Writer-director Derek Cianfrance made a nice name for himself back in 2010 with his indie depression-fest "Blue Valentine." The film told the story of a collapsing married couple – mixed with flashbacks to their cute origins for maximum tragic effect – with such brutal honesty and intimacy that the MPAA almost gave it a NC-17 rating basically because it was too painful to watch.
His follow-up, "The Place Beyond the Pines," represents a massive leap for the young director. The movie still has the intimacy that made "Blue Valentine" so emotionally potent, but it’s also a big, bold crime epic, tracing its way across two generations through multiple storylines.
Its lofty aspirations come with their share of flaws, but they also come with a sense of exhilaration. To borrow a phrase from one of the film’s costars, it rides like lightning but avoids crashing like thunder.
"The Place Beyond the Pines" tells three intertwined stories of fathers and sons connected through the consequences of their choices. Cianfrance favorite Ryan Gosling stars as Luke, a star stunt motorcycle driver for a travelling carnival. While the carnival makes a routine stop in Schenectady, New York (the origins of the town’s name gives the film its title), he reconnects with a fling from the past (Eva Mendes) who, unbeknownst to Luke, is raising his child.
When he finds out about his secret son, he ditches the carnival in order to stay in Schenectady and support his son. Unfortunately, his only skill is driving motorcycles fast, an item that doesn’t impress on too many resumes. Under the tutelage of a loner mechanic (Ben Mendelsohn, continuing his streak of playing characters who don’t shower), Luke begins robbing banks, which sets him on a collision course with Officer Avery Cross (Bradley Cooper, who doesn’t show up until about the 45-minute mark).
Their dramatic meeting, thrillingly captured by Cianfrance, leaves Avery – the son of a politician – a shaken hero, as well as our new protagonist. He’s haunted by the boy Luke left behind so much that he struggles to look at his own son. Avery doesn’t have much time to focus on family issues (including his wife Rose Byrne, who is very good in her few scenes), however, as corruption in his department – led by a menacing Ray Liotta – forces him into his father’s footsteps in politics.
It’s only until 15 years later when Avery must truly face his son, now a Jersey Shore-looking druggie delinquent. He must also face the consequences of his showdown with Luke when, in a cruel twist of fate, his son’s new friend Jason (Dane DeHaan from "Chronicle") turns out to be the renegade bank robber’s son.
The three-part script – written by Cianfrance, Ben Coccio and Darius Marder – will almost assuredly test the patience of many casual moviegoers. It’s a long film, coming in at just under two and a half hours, that paces itself and has no interest in pleasing its viewers.
Important characters drop in and out, and as the chapters unfold, the movie moves further away from more standard crime movie fare – motorcycle chases, bank robberies, corrupt cops – into the kind of bruising intimate family drama Cianfrance made his name with.
For those willing to go for the ride, however, "The Place Beyond the Pines" is an invigorating glance at an impressive new director taking his previously proven skills and evolving them before audience’s eyes.
Cianfrance is still terrific with actors, getting great performances out of every member of his cast (namely his two male leads and DeHaan, who will be playing Harry Osborn in next year’s "Amazing Spider-Man 2"). His use of music – Grizzly Bear’s soundtrack for "Blue Valentine," Mike Patton’s score here – is hauntingly perfect, and he hasn’t lost his touch with characters either. The emotions always feel raw and real, even if some of the plot’s mechanics feel less so.
Cianfrance’s tale of fathers, sons and consequences takes these known qualities and takes them in a big, bold new direction. His visual vocabulary has grown smartly, mixing shallow focus that puts the attention squarely on the characters with mesmerizing tracking shots and vigorously filmed motorcycle chases that are better crafted than most action movies.
The signature emotional intensity is there as well – combined with a new capability for visceral thrills – but on a significantly larger, grander scale.
