In Dining

That's a hearty fish fry for $9.99 ($10.99 with potato pancakes).

In Dining

The Trysting Place has a large menu with a lot more than just fish.

Despite being in plain view, a diner finally finds The Trysting Place

It's taken a long time for me to find The Trysting Place, N71W12980 Appleton Ave., in Menomonee Falls.

Of course, like most Milwaukeeans, I've heard of the place for years. But until life's little circumstances led me to start driving past the bar and grill on the corner of Appleton and Good Hope once in a while over the last year, I couldn't even have told you where it was located.

In recent months, we've talked about stopping in to try the fish fry, because we've heard good things. A few weeks ago we stopped in and tried the fish.

It was a warm evening – one of the first in a while – and so we took the opportunity to sit outside on the covered patio. While there's not much to see out there, it's remarkably relaxing considering it's nearness to the parking lot and busy Appleton Avenue. Anyway, we dined as a family and we figured if the kids got messy or loud, it would be less intrusive out there (luckily, they didn't).

Inside, the Trysting Place is a sprawling bar with an attached dining area, pool tables and even a banquet room. On a late spring early Friday evening, the bar wasn't crowded, but I suspect it gets pretty hopping as the sun sets and, I bet, when the softball crowd starts to roll in.

But, I saw no apparent trysting and so, parents, it's just fine to bring the kids. We were one of about a half-dozen tables on the patio with children during our visit.

While the kids noshed on grilled cheese and fries (and my applesauce, natch), I of course had the fish. Cod, battered and fried, and paid the extra dollar for the potato pancakes.

As is de rigueur, there were also two slices of rye, a cup of tartar sauce and a cole slaw.

The portion was generous – and cost $9.95 (plus the extra buck for the pancakes) – with three big pieces of fish that were flaky and delicious. Though the batter was a little on the greasy side, a few dabs of a napkin was enough to remedy that.

The pancakes were pretty good; not amazing but certainly not bad. They were crisp outside and tender inside, but could have used a bit of a flavor jolt.

I always hope for – but rarely experience – a revelation a la the old Turner Hall of Kegel's. Here, it was hard to tell if they were made on-site or not.

Though definitely better than the clearly out of the box variety, these shredded potato flapjacks were pretty uniform in shape, which made me think they may not be handmade at The Trysting Place.

The service was attentive and super friendly with our server and her helper keeping the kids happy and keeping our needs met despite their being in constant demand and in constant motion.

Of course, the large menu has lots of pub food options beyond the Friday fish fry, with a wide range of burgers, sandwiches, appetizers, salads and more.

In the end, we spent a total of $40 for two kids meals and two adult meals plus a beer each for the adults. Not bad. The food was plentiful and good, the vibe was mellow and low stress, and the staff was great.

So, though we arrived very, very late to The Trysting Place's charms, we'll be back to experience them again.



B.H. | June 3, 2011 at 7:27 a.m. (report)

Nice Review, I would go on Fridays for the fish fry buffet, it can get crowded but it's worth it. Great wait-staff, very friendly.

Rate this:
  • Average rating: 0.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
1 comment about this article.
Post a comment / write a review.

Facebook Comments

Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of or its staff.