Those walking into "Jack Reacher" with little knowledge of author Lee Childâ€™s popular book series are probably asking themselves "Who is Jack Reacher?" Moviegoers walking out of Tom Cruiseâ€™s latest action romp, on the other hand, are probably asking themselves "What is â€˜Jack Reacherâ€™?"
Because after 130 minutes, itâ€™s hard to walk out of the theater knowing what kind of movie "Jack Reacher" intends to be. Itâ€™s all entertaining, but itâ€™s also a combination of genres and tones that donâ€™t quite sit well together.
Cruise stars as the title character, an army cop turned drifter for justice with a name seemingly made exclusively for action movie fame. He makes his way over to Pittsburgh (I donâ€™t know if they ever say itâ€™s Pittsburgh â€¦ but itâ€™s clearly Pittsburgh) after a sniper guns down five random people in broad daylight with the kind of chilling, matter-of-fact realism thatâ€™s sure to make audience members uncomfortable after recent events. More on that in a second.
All the evidence points toward James Barr, a former military sniper who previously got in trouble in Iraq. Reacher, the officer behind the investigation in Iraq, is convinced of Barrâ€™s guilt and wants to make sure heâ€™s put away for good, either in a prison cell or a casket. After Barrâ€™s attorney (the lovely Rosamund Pike from "An Education") talks him into taking a second look at the evidence, however, Reacher begins to think there might be something more going on than a simple gunman-gone-crazy. The mysterious cars and henchmen following him would seem to validate that theory.
But back to the sniper scene, the uncomfortable elephant in the room. The opening sequence will inevitably trouble many in the audience, more so than the filmmakers couldâ€™ve ever imagined while making the movie. If youâ€™re looking for fun action escapism for the whole family this holiday, "Jack Reacher" doesnâ€™t really qualify anymore.
Before any angry letters get written, however, remember the movie was in production well before this past wave of tragedies, and, to the filmâ€™s credit, it doesnâ€™t fetishize the gun violence. Itâ€™s understandably easy to be reactionary, but unfortunately timed and distasteful are two different things, and "Jack Reacher" easily falls into the first category.
Now, returning to the movie.
"Jack Reacher" seems to be going for a modern day "Dirty Harry" vibe (which features an even more overt tie to a real crime spree â€“ Scorpio as the Zodiac â€“ but nevermind, back to the movie, back to the movie!), featuring a likeable anti-hero with a strong moral code that may not exactly go word-for-word with the law.
But whereas "Dirty Harry" and other movies of its ilk seem confident in its goals, "Jack Reacher" seems less sure of itself. Half of the movie plays like an intense realistic â€™70s paranoia thriller, with cars following our heroes down over street, long periods of time spent talking the investigation and every event a cog in some greater conspiracy.
Even the action is filmed with minimal flash; thereâ€™s never music (slightly disappointing because that rockinâ€™ guitar music in the trailer was awesome), and it all seems refreshingly practical, featuring real stunts. A great car chase near the middle of the film looks like Cruise and company are actually behind the wheel, only adding to the intensity.
The other half of the film plays like a silly â€™80s-style action fantasy, with literally every woman on-screen mesmerized by Reacher, goofy action quips and even goofier action moments, highlighted by a bathroom sequence in which two henchmen do their best impersonation of the Three Stooges, bonking each other on the head with baseball bats and crowbars. The only thing missing is someone going "nyuk, nyuk, nyuk."
Luckily for "Jack Reacher," theyâ€™re slamming two entertaining, well-made brands of action movie together. Itâ€™s amusing to watch Reacher toy around with inept goons and drop tough guy one-liners, especially with Cruise in the lead. Fans of the book may question his casting because of his notoriously short stature, but if youâ€™re really that unnerved by his height, youâ€™re not seeing the forest for the trees. Few actors can deliver an effortless star performance like Cruise, 5â€™ 7" frame be damned.