As a new writer-director, Cianfrance is still going through his fair share of growing pains, mainly in the storytelling department. Some of the plot developments, such as the sons’ friendship in the last third and the corrupt cops, feel contrived.
The story is an upgrade from the mostly plotless (and therefore momentum-devoid) "Blue Valentine," but the characters and plot developments still sometimes seem motivated by the screenwriters’ need to move their chess pieces into place rather than real behavior.
These only feel like big issues, though, because "The Place Beyond the Pines" dares to be big. It has the ambition – a rare quality to find in most Hollywood movies – to be one of the best of the year. It’ll have to settle for being merely really good.
No Talkbacks for this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Matt Mueller
Published Feb. 27, 2015
After a quarter of a century as Milwaukee music mainstays, Clamnation is coming to an end, bringing things to a grand close Friday night at the Nomad World Pub beginning at 9 p.m. There tends to be an assumption of the worst when band members go separate ways, but that's far from the case here.
Published Feb. 25, 2015
"The Lego Movie Sequel" made headlines yesterday announcing its newly appointed director: Rob Schrab, a veteran of TV shows like "The Mindy Project," "Children's Hospital" and, most notably, NBC's beloved cult hit "Community." He also wrote the indie hit comic book "Scud: The Disposable Assassin." Oh, and he's also from Wisconsin! Everything is local! Everything is cool when you're from Milwaukee!
Published Feb. 25, 2015
If you've kept an ear to the local music scene over the past year or two, the odds are good that you've heard about GGOOLLDD. The band hits the Company Brewing (the former Stonefly Brewery) stage on Saturday night as a part of Arte Para Todos. Before that, however, OnMilwaukee.com caught up with the group to learn more about Milwaukee's latest music obsession.
Published Feb. 24, 2015
In the war between honesty and artifice, "Still Alice" has a pretty phenomenal performance in the former's corner.
Published Feb. 22, 2015
In movies, time travel typically ends up in the hands of the decent or deserving. "Hot Tube Time Machine 2" proposes ... what if it didn't? What if, instead, it wound up in the depraved hands of a bunch of restrained man-child ids, who then proceeded to violate space, time and everyone and everything they ran into along the way? The answer? Some laughs, I guess. A good amount of silence too. Bags don't come much more mixed than this.
Published Feb. 20, 2015
After months of hoopla and think-piecing (and a bomb scare just for extra drama) the Oscars are finally set to go this Sunday. And I suppose that means it's time to get my picks in order.
Published Feb. 18, 2015
Local rock band Eagle Trace has a new EP - "Off in the Night" - primed for release this weekend at a show at Anodyne Coffee in Walker's Point on Saturday, Feb. 21. For the guys, it's exactly the step forward they're hoping for. It's an understandably exciting one after about a year of drama and tension for Eagle Trace. And not just because of the predictable brotherly bickering - though there's some of that as well.
Published Feb. 16, 2015
The fan favorite jukebox musical "Mamma Mia!" - arriving at the Marcus Center for the Performing Arts on Friday for a five-show weekend stint - tells the tale of love found and thriving in the midst of the Mediterranean, all to the tune of ABBA hits. For ensemble cast members Jennifer and Vince Wingerter, it's a story that rings true in real life.
Published Feb. 14, 2015
It's Valentine's Day, which means many will be showing their love to their significant others, boyfriends, girlfriends and so on. But how much do we show our love to our pets - dogs in particular? According to a recent survey, as far as Wisconsinites go compared to the rest of the U.S., we're somewhere in the middle.
Published Feb. 14, 2015
Over 16 years of "SpongeBob SquarePants," the Nickelodeon cartoon's blend of childish giddiness, meta jokes and kooky non sequiturs has landed alongside Fruit Roll-Ups and naps in the middle section of a Venn diagram of things kids and cannabis users can equally love. That's certainly the case with the chatty cleaning device's delightfully wackadoodle second big screen trip, "The SpongeBob Movie: Sponge Out of Water."