Milwaukee's Daily Magazine Friday, July 4, 2008
Today
Hi: 71
Lo: 58
Sat
Hi: 72
Lo: 60
Sun
Hi: 80
Lo: 65
Section Sponsor
Article Tools
Print this Article
Make text larger
In Politics Blogs
I object to negative and confusing judge ads
 
By Andy Tarnoff RSS Feed
Publisher

E-mail author | Author bio
More articles by Andy Tarnoff

What is a blog?  For us it is a short blurb that we write when the mood strikes us.  It can be first person, funny or informative. In short, a blog is whatever we want it to be. Published March 16, 2008 at 6:00 p.m.
Tags: supreme court, election, special interest, judge

I'll admit it, I'm perhaps not as tuned in as I should be into the race for Wisconsin Supreme Court judge.

I'll also admit that until I started seeing these vague and confusing commercials lately, I didn't even know a race was underway.

In fact, I had to figure it out myself, since these commercials mention neither the race at hand, when the election is, or who they'd like me to vote for. They just tell me why some judge I've never heard of is soft on crime, peppering in some bobbling heads, grainy, stock footage of criminals and prisons and testimonials from organizations I've never heard of.

Then they tell me to call some number in the 608 or 715 or area code and tell this judge I've had enough.

Um, why are you telling me to do this?

Surely, you don't really want me to call these judges. I've gathered that these are third-party negative ads indirectly pitching a candidate for an upcoming April election (again, no date is shown, but I'm sure I'll figure it out). Apparently the candidates, whose names I don't recall, are soft on crime and let criminals go free.

Maybe I'm being naïve, but isn't it the job of state judges to enforce laws, not to enact them? I know there's room for interpretation, as is the case at the U.S. Supreme Court, but is it that highly partisan at the state level? If it is, do I even have the knowledge at my fingertips to make an educated decision about who to vote for? More importantly, should this really be up to me, or should the Wisconsin Supreme Court justices be appointed by an elected official?

Maybe if I saw some commercials with a few salient points from the candidates (whoever they are) on why they're great judges, I'd feel more comfortable voting next month. I highly doubt these guys are really setting rapists free, nor are they "keystone kops" they're portrayed to be. If these commercials work as a loophole into a 501.c style endorsement (I noticed no one is saying "I've approved this message" at the end), they're not working.

Not only do I not feel strongly about either of these candidates, I'd prefer my judges to follow the law, not to serve as activists. I'd be more impressed if one of these commercials simply said, "Hi, I'm Judge Blah-blah-blah. I've been a judge for 20 years, and I have a record of ruling consistently with the state's laws, whether I agree with them or not."

And until that, I object. Unless these obscure campaigns change their tactics, I'm not voting for anyone for that position come April.

5 comments about this article.
Post a comment / write a review.

Recent Talkbacks ...
Posted by Preview
ChateauDweller This blog is why we shouldn't encourage mass voter participation. People should ...
Franksville Unless you want to have a narrow clique of courthouse insiders pick our judges, ...
CoolerKing Actually, this type of election should really have more voter participation. ...
themil Andy, it's important to know that since judges are elected in WI, they're politicians. ...
mkelover You can thank McCain/Feingold campaign finance reform for these shady, third ...

Recent blogs/briefs by Andy Tarnoff
What is a blog?  For OMC, it is a short blurb that we write when the mood strikes us.  It can be first person, funny or informative. In short, a blog is whatever we want it to be. My Summerfest food lap
Wednesday
Everyone has his or her own annual Summerfest plan of action. But for the purpose of this ...

What is a blog?  For OMC, it is a short blurb that we write when the mood strikes us.  It can be first person, funny or informative. In short, a blog is whatever we want it to be. A pedestrian South Side morning
Saturday
I'm waiting for new tires to get installed, so I've spent the last hour wandering around ...

What is a blog?  For OMC, it is a short blurb that we write when the mood strikes us.  It can be first person, funny or informative. In short, a blog is whatever we want it to be. They Might Be Giants toes the line between kid, adult rock
June 27, 2008
The last time I saw the harmonizing, nerd rock stylings of John Flansburgh and John Linnell, ...

What is a blog?  For OMC, it is a short blurb that we write when the mood strikes us.  It can be first person, funny or informative. In short, a blog is whatever we want it to be. Video tutorial of OnMilwaukee.com's new features
June 25, 2008
Here's a quick screencast that my main programmer Zach Karpinski and I shot this morning.

What is a blog?  For OMC, it is a short blurb that we write when the mood strikes us.  It can be first person, funny or informative. In short, a blog is whatever we want it to be. The "perpetual beta" is fresh for summer
June 24, 2008
A long time ago, we used the word "redesign" to describe our frequent changes and upgrades ...