An anniversary came and went a few weeks ago and no one seemed to notice – March 26, 1992. It was the day the Milwaukee Brewers shipped a 23-year-old Gary Sheffield to the San Diego Padres for a bag of Bones.
Twenty years ago.
I was 11 when that trade went down, an avid baseball fan. Since the Brewers played in the same division as the Chicago White Sox, I knew a lot about The Crew. As baseball card collector, I knew a lot about the great prospects of that time, of which Sheffield was clearly one.
From afar, I remember being shocked by the deal. Gary Sheffield? For who?
As I got older and read stories as to why he was dealt, I was naturally less surprised. But this recent revitalization of Brewers baseball got me thinking – did that trade set the franchise back during the '90s?
Superficially, it's easy to say yes.
The Brewers went 92-70 in 1992 while Sheffield nearly won the National League Triple Crown, but after that the Brewers went 12 years before finally reaching the .500 mark in 2005. Sheffield went on to have (arguably) a Hall of Fame career.
While its clear by looking at Sheffield's career – and at former Brewers ownership – that he probably wouldn't have signed a long-term deal in Milwaukee even if he liked it here, it is fun to play the "what if" game.
What if a nine-time All-Star, five-time Silver Slugger with a career .292 average and 509 home runs had stayed?
It would've been a sight to see, all those baseballs flying out of County Stadium.
Maybe then the commissioner would've sunk some money into the pitching staff to compliment this ferocious lineup?
In the pre-wildcard era, it's impossible to predict if Sheffield's presence would've resulted in a bunch of winning seasons, but it definitely didn't help that one of that of the best right-handed hitters of the last 20 years was traded away for Ricky Bones, Jose Valentin, Matt Mieske and a killer mustache.
Jim...you should have done more research...Gary Sheffield was a cancer...as a rookie, he criticized the pitching staff for not protecting him...he ripped management for not respecting him...he was upset tht the club moved him from shortstop to third base...the year before he was traded, he accused Harry Dalton for ruining the team,he criticized manager Tom Trebelhorn and owner Bud Selig for forcing him to play hurt. The last straw was when he came to camp in 1992 demanding to be traded. Manager Phil Garner did not want him on the team. That's why he was traded. Many teams did not want him. Sal Bando got what he could get from the Padres. As good as Sheffield was when he wanted to play (yes many called him a selfish player), he caused similar problems with the Padres, Marlins, Yankees and Tigers. Is he Hall of Fame material? Perhaps. But it'll take him a long time to get in...if he ever does get in.
Nah, I'd say it's Sal Bando referring to Paul Molior as "just a DH" and letting him walk after the 92 season as the main culprit.
4 comments about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Jim Owczarski
Published March 5, 2015
Just off 6th Street, near the Iron Horse Hotel, is a small, independent, locally-owned business that saw a hole in the construction and architecture business model and sought to fill it in. But that's just what ScopeBridge does. The man behind it, and his story, make it much more than that.
Published March 4, 2015
The 2014-15 regular season is about over for the Marquette Golden Eagles, and it's been a trying season for first year coach Steve Wojciechowski. But one silver lining is that the young players currently on the roster have been given ample opportunity to show they belong. Have they done it?
Published March 3, 2015
The Milwaukee Brewers are about to begin their spring training schedule, which is the first test of Ryan Braun's repaired thumb. The former National League MVP feels he's healthy for the first time in years, and if he remains so he can return to that elite level of play.
Published March 3, 2015
This latest snow fall made me realize something. I've never called dibs here. I'm not alone. I don't see any Milwaukeeans shoveling out angled parking spots or street parking spots and calling dibs on their handiwork. You know, "dibs." See, this is a real thing that real people do - specifically 90 miles south of us in Chicago. And it's serious business.
Published March 2, 2015
With a month and a half left in the NBA regular season, the Milwaukee Bucks are taking their position within the Eastern Conference playoff race seriously, which means expecting a more dialed in mentality from one another.
Published Feb. 27, 2015
The Milwaukee Bucks launched a "bar network" at the start of the season in an effort get bars in Milwaukee, and in the surrounding suburbs, to turn on their games and create a team atmosphere outside of the BMO Harris Bradley Center. It's worked, for the most part, to connect the team to a new fan base.
Published Feb. 26, 2015
What's old (the Milwaukee Wave in the playoffs) is new again (in the Major Arena Soccer League) and the franchise is searching for a way to meld the two together by winning the organization's seventh indoor soccer championship. That quest begins tonight as the MASL playoffs begin.
Published Feb. 25, 2015
Major League Baseball and the MLB Players Association agreed to enforce rules already on the books (wait, what?) in the hopes of speeding up the game. There will be hemming and hawing from veteran players, but the game does need to move little quicker.
Published Feb. 25, 2015
Four days after the Milwaukee Bucks officially bought him out of a $44 million contract, Larry Sanders opened up at length for the first time since a Dec. 23 interview with OnMilwaukee.com in a video message.
Published Feb. 24, 2015
Having given it an honest effort at several places around Milwaukee, I've come to a judgment: Cucumber is just a taste that doesn't belong in alcohol.