My wife - who is on the Historic Third Ward executive committee, is a former business improvement district director and co-founder of Lela - and I were discussing the Sydney HIH building recently. And, she made a very Austin-type comment. Milwaukee needs more weird. So, of course, I told her to blog her thoughts. Here they are.
Why Weird Works
by Stephanie Sherman
Milwaukee is home to beautiful architecture, rich history and new cutting edge development and art. We also have our share of weird; the Bronze Fonz, that car ("God Mobile") that drives on Downtown covered in opinions, deceased icons like Dick Bacon and Pepperoni Cannoli Guy, and, one could even argue for Nyjer Morgan.
And, with all of its charm and pending death sentence, the Sydney HIH building is weird and we should embrace it.
Sydney HIH has become something people talk about, tell urban legends about and brag about being a part of. Why tear it down? I understand the City's desire to clear the way for something new. But how about embracing it and making it truly art? It's time for more Milwaukee leaders to take risks.
It was the home of artists, musicians and so much more. Now, could it, the building itself, become public art? Think something better than "plop art" like the Beasties or temporary sculptures. Let's make it a formal tribute to what it created. Fill it with sand if it is uninhabitable. Cover it in color. Let's let artist Reggie Baylor cover it once again with bold color!
I understand the desire to clear the way for a large, pinnacle development. And I understand that no developer is interested in purchasing and redeveloping the building given its uninhabitable condition. So, develop around it.
This is Milwaukee. Every day tourists stop in amazement at the beauty of the old architecture in our Downtown. We need every last bit of the past. It is our competitive edge. It is what makes us better than other cities.
I saw the owner of Zappos speak several years ago on what makes his company successful. Certainly great service, an excellent product were mentioned. But, he also mentioned the "weird factor."
Weird works for Milwaukee. Let's not lose out on the chance to preserve weird. It's time for more color and beauty to thrive as parts of our Downtown landscape.
Stephanie Sherman is co-founder of Lela boutique, an economic development professional and much more.
No, in all likelihood we won't get a new building with just as much history or appeal as the one that currently stands. What will likely rise is a cheaply constructed, mundane structure that will be lucky to last 40 years. Look no further than the ultra-cheap A-loft next door. This is typical of what bottom line developers are building all over the country.
Like it or not, the Sidney Hih is unique. It was built well and could easily be saved, it just takes money. It's a building that makes Milwaukee uniquely Milwaukee and not Anywhere, USA. It's also the potential corner stone for a vibrant future street. We rarely build storefronts at the scale that you see in the multiple buildings strung together. Those facades could easily be remade into inviting restaurants, bars, and cafes --- much like our most cherished pedestrian streets --- Third St, Brady St, Milwaukee St, etc. Which all happen to be historic, small scale, with a patina that only time can generate.
Lastly, there's no argument more fundamentally stupid than "if you don't like it, why don't you just move." Please, grow up. Thank goodness there are many people in this city making it what they want.
There's not development in the wings. There is absolutely no reason for another vacant surface lot. Learn from your past, Milwaukee...
The Sydney Hih is an eye sore and is falling apart. Plow it away. We'll build another building that will have just as much history in time. As it stands, we have a bunch of tiny vacant buildings that remind us of our frontier & industrial history. It's not worth keeping them all. If I want to show my kid what Milwaukee was like in the 1900s, I can just drive down to the 3rd Ward & Walker's Point.
If you want a weird city like Austin, why not just move to Austin?
Huge problem with this city is they tear things down before really thinking it through. Travel europe and cities that have gone through modernization has managed to integrate the existing structures. Here in the USA we simply plow over in the name of progress. Makes me sick. This building can't be replaced. What exactly is the point of tearing it down? Oh yeah, that right, it ruins the view of the new high rise next door. Pathetic Milwaukee.
5 comments about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Jeff Sherman
Published Sept. 1, 2015
Lakefront Brewery's Russ Klisch is currently out of the office healing from hip surgery. Email him, and his out of the office response is exactly what you'd expect from a beer maker. Love it!
Published Aug. 31, 2015
We all need reminders of the importance of keeping the project on pace. So, since it's public record once I submitted it last week, I'm sharing the letter I sent to all members of Milwaukee's Common Council.
Published Aug. 27, 2015
What am I enjoying right now? Other than, of course, my family, faith and friends, the list could get long quickly so I'll keep it to eight. What's on your list? As you think about it, enjoy these.
Published Aug. 19, 2015
It's fun to analyze, pontificate and rank team uniforms and logos. Paul Lukas' latest work on ESPN ranks "uniform attractiveness." Milwaukee falls into his group with two major pro sports teams (NFL, MLB, NBA, NHL). He also does a ranking of the 20 cities with three or more teams.
Published Aug. 12, 2015
To help highlight MMSD Green Luminaries awards, we're focusing on the winners by asking about their practices and new environmental approaches.
Published Aug. 5, 2015
OnMilwaukee.com is once again honored to support Potawatomi Hotel and Casino's Heart of Canal Street program. As a long-time partner and passionate community advocate we're also thrilled to announced that this year we'll help support the Betty Brinn Children's Museum.
Published July 29, 2015
Today, my alma mater - Marquette - helped fuel my fan fire by releasing a new app that is available for free download, thanks to a partnership with Bluechip Athletic Solutions, Inc.
Published July 29, 2015
Children's Hospital of Wisconsin is more than a hospital. It's at the center of an ongoing discussion about health, wellness and access to care for all kids in the state. Today, Peggy Troy talks about the mission, vision, challenges and opportunities at Children's.
Published July 27, 2015
Today I'm writing to ask the members of the state legislature to please vote yes tomorrow for the new Wisconsin arena and entertainment district in Downtown Milwaukee. It's important and vital to our state's long term viability. You should call or email your state representative, too.
Published July 24, 2015
That's right, Downtown Milwaukee may not have a ton of ice cream options but you can order ice cream on demand with #UberIceCream.