Merry Christmas, "Les Miz" lovers â€“ I'm about to hate all over your musical.
All right, calm down. I don't hate the musical itself, per se. What I hate is its utterly superfluous big screen adaptation, which I'm about 90 percent sure is getting rave reviews only because people can't differentiate between "great musical" and "great musical lazily slapped onto film for mass consumption."
"Les Miserables," to the musical-inclined, is the story of Jean Valjean (Hugh Jackman), a 19th-century French parole jumper who vows to care for young Cosette (Isabelle Allen/ Amanda Seyfried) after the death of her mother, Fantine (Anne Hathaway). "Les Miserables," to the musical-less-than-inclined, is that new movie with Hathaway ugly-crying into the camera as she belts out that Susan Boyle song.
Those in the latter camp will be sorely disappointed when Hathaway bites it within minutes of first appearing on screen, and that's the fault of a dirty marketing trick to get people into seats with her clout behind the trailers. It's a minor offense, though, compared to the rest of the more legitimate shortcomings that litter this two-and-a-half-hour trudge.
For all of the languid pace it takes up in later acts, "Les Miz" rushes through its exposition like the opening credits were on fire. It drops key points of the introduction in moments, scattered across characters in a muddled mess of sing-talking, which is itself hard to follow right from the beginning. The exchanges may as well have been in French, especially considering Valjean and Javert (Russell Crowe)'s penchants for referring to themselves in the third person.
It wasn't the completely musical dialogue that turned me off, though, but the constant soliloquizing. Having the characters talk to themselves to reveal their innermost thoughts and feelings to the audience might work on a Broadway stage, but in a movie â€“ where "showing" takes precedent to "telling" â€“ the device just comes off as lazy. After being translated from novel to stage so successfully, I would think the people behind the film version would have invested time and effort into crafting a screenplay that would embrace the medium with a little more grace. Instead, it comes off as a stubborn, bloated diva.
Another cause for distraction is director Tom Hooper's pervasive visual style. The too-close camerawork, coupled with offset shots later on, take the audience completely out of the moment. Extreme closeups of Jackman's face during his early spiritual conflict at the church are uncomfortably invasive, and the off-center framing of Hathaway during the famous "I Dreamed a Dream" was downright "Blair Witch"-y. Hooper's decision to situate her face in the bottom right corner of the screen with a stark black background filling the rest of the frame drew harsh attention to every camera shake and readjustment.
I felt a little nauseous, and that made me feel worse, since there were plenty of other things more deserving of the feeling in this otherwise blasÃ© film. The music â€“ not the singing, but the accompaniment â€“ was inconsistently balanced with the vocals and made the interactions and solos that much harder to follow. The actual musical numbers were slightly more consistent, but the background music during conversations only served as complicating noise.
Of course, I can't discuss inconsistencies without mentioning Crowe's performance as the adamant poster boy for blind obedience, Javert. He wows, frankly, in the sing-songy conversations because he's nowhere near the short list of prospective musical talent, but he completely falters in bigger numbers. He also didn't bring a convincing amount of tenacity to his role as Valjean's dogged pursuer. He came off as whiny instead of conflicted, and he didn't have enough of a character arc to make his screen time worthwhile.
Another installment to the "static character" list is the comic relief pair of Sacha Baron Cohen and Helena Bonham Carter as the Thenardiers. They're typecast to a tee as the deadbeat innkeepers who hold initial custody of Cosette, but (and it pains me to say it) they were almost tedious in such expected roles. Even though they did a fine job of carrying their responsibilities in the ensemble, their performances felt like phone-ins if only because they've gone there so many times before.
That, in essence, is the problem with all of the assorted downtrodden souls that make their way through "Les Miz." I understand these are struggling people in the depths of trying times and all manner of despairs, but I just didn't care about a single one of them. They were, across the board, so uniformly ennui-laden that there was nothing interesting to cling to. The ensemble shots, larger musical numbers and visuals were the only things that embraced something other than the washed-out gray mood and sea of warbling solos. But, they were so infrequent that they merely served to rouse me from my apathetic coma.
I can't help but think that some restructuring could have saved "Les Miserables": film edition. Some editing, dialogue adjustment or more conventional camera choices could have rescued it from its self-inflicted misery. Toward the end I was just hoping they'd be put out of it, but not even the act of dying was spared laborious screen time â€“ the only thing more insistent than the self-indulgent death scenes was my brain screaming, "Just shut up and do it already!"
1 comment about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Renee Lorenz
Published Jan. 11, 2013
Classic gangsters loved a good embarrassment of riches. And for a movie like "Gangster Squad," showing off is fine. But, when the swanky style of the era meets the stylized swank of the movie's own excesses, things get out of hand.
Published Jan. 3, 2013
It feels like not a week goes by without someone posting something about how Facebook's invading everyone's privacy, spying on your browser history, etc., ad nauseum. (These posts are usually made on Facebook, by the way.) I understand the generic concern over the Orwellian slippery slope, but it doesn't take me too long to re-assess and arrive back at my old conclusion: Who cares?
Published Dec. 31, 2012
Although outsiders may not see Milwaukee as a hotbed for the performing arts, locals know there's plenty of talent to go around. And, there are numerous venues across the city that proudly show off area actors, dancers and musicians. But, despite the wide array of opportunities available, Katie Rhyme and Karen Zakrzewski still felt something important was missing.
Published Dec. 25, 2012
Well, it took director Quentin Tarantino 20 years, but he finally got his Western ... kinda. Although it's fair to say he's been preparing his entire career with his raucously bloody shoot-'em-ups, Tarantino's time warming up has been well spent if "Django Unchained" is the final result
Published Dec. 21, 2012
Unlike most middle-aged men, Judd Apatow can afford a whole garage of Camaros and Mustangs. So, it makes sense that his mid-life crisis would manifest not with a youthful car buy, but by splurging on the production of a new movie.
Published Dec. 19, 2012
They say time flies when you're having fun. I don't know who "they" are (probably those terrifyingly upbeat "glass half full" people), but they nailed it. My 2012 is a blur of exciting times and memorable moments, most of which my lawyers have advised me not to discuss in detail. There's still plenty to talk about, though, and I've shared the highlights below.
Published Dec. 18, 2012
Well, another year of movies is (almost) in the books. Full of many memorable ups and seared-in-my-brain-forever downs, here's my take on the best (and worst) of 2012.
Published Dec. 14, 2012
Eleven years after "Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring" introduced audiences to the majesty of director Peter Jackson's Middle-earth, "The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey" makes a triumphant return to the mythical land with a new trilogy based on J.R.R. Tolkien's "The Hobbit."
Published Dec. 12, 2012
After being tasked with putting together an actual wish list, I'm legitimately afraid of the death glare I'll get if I hand over my ultra-practical, completely un-whimsical list of stuff I want. So, I'm posting it here.
Published Dec. 11, 2012
Ferrets. A singing geriatric in an eye patch. Disturbingly upbeat wound care. These topics are the most recent added to the popular Found Footage Festival, which returns Dec. 19 with its sixth volume of so-bad-they're-good clips.