A bittersweet goodbye to Sugar
The obituaries for Bert Randolph Sugar, who died at 74 on Sunday, laud him as an "iconic" and "legendary" boxing writer and historian and even as "the heavyweight champion" of the genre, from which the only conclusion to be drawn is that the shameless self-promoter wrote them himself before the angels swooped.
When it came to hymning the greatness of Bert Sugar, nobody was better at and louder about it than Bert Sugar. The cover blurbs he wrote about himself for various boxing books were preposterous monuments to an ego proportionate to his hat size. My favorite: "Bert Randolph Sugar, called 'the guru' of boxing, is one of the most flamboyant and charismatic writers ever to capture the drama of fights and fighters on paper."
His vaunted charisma may have lit up many a barroom, but it wore thin on the many Sugar stiffed for services rendered. I took my place in that long line in the early 1990s as a frequent contributor to Boxing Illustrated, then edited by Sugar. Getting him to pay for what he used required the stamina and doggedness of 1890s ring dynamo Sailor Tom Sharkey. Frequent calls and messages left at Bert's office and home were ducked and ignored.
"I'm juggling a million balls in the air, and two of them are mine," he would say when finally cornered, and then promise a check that never came.
I was in good company.
"Your experience with Bert Randolph Sugar is not unique," wrote W.C. Heinz – a legitimate sports writing legend – in a 1990 letter to me. "Last April ... he ran without permission my piece on Norma Graziano ("Fighter's Wife").
"When my agents finally got him on the horn he said that he had tried to reach me by phone and then had left a message on my answering machine and when he heard nothing presumed I had no objection. The problem is that I don't have an answering machine. If I were in New York (Heinz lived in Vermont) I'd take him to small claims court, as up to the moment he still refuses to cough up."
He never did. Two years later, wrote Heinz, "Whenever I think of Bert Randolph, and always unpleasantly, I remember a quote from (famous boxing manager) Al Weill, born in Alsace, who described his exodus to this country: 'We come over storage because my old man had no sugar.'"
Writing fondly of Sugar in The New York Daily News on Sunday, Tim Smith recounted the tale about when sportswriter Dick Joyce yanked the trademark fedora off Sugar's bald head at a Boxing Writers of America dinner in New York and tossed it out the window of the 20th story room. But Smith left out the reaction of former heavyweight champion Jack Sharkey, who obviously had his own history with Sugar.
"Why didn't he throw the rest of the bum out, too?" growled Sharkey.
Talkbacks
![]() |
1 comment about this article. Post your comment/review now |
Facebook comments
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Pete Ehrmann
Milwaukee's most maligned boxer
Published May 18, 2013
Ninety-two years ago this month, Johnny Mendelsohn won the biggest fight of his career and simultaneously sealed his fate as, in the words of a sportswriter who covered him, "the most maligned boxer Milwaukee ever had."
Norman Johnson, former Golden Gloves champ, passes away
Published April 10, 2013
Norman Johnson, the sensational Milwaukee lightweight who won the 1953 and 1954 Golden Gloves at 135 pounds, passed away last Friday about three weeks short of his 78th birthday.
Former Badgers heavyweight recalls Golden Gloves triumph
Published April 6, 2013
Far be it from Bob Ranck to suggest that his participation in the 1953 Wisconsin Golden Gloves tournament was responsible for the attendance that is still the high-water mark in the history of the amateur boxing - an event whose 83rd annual run starts April 6 in Racine.
Remembering Mary Ehrmann
Published March 5, 2013
Pete Ehrmann remembers his sister Mary, a beloved local educator who passed away on March 2.
Flowers a pioneer in Milwaukee boxing
Published Feb. 28, 2013
The cause of civil rights in Wisconsin has been advanced through the years by stalwart trailblazers who weren't afraid of a punch in the mouth. Or, in the case of Bruce Flowers - who ended discrimination against black boxers in the state when he stepped through the ropes at the Milwaukee Auditorium 84 years ago - in the plums.
Boxer Harry Wills an inspiration every February
Published Feb. 2, 2013
Nowadays the groundhog and its accursed shadow get all the attention at this time of year, but back in the 1920s, 30s and 40s people knew it was February when Harry Wills became a shadow of his old self by not eating any food for the entire month.
Remembering boxer Al Andrews
Published Jan. 13, 2013
In an era of mob-controlled fights, Wisconsin boxer Al Andrews managed to make a name for himself across the country by becoming one of the first faces of boxing on national television.
"Iron Man" Joe Grim found fame with a thick skull
Published Jan. 7, 2013
After one of the world's most famous athletes showed his stuff in Milwaukee 107 years ago Jan. 5, a newspaper sports reporter pronounced him "a nerveless, brainless, freak of human idiocy." Those were layman's terms, of course, but a few years earlier medical experts came to virtually the same conclusion about boxer Joe Grim.
German-born wrestler Ernst Scharpegge found fame on Milwaukee mats
Published Dec. 20, 2012
Constance and Ernst Scharpegge were German-born siblings who emigrated to the United States and won wide acclaim in the performance arts. She was an opera singer in New York City, but her brother settled in Milwaukee. When his virtuosity moved audiences to the heights of rapture, instead of "Bravo!" they screamed, "Twist der kopf out, Ernst!"
Milt Rickun: An old-school fight referee
Published Dec. 11, 2012
Compared to some of the high-profile, self-promoting boxing referees who came after him, Milt Rickun was a shrinking violet. Rickun, who died Dec. 7 at age 85, was properly inconspicuous between the ropes. He didn't preen or showboat, and let his professionalism speak for itself.
Like Us
Follow Us










