. With a 15-minute intermission, the play came in at two and a half hours. With songs that did nothing to move the story and the never-ending throes of lingering death, I kept waiting for the signal to bring the lights up and send us home.
This play has a future life, I’m sure, but Shipe needs to find a good dramaturg who can help keep the pedal to the floor and take her foot off the brake.
Mr. Begel is spot on when describing Kelly Dohertys performance. I can imagine her character played by a number of other individuals, but Dohertys performance brings something that would be quite good and funny to amazing and hilarious. And I do mean hilarious. At times the humor was very witty eliciting chuckles from the audience, and at other times the cast commanded us to laugh at times almost uncontrollably. More than once I had a tear in my eye because the humor was so good. Fortunately for me, the people around me were doing the same.
Where however, I take issue with this review is in Mr. Begels assessment of the second half. The notion that the play began to take itself too seriously couldnt be further from the truth, and, in my opinion edges on insulting to the playwright. It certainly does take a turn in tone, however in paying attention to the plot that was to be expected. We were asked to weep at times, and more than a few people in my section rose to that. The juxtaposition between the almost jovial first half and the serious and emotional (but still very witty and funny) second half was expertly executed by everyone on stage. The whole cast deserves applause for being able to make the switch so convincing authentic.
In hindsight, perhaps a speech or two could have been condensed slightly, but for Mr. Begel to say it was tortuous, and to suggest that playwright should have been taken aside is puzzling, as everyone that I spoke with after the show couldnt sing enough praise, no one mentioned that so-and-so should have cut a sentence out. And further on waiting to be sent home more than a few people stayed though the impromptu meet-and-greet with the cast and staff after the show. I find it hard to believe anyone was rushing to leave.
The play was very well written, very well executed, delivered the right amount of laughter and emotion throughout. My suggestion would be for Mr. Begel to see it again in a week and leave his critic hat at home.
1 comment about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Dave Begel
Published Dec. 20, 2014
Theatre Unchained has had a couple of great productions this season but their Christmas offering doesn't come close to matching what they have done. It's a story that's trite, confusing and doesn't belong in anyone's Christmas stocking.
Published Dec. 19, 2014
All In Productions is a new theater company that made its debut with a wonderful production of "The Last 5 Years." The musical is a romantic and intelligent story of a relationship, with one side told from the end to the the beginning and the other side telling the story in reverse
Published Dec. 18, 2014
The latest application for Silk Exotic to open a strip club in Walker's Point has been turned down again. But there is plenty of evidence that the committee had already made the decision before the public hearing began. This battle is not over.
Published Dec. 16, 2014
How do you explain why a hot, successful team like the Green Bay Packers lose to the Buffalo Bills when there is so much at stake? It's a complicated answer, but it isn't just statistics or even motivation that seem to be the problem. A loss like that may not even be avoidable at some point.
Published Dec. 14, 2014
The sixth edition of "Who Killed Santa" by the Umbrella Group has become a highlight of the holiday season in Milwaukee. But unlike almost all the other traditions, this one not only takes the gloves off, it never even had any gloves. If you like your humor both funny and raunchy, this show is just for you.
Published Dec. 13, 2014
A 50-year-old play about race seems like a perfect fit for the discussions raging across American today. And while the play has lessons, they get lost in too many amateur moments in the production by World's Stage Theatre Company.
Published Dec. 11, 2014
"A Christmas Carol" is a story well over 110 years old but it still has a magic and the MilwaukeeRep manages to find new pieces to keep the audience delighted. It is running for the 39th consecutive year at The gorgeous Pabst Theater.
Published Dec. 11, 2014
Cases in New York, Ferguson and Cleveland are getting a whole lot more press than the case of Dontre Hamilton here in Milwaukee, It sure seems like his story deserves to be right up there with the others.
Published Dec. 10, 2014
This is the season when thousands of people try to do something special for those less fortunate. There are lots of good causes out there, but a tiny South Side church runs programs for the homeless and it has a very special fundraiser coming up.
Published Dec. 9, 2014
Marquette has always had a pretty good basketball program but there is something about the whole thing that doesn't inspire love. As a matter of fact, in some quarters, it's very easy to hate the Golden Eagles.