Milwaukee's Daily Magazine Saturday, Nov. 21, 2009
Today
Hi: 56
Lo: 38
Sun
Hi: 52
Lo: 41
Mon
Hi: 52
Lo: 39
Section Sponsor
Article Tools
Print this Article
Make text larger
Related Twitter Posts

  • LearfieldOnline:
    What Twitter's geolocation makes possible link How about targeted promos for people in a football stadium or at an ag show?

  • obilon:
    I mean, I love SM as much as the next guy but sometimes I want to talk about Football or something, y'know.

  • aniketdixit:
    which is difficult, fixing a cricket match or a football match??

  • tobymoody:
    Can someone who understands football tell me (as I'm not bothered by it) why there cannot be a '3rd upmire', or replay of Eire/France match?

  • NeilWithers:
    @Lollylisbeth Oh come on. Course its public. You just have to pay. Like a football match. Or a journal article. It's just expensive.


Follow us on Twitter ...
In Sports Blogs
Thoughts on football and dog fighting
Gladwell: "How different are dogfighting and football?"
By Jeff Sherman RSS Feed Twitter Feed
OnMilwaukee.com Staff Writer
Photography by csmfoundation.org
E-mail author | Author bio
More articles by Jeff Sherman

What is a blog?  For us it is a short blurb that we write when the mood strikes us.  It can be first person, funny or informative. In short, a blog is whatever we want it to be. Published Oct. 22, 2009 at 10:19 a.m.
Tags: football, concussions, brain damage, gladwell, new yorker, dog fighting, tipping point


I like watching football, but it's far from my favorite sport. There's the groundwork. Now, on to the guts of this blog.

American football really has it all. It's fast, full of destruction, precision and, at any moment, you know someone is liable to get whacked, flattened and downright leveled. Ah, football. Many games are more like video games or movies, aren't they? Huge guys, in full armor, going all out in search of a win.

What's got football on this basketball boy's mind today?

Malcolm Gladwell, author of "Blink" and "The Tipping Point," is the one who has me thinking. Gladwell has written one of the year's best pieces of sports journalism. His New Yorker piece called, "Offensive Play. How different are dog fighting and football?," is as good as it gets in his profession. It's thought provoking, honest and entertaining. Give it a read.

Here's an exerpt:

"In 2000 and 2001, four drivers in NASCAR's elite Sprint Cup Series were killed in crashes, including the legendary Dale Earnhardt. In response, NASCAR mandated stronger seats, better seat belts and harnesses, and ignition kill switches, and completed the installation of expensive new barriers on the walls of its racetracks, which can absorb the force of a crash much better than concrete. The result is that, in the past eight years, no one has died in NASCAR's three national racing series. Stock-car fans are sometimes caricatured as bloodthirsty, eagerly awaiting the next spectacular crash. But there is little blood these days in NASCAR crashes. Last year, at Texas Motor Speedway, Michael McDowell hit an oil slick, slammed head first into the wall at a hundred and eighty miles per hour, flipped over and over, leaving much of his car in pieces on the track, and, when the vehicle finally came to a stop, crawled out of the wreckage and walked away. He raced again the next day. So what is football? Is it dog fighting or is it stock-car racing?"

I never played the game at any thing above a flag football level, but even so I'm certain that even with all the precautions taken to protect players that I wouldn't want my son or frankly your son to play the game. Call me a wuss or risk averse, but I'm simply doing the concussion and brain damage math. Again, read the piece, do some research on concussions and on post-playing-days life for football players and you, too, might be a bit scared.

I'm not bashing football. Again, I'm a fan. But, I am wondering if the sport may need to pay more attention to safety.

But, as Gladwell concludes in his 10-page piece, "There is nothing else to be done, not so long as fans stand and cheer. We are in love with football players, with their courage and grit, and nothing else -- neither considerations of science nor those of morality -- can compete with the destructive power of that love."

Is football too violent? Use the Talkback feature to react.



More Information ...
Related links:

5 comments about this article.
Post a comment / write a review.

Recent Talkbacks ...

Posted by sandstorm on Oct. 23, 2009 at 2:05 p.m. (report)

broner is right and quite frankly i thought the New Yorker published articles better thought out than this weak attempt to point that, duh, football is violent.

Rate this:
  • Average rating: 0.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


Posted by LegallyBlonde on Oct. 22, 2009 at 3:05 p.m. (report)

I was at that game where Freeman got smacked. Also the same game where Green ripped off a 98-yard run and the Vikings blew it on 4th and 28. Vikings still suck. Looking forward to reading this piece.

Rate this:
  • Average rating: 0.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


Posted by speakthetruth on Oct. 22, 2009 at 2:29 p.m. (report)

Soccer is not a sport, it is an athletic event that is roughly as exciting as watching paint dry. Football is a brutal, violent sport...but no one is "forced" to play football. Players understand the risks.

Rate this:
  • Average rating: 0.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


Posted by wiscoleeds on Oct. 22, 2009 at 11:39 a.m. (report)

Take off the pads and helmet and you won't see so many "macho" hits where someone just blindsides someone. Perhaps these "studs" should try playing rugby or Aussie rules football. Until the mentality that smacking an unsuspecting reciever coming across the middle is cool and not the equivalent of a cowardly sucker punch and the participants are more armored than our fighting soldiers in Afghanistan then football will continue to have concussions. Wiscoleeds

Rate this:
  • Average rating: 0.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


Posted by Broner on Oct. 22, 2009 at 10:34 a.m. (report)

Football certainly is violent and becoming moreso with bigger, faster, stronger athletes. But the big difference between dog fighting and football is that the losing football players don't die on the field and if they don't die aren't left for dead or outright killed by their owners afterwards. Plus, football players especially at the college and professional levels make the decision to play of their own free will. The risks and rewards are known and those who take the risk to potentially get the reward make their own decisions. And those who do play don't spend their lives chained up, living in their own feces, and ultimately killed by their competition or owners when they've outlived their "fight."

