There are few things in the world I dislike more than when I feel I am being manipulated or when I am stuck in the middle of something designed to shock for shock’s sake.
That’s the feeling I walked away with after opening night of a solid production of "Oleanna" at Alchemist Theatre. In 1992, the play was David Mamet's stab to stake out a position on the furious national debate about sexual exploitation. The play was written on the heels of the Congressional hearings in the Anita Hill-Clarence Thomas debate.
In the world of theater, shock and surprise need to come from the play and the actors, not from production subterfuge and gimmicks. But that’s what happened Thursday night.
The story is about a college professor and his student. He is a righteous pedant. She is clueless and has come to his office to ask for understanding and beg for help. Erin Eggers, who made her directorial debut with this production, took Mamet’s student Carol and cast it with a man, actor Ben Parman.
I don’t know if the decision would have worked or not, but I will say that in her notes, Eggers says that she purposely did not disclose the casting decision so that the audience could focus on the words in the play.
Somebody needed to tell her that if she really didn’t want it to be an issue, she should not have kept it a secret. When you spring it on an audience moments before the curtain goes up, you allow no time to deal with the shock, and a great deal of the words are lost.
Let me give an example, which I hope she reads.
The wonderful Illinois Shakespeare Festival has done several plays with all men in the cast. The motivation is that, in Shakespeare’s day, there were no women actors. But they didn’t spring the surprise on the audience. They got it out of the way in advance so that the play was the thing.
So right off the bat, I felt manipulated, that this casting decision was done for shock value despite protestations to the contrary. If she didn’t want to shock people, she would have revealed the casting well in advance.
Eggers calls her casting "gender fluidity." But this wasn’t fluid gender. This changed the play.
The way Mamet wrote it, the story is about a man and a woman. In this production, it’s about a man and a man who is clearly a gay man. He even complains about "doubtful sexuality" and overcoming "sexual prejudice" to get into college. When first we see him, he’s wearing silver sparkling flats and white pedal pushers with zippered sides.
That adds a pretty important and artificial layer to Mamet’s play. All of a sudden, we have a straight man with a wife and a son trapped in a room with a young man of "doubtful sexuality."
Talk about obscuring the point of the play. And it’s really a shame because this is really quite a play. I saw it in New York about five years ago, and it’s moving and tough and raw and exposes the issues of power and dominance.
If Eggers had been upfront about this whole thing, it would have been much easier to ride the flow of Mamet’s words. There is so much interesting content in this play that it’s a shame that more seasoned heads didn’t put the brakes on Eggers.
Everything else about this production was really pretty good. There were minor details that might be fixed, but generally the acting and staging was just fine. But the whole thing got lost in a cloud of resentment, shock and wonder.
No Talkbacks for this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Dave Begel
Published April 18, 2015
The adaptation of the P. G. Wodehouse books about the stiff upper lip butler and his boss, Bertie Wooster, comes alive at Milwaukee Chamber Theatre. It's a night filled with laughter and more laughter.
Published April 16, 2015
Nobody expected the Milwaukee Bucks to be in the playoffs this year, but they surprised the world by being the sixth seed in the Eastern Conference. The Bucks open the playoffs against the Chicago Bulls Saturday night.
Published April 16, 2015
Sheriff David Clarke is the darling of the far right and he is a favorite of the Fox News Network. But amidst all the bluster there are some truths to be discovered when he talks about the epidemic of black violence in Milwaukee.
Published April 15, 2015
I recently began walking with a cane. And I had to park near the Milwaukee Public Market. I parked at one end of the block and had to drag myself all the way to the other end.
Published April 14, 2015
Jordan Spieth and Rory McIlroy are set to take over the big rivalry that the PGA Tour needs to keep interest up. The two are likely to become the next Tiger vs, Phil or the next Jack vs. Arnie. And it will be god for golf.
Published April 13, 2015
"Luchadora" is a production commissioned by First Stage, and it's an amazing production - full of joys and important messages to young women. Written by UWM professor Alvaro Saar Rios, it's a production that every young woman, aunt, uncle and parent should see.
Published April 12, 2015
A frothy comedy by Peter Schaffer is a delight at Renaissance Theaterworks. For two hours it's a great character study filled with laughs. But a contrived ending makes the evening end on a note that is far less funny.
Published April 11, 2015
The question of evolution versus creationism is at the heart of "Ten Questions to Ask Your Biology Teacher About Evolution" at Next Act. The most refreshing part of this production is that it values each side of the argument.
Published April 9, 2015
Just one string of shootings last weekend raises a whole bunch of questions about what's happening in the black community in Milwaukee. It also raises questions about what the rest of the city thinks about the violence.
Published April 7, 2015
In the overwhelming joy about the Badgers victory over Kentucky, there were a few threads that claimed it was silly to root while so much serious stuff was going on in the world. The people filling social media with such thoughts totally missed the point.