Remakes, like this weekend's "Total Recall," are often considered the lowest of the low for Hollywood. Just take an old movie or franchise with the slightest bit of name recognition and rehash it for a new generation with lackluster results ("Psycho," anyone?).
Sometimes, however, a remake manages to equal or even surpass its predecessor. Here are five great examples that give unoriginality a good name.
It's rare for remakes to be good, much less for them to win Best Picture. However, in the hands of master director Martin Scorsese (who previously found remake success with "Cape Fear"), it should come as no surprise, especially when the source material, a 2002 Hong Kong crime thriller "Infernal Affairs," is right down his alley.
As expected from a Scorsese film, the cast is at their gritty, profane best, but it's the director's craftsmanship with the genre that makes "The Departed" a delight. He knows how to create terrific, character-driven tension, clearly demonstrated in a sequence involving two moles and a ringing cell phone. I'm not sure if it quite deserved Best Picture in 2007 (it seemed more like a make-good for Scorsese's previous overlooked classics), but it certainly deserves a high spot on this list.
"The Manchurian Candidate"
The original "Manchurian Candidate," starring Frank Sinatra, is almost as much a product of its time as it is a product of great filmmaking. Released in 1962, its paranoia-drenched story of a brainwashed politician echoed the fears of a nation in the grips of the Cuban Missile Crisis and, a year later, the Kennedy Assassination. The 2004 remake, directed by "The Silence of the Lambs" director Jonathan Demme, could never hope to be as timely, but it's close, capitalizing on post-9/11 fear and paranoia.
Demme does a terrific job of making the audience uncomfortable and feeling the characters' paranoia. The updated screenplay is surprisingly an improvement as well, especially in its treatment of Rosie, who in the original (played by Janet Leigh) was superfluous. As heretical as this might be to say, "The Manchurian Candidate" may be a rare case of a remake outdoing the classic.
I saw Takashi Miike's brilliant "13 Assassins" a little too late to put it on my Best of 2011 list last year, so consider this a type of redemption. Based on a 1963 Japanese movie of the same name, the film follows a band of samurai who team up to take down a viciously cruel ruler.
It's a relatively common premise but made uncommonly well. The first half of the film focuses on getting to know the characters and seeing the intricate training and lifestyle of the samurai. The audience really gets to care about the assassins, which makes the final 45-minute battle all the more intense and nerve-wracking. "13 Assassins" is a glorious tribute to the legendary warriors that ends up legendary in its own right.
Though the Rat Pack may not surpassed in inherent cool and suaveness, their 1960 version of "Ocean's 11" is easily outdone by Steven Soderbergh's slick, sexy and smart 2001 remake. The tricky heist plan is thrillingly complex and wildly entertaining to watch unfold, but really, the movie is all about style, something Soderbergh and his cast have in spades.
Clooney, Pitt and company do their best to effortlessly match the timeless charisma of Sinatra and the Rat Pack, making crafty casino heists seem like the coolest job in the world. The crew is having fun, and the audience feels like they're having fun with them. "Ocean's 11" is everything we hope hanging out with celebrities would be like, though perhaps without the thievery and jail time.
If remakes are normally the bottom of the barrel, then horror movie remakes are the scummy excess that leaks out of the bottom. There are a few notable exceptions, such as 1982's "The Thing" and Zach Snyder's "Dawn of the Dead." However, it's director Gore Verbinski's 2002 take on the 1998 Japanese horror flick, "Ringu," that earns the last spot on this list.
With the numerous Japanese remake flops and even more numerous spoofs that followed, it's easy to forget how terrifying "The Ring" is. Verbinski creates a pervasive, dread-filled mood throughout the film, making the real world seem almost as dark and unsettling as the disturbing footage on the notorious cassette tape. Most importantly, "The Ring" is actually scary, a rare feat for most modern horror films. Case in point: I wasn't able to look in my closet for at least a week after "The Ring."
1 comment about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by OnMilwaukee.com Staff Writers
Published Dec. 8, 2013
This week, we asked the Social Circle if it thought celebrating St. Nick was excessive considering Hanukkah and Christmas and other December gift-focused holidays. What are your thoughts on the other jolly ol' chap?
Published Dec. 7, 2013
It's a loaded set of recommendations this week from OnMilwaukee, featuring everything from sporting events to soulful folk songs to fun with fungi and Fischberger's.
Published Dec. 6, 2013
Whether you want to embrace all of the holiday goodness going on, hit up the town, or cheer on our local teams, there is a ton to do this great Milwaukee weekend.
Published Dec. 5, 2013
Milwaukee World Festival, Inc.'s Chairman of the Board, Ted Kellner, announced today that Summerfest 2013 created a positive economic impact of $226 million for the State of Wisconsin, including $187 million for the City of Milwaukee.
Published Dec. 4, 2013
It's the playoffs, and you're feeling good about it. But maybe you've got that guy stashed on your bench that might be poised for a breakout, or is a coin flip with another starter on your squad, or you're playing the team with Peyton Manning this week. Well, we're here to help you with who to go with if you're looking for maximum points this week.
Published Dec. 4, 2013
Shampriel Morrise, an 11th grade voice major student at Milwaukee High School of the Arts (MHSA), was one of 700 young artists selected from more than 10,000 applicants across the nation to receive the YoungArts Merit Award.
Published Dec. 4, 2013
It's Christmas time, and that means it's time for cinemas and televisions across the nation to overdose on holiday specials. There are seemingly hundreds of Christmas movies scattered across the entertainment world come November and December. Some are silly. Some are serious. Almost are sappy. But a few manage to become true classics, beloved for years. Here are the OnMilwaukee.com staff's personal favorites.
Published Dec. 2, 2013
These new transit features will be available to view on Thursday, Dec. 5, between 9 a.m. and 2 p.m. at the MCTS Fleet Maintenance Building, located at 1525 W. Vine St.
Published Dec. 2, 2013
A lot of folks descend the stairs into the Cave of the Mounds in Blue Mounds, west of Madison, and marvel at the great acoustics. That's one natural feature that makes the annual Caroling in the Cave Music Series so perfect for the caverns, which we dubbed one of the Seven Wonders of Wisconsin a few years ago. Now in its seventh year, Caroling in the Cave is a three-day event that is slated for Friday-Sunday, Dec. 6-8 this year.
Published Dec. 1, 2013
Six holiday seasons ago, we wrote about Jeff Gelder's "Holiday Magic" CD series, which brings stories and holiday cheer to kids spending the holidays in the hospital. This year, 150 copies are headed to Children's Hospital of Wisconsin.