Dear Wall Street Journal,
It is nice to see the Journal taking an interest in Milwaukee's doings again; it has been more than a decade since, for example, you elite Manhattanites writing for the nation's foremost financial newspaper deigned to endorse candidates for the Milwaukee school board, in elections where perhaps a couple thousand people even voted. That was such a great use of your time and resources.
(These endorsements are all ably documented in Milwaukee journalist Barbara Miner’s book Lessons from the Heartland.)
I write specifically in response to the op-ed published last week written by C. J. Szafir "The Vacant School Buildings That Made Milwaukee Infamous" (because there's nothing Milwaukeeans like better than a Schlitz joke!), about the Milwaukee Public Schools and certain conservative schemers' plans for things that don't belong to them. It's part of a long-running attempt to subvert local control and force MPS to sell properties it is using, or planning to use, to outside groups.
I write today not just because I disagree with the thrust of Szafir's argument (paraphrasing: "MPS ought to just do whatever I want, darn it!"), but because Szafir gets so many basic facts wrong or leaves basic facts out, it is impossible to take him seriously.
(It is equally impossible to take Szafir seriously because, while he does not directly work for St. Marcus Lutheran School – the school he advocates should have been given an MPS building to operate in – his salary is paid by the same right-wing foundations that fund St. Marcus and many other schools in the Milwaukee Parental Choice Program. Of course he supports the same things they do.)
For example, Szafir gets things like the enrollment at MPS wrong, saying about 71,000 students rather than the actual number of nearly 78,500, a difference of 10 percent (and an increase over last year). If the Wall Street Journal cannot be bothered to check these most basic facts, how can we trust anything else it prints in its op-eds?
And Szafir writes that the empty building that St. Marcus wished to purchase, but couldn't – the people who owned that building had the temerity to sell it to someone else because free market! – is "conveniently located on the same block as [St. Marcus's] main campus." This is so false it's not even funny. Google maps tells me the buildings are almost a mile a part.
And since Szafir is on record, getting this fact right before your readers are now clearly left to question his motives – is this an honest mistake or a "mistake" that just happens to make St. Marcus look like that much more the innocent victim?
Szafir also repeatedly tells your readers that schools like St. Marcus are "high performing." He does that without offering a meaningful comparison of performance data, even though he gleefully cherry-picks some statistics about MPS to show that the public schools are failing. When he writes that MPS has only 16 percent of its 4th graders scoring proficient or above in reading, he picks a low statistic just because he can, ignoring grades that score better and not mentioning math at all, where 24 percent of MPS 4th graders score proficient or advanced.
I can do the same kind of cherry-picking for St. Marcus. Only 18 percent of its 3rd graders score proficient or better in reading, according to state data, which is not quantitatively much different from MPS's 4th graders, is it?
St. Marcus's 6th grade is worse – only 9 percent are proficient or better. By Szafir's standards, there's no way that's "high performing." Indeed, it is probably a "crisis" – the label he reserves for MPS. In fact, if you look at voucher schools as a whole, they underperform MPS more often than not.
Further, since the MPS school planned for the building in question to be an International Baccalaureate Middle Years Program, the better comparison is not MPS as a whole, but the district's other IB MYP: Wedgewood Park. There, 28 percent of 6th graders are proficient or advanced in reading, and 55 percent in math – a better number than the state as a whole and far, far better than any of St. Marcus' 6th grade stats.
(Another parenthetical: Wisconsin's percentage of students proficient or better in reading, overall statewide, is only 37 percent – 34 percent in just 4th grade – in case you were thinking that "proficient" were the kind of thing half or more of a state's students ought to be scoring. This is because Wisconsin, like other states, is using a bad reading of NAEP standards to set its proficiency levels.)
Szafir also offers your readers a conservative's-eye summary of 24 years of the Milwaukee voucher program, with those poor voucher schools always the victim (never the children of schools that crash and burn far worse than any MPS school ever could).
He concludes that history with a bold lie about "they" – "teachers unions, state bureaucrats and the far left":
"Now they are trying to block schools in the choice program from expanding," he says.
As if unions and bureaucrats have literally invaded these schools' boards of directors and voted down any attempt to expand them. In fact, what Szafir has his knickers twisted about is that one building that MPS sold to someone other than St. Marcus.