Rate this:
  • Average rating: 0.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5



Recent blogs/briefs by Jeff Sherman
What is a blog?  For OMC, it is a short blurb that we write when the mood strikes us.  It can be first person, funny or informative. In short, a blog is whatever we want it to be. Milwaukee Holiday Lights Festival kicks off tonight
Thursday
The Milwaukee Holiday Lights Festival lights Downtown for the 11th season during its ceremonial ...

What is a blog?  For OMC, it is a short blurb that we write when the mood strikes us.  It can be first person, funny or informative. In short, a blog is whatever we want it to be. Mark Cuban talks business, life and basketball in Milwaukee
Tuesday
Mark Cuban opened the new "Bucks Speakers Series" Monday night at Historic Turner Hall. ...

No fondue for you: Melting Pot expansion plans on hold
Tuesday
A planned Melting Pot restaurant in the Historic Third Ward is not "proceeding as planned," ...

What is a blog?  For OMC, it is a short blurb that we write when the mood strikes us.  It can be first person, funny or informative. In short, a blog is whatever we want it to be. Wanted: student artists with ugly Christmas sweater skills
Monday
Ugly Christmas sweaters are coming to the East Side and local student artists are being ...

What is a blog?  For OMC, it is a short blurb that we write when the mood strikes us.  It can be first person, funny or informative. In short, a blog is whatever we want it to be. Keb Mo was "Live & Mo'" Saturday in Milwaukee
Sunday
Keb Mo smiled and sang through a wonderful set Saturday night at the intimate Northern ...

OnMilwaukee.com is part of the In Click Network. Other In Click sites include: 30RockReport.com | Behind The Scenes at OnMilwaukee.com | BetterRecipes.org | Bimmer Digest | Brain Brawn & Body | BrewCityBeats.com | Brewcitybigscreen.com | britneysnation.com | BritPop Rocks | Brooklynbanter.com | CactusLeagueReport.com | Caffeinateddigest.com | Culinary Piedmont | Cycling Chainring | Daily Lost Update | Daily Milwaukee News | Daily Spa | DannyGokeyMilwaukee.com | Dogs Blogs | EarthFueled.com | Edible Wisconsin | FanaticPhotog.com | Gadget Deals and Steals | GolfLinksWisconsin.com | H1N1 Alerts | H1N1 Blog | H1N1 Prevention | H1N1 Reporter | H1N1 Tracker | HogEnthusiast.com | Informed Runner | iPhone Daily Report | Man United Nation | Milwaukee Brewers Nation | Milwaukee Bucks Blog | Milwaukee Dad | Minnesota Wild Nation | MomMilwaukee.com | My Super Stocks | MyGayMilwaukee.com | MyHangoverHelper | News on Draught | NY Mets Nation | OnAtlantaGA.com | OnAustinTX.com | OnBaltimoreMD.com | OnBirminghamAL.com | OnBostonMass.com | OnBuffaloNY.com | OnCharlotteNC.com | OnCincinnati.com | OnClevelandOH.com | OnColumbusOH.com | OnDallas.com | OnDCmetro.com | OnDenverCO.com | OnDetroitMI.com | OnDoorCounty.org | OnFortLauderdale.com | OnGreenBay.com | OnHartford.com | OnIndianapolisIN.com | OnKansasCityMO.com | OnLakeCountry.com | OnLosAngelesCA.com | OnLouisvilleKY.com | OnMadison.com | OnMemphisTN.com | OnMiamiFLA.com | OnMilwaukee.com Cars | OnMilwaukee.com Metro Headlines | OnNashvilleTN.com | OnNewOrleansLA.com | OnNYCny.com | OnOrlandoFL.com | OnPalmSprings.com | OnPhiladelphia.com | OnPhoenixAZ.com | OnPittsburgh.com | OnPortlandOR.com | OnProvidence.com | OnRichmondVA.com | OnSacramento.com | OnSaltLakeCity.com | OnSanAntonioTX.com | OnSanDiegoCA.com | OnSanFran.com | OnSanJose.com | OnSeattleWA.com | OnSinCity.com | OnStLouis.com | OnStPetersburg.com | OnTampaBay.com | OnTucsonAZ.com | OnTwinCities.com | OnWichita.com | OnWindyCity.com | Packers Posts | Porsche 911 Fans | PriusFans.com | Roller Derby Network | SnuggieFans.com | SummerfestRocks.com | Swine Flu China | Swine Flu Reporter | The 24 Reporter | The Barack Obama Fan Club | The Brilliant Manager | The Comic Book Reporter | The In Click | The Office Fan Blog | TheHDTVReporter.com | TheNetbookBlog.com | TheNewParentBlog.com | Trueguitarheroes.com | Vintage Mets | VW Busses | WaukeshaWeekly.com | Weekly Media News | Wisconsincustomhomenews.com | WisWomen.com | Woodworker Digest