At the same time, itâ€™s captivating to watch Reacher work his brain like a grown-up version of Encyclopedia Brown, putting the pieces together and barely staying a step ahead of the villain, played by the famous German director/documentarian Werner Herzog in strangely menacing but underutilized turn. Seriously, his henchman, played by Jai Courtney (aka John McClaneâ€™s son in next yearâ€™s "A Good Day to Die Hard"), gets more screentime, and though heâ€™s awesomely sinister too, heâ€™s still just the heavy.
That aside, the slow-building legal mystery is intense and intriguing, even when the deadly conspiracy itself is revealed to be rather ridiculous. Not to spoil anything, but it seems like a lot of effort and dead bodies for a rather mundane goal. However, it works as a means to an end, and that end is watching Cruise be charming and punch bad guys in the face, sometimes with rocks.
Unfortunately, while these two movie styles are fun, they have to sit uncomfortably together in the same film. Itâ€™s hard to get the full comedic entertainment out of the goonsâ€™ bumbling Keystone Cops routine when a few scenes before, we were taken through each of the sniper victims' last moments (one of whom is caring for a child before her final moments).
Each element is handled well â€“ the aforementioned sniper victim sequence is actually quite powerful â€“ but they belong in separate movies where the sequences of action fantasy and serious drama donâ€™t undercut one another.
Youâ€™d think that two entertaining movies for the price of one would be a good thing. In the case of "Jack Reacher," however, itâ€™s reaching just a bit too far. Â
No Talkbacks for this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Matt Mueller
Published Aug. 26, 2016
OnMilwaukee caught up with comedian and "Silicon Valley" star T.J. Miller - while he was in a cornfield, natch - before his upcoming Milwaukee set to chat about working with Steven Spielberg, dying painfully (in movies) and why he loves Appleton.
Published Aug. 26, 2016
This morning, the Bucks and Froedtert & MCW announced they will develop two new health-oriented facilities in Downtown Milwaukee: a new practice and training facility, as well as medical office building and health center for the near North Side.
Published Aug. 25, 2016
Today, County Executive Chris Abele released a statement in the hopes of clarifying Milwaukee County's stance on Pokemon Go. It's fairly identical to what his office and the Parks Department said yesterday - just this time, with a lot of puns.
Published Aug. 24, 2016
The year 2016 has seen some powerful, earth-shattering tiffs in just its eight months, and now our city has a pop cultural beef of its own: Pokemon Go versus the Milwaukee County Parks Department. OnMilwaukee spoke to players and the Parks director for reaction.
Published Aug. 23, 2016
It's never been easier to know about breaking news as it's happening on the ground - and then share that news with others. But the facts can easily become polluted with ever more convincing half-truths, lies and oftentimes simple confusion.
Published Aug. 23, 2016
This morning, the Milwaukee Film Festival announced its latest program lineup, this time for the homegrown Cream City Cinema category. From docs to music videos to dramas to shorts and more, here's what to expect at this year's fest.
Published Aug. 17, 2016
Beginning Friday night, the inaugural Milwaukee Women's Film Festival will present a three-day big screen showcase for women's stories. The project, created by Andrea Thompson, started with a simple question: What are you doing?
Published Aug. 12, 2016
A federal judge today overturned the conviction of Brendan Dassey, who was found guilty of being an accessory to Teresa Halbach's 2005 murder and served as one of the subjects in the hit Netflix docu-series "Making a Murderer."
Published Aug. 10, 2016
The first stage on which actor JJ Phillips stood and spoke Shakespeare was the Cabot Theater. About two decades later, Phillips is returning to that exact stage - except more as barely clothed bro than Bard in Chamber's "Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike."
Published Aug. 9, 2016
Henry "The Fonz" Winkler is in Milwaukee today for tomorrow night's Wisconsin State Fair "Happy Days: Live" main stage show. So what does The Fonz do to kill some time in the city that helped make him famous? We'll give you one guess.