Indeed, MPS offered to sell St. Marcus two other buildings closer to the "main campus," and a third not much farther away. If the union thugs and gummint bureaucrats are really trying to stop St. Marcus from expanding, offering to sell it space is a really lousy way to do it.
In short, what Szafir has offered in your pages, dear Wall Street Journal, is an error-riddled piece of propaganda designed to elicit sympathy for a single school – a low-performing (but private!) school throwing a fit because it didn't get what it wanted for Christmas. This is a bad way to make public policy, and a worse way to treat your readership.
Jay Bullock, Milwaukee
and actually the buildings are .7 miles apart. So not "almost a mile" closer to a half mile
You should be happy that it didn't go to St. Marcus since Milwaukee got that sweet deal of selling it for $2 million and renting half of it back at $4 million. Oh wait that's not a good deal at all! Explain that math to me. St. Marcus has done excellent work in the community and I get it that your bitter at them for taking that school choice money MPS would've blown on awful deals like this, but get over it since you're always claiming it's about the children.
3 comments about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Jay Bullock
Published June 30, 2015
The takeover plan, Jay Bullock has realized, amounts to a rerun of the Milwaukee school board elections of the 1990s, when humdrum local off-year elections suddenly drew the spotlight of national media and the checkbooks of major conservative organizations around the country.
Published June 16, 2015
On "The Sopranos," Edie Falco's Carmela stresses about a house she helped build with cheap insufficient lumber. This happens on a fictional TV show, sure. But there's a lesson in there: Don't do things on the cheap just because you think you know better and can get away with it. That lesson is lost on Wisconsin's Republican leadership and legislators, unfortunately, as they pursue an explicit policy of doing just that: trying to do things on the cheap.
Published May 26, 2015
Last week, Wisconsin's Joint Finance Committee passed a 29-page Republican-penned omnibus education funding package, which includes so many terrible provisions it's hard to know where to begin.
Published May 18, 2015
I'm also a teacher in the Milwaukee Public Schools, so for me, the most important topic of any campaign, even for alderman, is education. You can imagine, then, that Ald. Tony Zielinski's surprise proposal last week, which would stop the City of Milwaukee from opening new charter schools, was of interest to me. I like this plan, though the timing seems suspicious.
Published May 12, 2015
There is nothing wrong with being hopeful and keeping your fingers crossed as you try something new. But when hope and magical thinking become not merely your attitude but the entire rationale behind your actions, you should be prepared to be disappointed. After all, magic is not real. Only reality is real, and as Stephen Colbert once sagely observed, reality has a well-known liberal bias.
Published May 5, 2015
I teach high school, so this time of year I hear a lot about prom. This year, in particular, I've about had it with prom. Not because of the tiresome campaigning for prom queen or the incessant classroom distraction, but because it seems now more than any time in recent memory prom has taken destructive cultural influences and turned the amplifier knob to 11.
Published April 28, 2015
Last week, the Washington Post issued its annual ranking of the best high schools in every state around the country. The Milwaukee Public Schools, with six high schools making the cut, including the top two spots in Wisconsin and three of the top 10. But here's a thing: Two of the schools on the Washington Post's list also made a different list, the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction's list of the worst schools in the state.
Published April 21, 2015
Based on older data, MPS had the highest suspension rate in the country for African American high school students. Is it because white teachers (like me) are racist? I have been asked this before, casually in conversation with friends or acquaintances and seriously by people trying to get to the root of the problem - even by a fellow OnMilwaukee.com columnist worried that MPS teachers might be setting their expectations too low. I tend to answer no.
Published April 14, 2015
We're well into our second generation of students who have no sense of loyalty or school pride, our second generation of alumni who are leaving the system with no particular connection to their high schools. These young men and women will be of little use in any kind of alumni engagement scheme unless something changes in this city and district to help students -- or force students -- to be more loyal to their schools.
Published April 7, 2015
Today is election day in Wisconsin. Non-partisan elections like today's, especially here in Milwaukee, are usually low-turnout affairs, with few candidates, few ads or debates, and few big issues on the table for argument or discussion. This year is feels like there's been even less of that than usual, since of five school board races on the ballot, three candidates -- including the citywide candidate, Terry Falk -- have no opponent at all.