Milwaukee, which basket do you put your eggs in?
In the past, most people when deciding where to dine out would pick up the local paper or a magazine and peruse the latest restaurant reviews.
Today, the Internet has really changed the scope of things and how people get their information. There are dozens of food sites, blogs and apps but, I'm not so sure it's for the better.
The point is this; should you trust someone who eats, drinks and dines for a living or a self appointed "foodie expert?" (This question posed, I'll admit, by an amateur writer.)
Where do you get your information from? Friends? Family? The Internet? A local magazine? The newspaper?
Which is mightier, the pen or the blog?
My wife and I have become more thoughtful about our eating out decisions for financial reasons. We tend to frequent our favorite close to home restaurants that we know constantly provide good food and service. (VIA on Downer)
Aside form that, we tend to trust certain friends recommendations. That got us to try Sweet Water on 2nd Ave.
Theater season is beginning, which means we'll be re-looking at the restaurants in the 3rd Ward. Swig and The Wicked Hop were favorites last season, but new The Benelux. is certainly in the mix.
I use a combination of traditional reviews, blogs, and yelp. I also frequent a couple of messagboards. If a restaurant has 100 good to excellent reviews on Yelp, chances are they are doing something right. If they have 3 reviews I am less inclined to trust them.
The problem with newspaper critics is that you are only getting the perspective of one person. With that perspective comes biases. Dennis Getto was the mot important critic the last quarter century in Wisconsin but he had certain things that he was prone to bitch about that were more of a personal preference than a reflection on how the food tasted. The other issue with reviewers is that many restaurants know what the food critic looks like so they are likely getting the absolute best in service and food.
I think you need to be more skeptical of bloggers, yelp, and other non-professional reviews but it seems like Chefs would like to have you completely ignore them. There seems to be something disingenuous about some of these chefs that would like to completely dismiss the opinions of hundreds of people and want us to only trust a handful of food professionals.
So when I am visiting a new restaurant or planning some vacation dinners, I'll look at as many sources as possible.
2 comments about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Jason Gorman
Published June 29, 2012
Rehorst has been producing some fantastic local spirits for quite some time. Jason Gorman recently met with founder Guy Rehorst to shake, stir and pick his brain about his passion.
Published June 22, 2012
In case you missed it, Tory Miller - Madison chef, restaurateur and lover of all culinary things Wisconsin - brought home the James Beard Award for Best Chef of the Midwest region this year. Jason Gorman recently had the chance to catch up with him and asked him to share some of his insight.
Published June 4, 2012
Last year I was a featured guest chef at an amazing dinner pairing chefs with the next generation of Wisconsin cheese makers and I had the pleasure of meeting LaClare Farms' award-winning cheese maker Katie Hedrich. I recently caught up with Katie to ask her about all things in the world of cheese.
Published May 12, 2012
One of the remarkable things about Nate is not only his genuine love of wine, but he is always engaged in the constant pursuit of enlightenment, not for himself but to share with others. Jason Gorman recently had some time to sit and ask him about his perspective on all things wine.
Published May 2, 2012
I met director and creator of "Wisconsin Foodie" Arthur Ircink several years ago and was fortunate enough to work with him in the first season of the show. I recently caught up with him to ask him about his ideas, inspirations and some recommendations.
Published April 12, 2012
There are so many different ways to cook asparagus. Most people enjoy grilling, sauteing or even topping it with a poached egg. Well, I thought you might enjoy a Wisconsin-inspired recipe on what to do with asparagus, as the market season is about to begin.
Published April 2, 2012
It seems spring hasn't fully committed yet, but we are starting to see some local spring green garlic. Pinehold Gardens, run by farmers David Kozlowski and Sandra Raduenzis, is already harvesting some. Treat yourself to a spring-inspired soup with a special recipe featuring this flavorful ingredient.
Published March 27, 2012
Barry Estabrook is a two-time winner of the prestigious James Beard Foundation Awards for food writing. His first, for a gourmet feature about labor abuses in Florida's tomato fields, led to his acclaimed book "Tomatoland," about how industrial agriculture has ruined one of America's favorite foods.
Published March 13, 2012
I'll admit it: I have a sweet tooth, much to my chagrin. This past week I was grocery shopping, picking up some basics and longing for the markets to start up again, when behold - I stumbled upon a new product that just came out: WhoNu cookies!
Published Feb. 27, 2012
This week I'd like to pose a question: When dining out, if there is something you don't care for, do you tell your server? Do you give the restaurant a chance to reconcile the situation?