Get your laughs out of the way now: I've waited a very long time to see Burton Cummings live.
The Guess Who is one of my top 10 favorite bands, and while I reviewed them in Waukesha in 2007 the only original member then was bassist Jim Kale. The most dynamic part of the Guess Who, lead singer Burton Cummings, wasn't with this veritable tribute band, replaced with a sound-alike stand-in. And let's just say, that band isn't talking to Cummings.
So when I saw that 64-year-old Cummings was playing Summerfest this year, I put it in my calendar early. I watched YouTube videos of his performances; I followed him on Twitter. I knew what to expect.
This was a case of "I'd better see him play, in case I never get the chance again."
I think it was worth it ... but I'm not sure.
In the '70s, Cummings had that wide mustache, framing a grinning mouth that showed amazing range. His unruly, curly hair evoked Canadian classic rock, the originator of amazing music like "No Sugar Tonight, "These Eyes" and "American Woman."
Tonight, Cummings still has the jet black hair, his too-small mustache completely unironic. He looks and sounds like the lead singer of a Guess Who tribute band, his sweet, sweet voice somehow turned lounge singer as he makes beautiful music on his piano.
It was pretty weird, actually. When Cummings hit the high notes (which he seldom attempted and weren't that high ), he sounded so nasally and unlike the voice I've known and loved. He sounded good in the lower registers, but his vocal skills have deteriorated in a way I've never experienced.
Again unironically, clad in a black cat T-shirt, black jeans and black button-down shirt, Cummings sweated his way through a long hot set at the Potawatomi Stage. He brought with him a top-flight backing band, and bantered a lot with the crowd.
Unfortunately, he took repeated digs at the band touring as the Guess Who (which, technically speaking, sounded much better than Cummings tonight). I can see how angry he was, and I don't blame him, but the ever-present griping got old. Cummings also told a nice story about hearing how he found out "American Woman" went #1 when he was playing in Milwaukee in 1970.
But the show just didn't have much luster. Some songs, like "Undone," "Clap For The Wolfman," "No Time" and "Share The Land" sounded great. But others, like "American Woman," started with a long and hokey, Doors-eque intro. All in all, it felt a little sad.
But you know what, Cummings had fun out there, and so did the older, sweaty crowd. We get it: these are his songs, and I just came to watch and to enjoy.
Mostly, I did. But I can't help but be a little disappointed. Cummings once had a voice as good as Freddie Mercury, but that's long gone now.
You can't go back, but hey, you can try. Who can fault him for that?
No Sugar Tonight / New Mother Nature
Clap for the Wolfman
Guns, Guns, Guns
Hand Me Down World
We Just Came From The USA
Share The Land
The arrangement of "American Woman" with the extended blues intro dates back a good 40 years; listen to The Guess Who's 'Live At The Paramount 1972' album and you'll get a 16+ minute version. I thought Burton throwing in a little nod to one of his greatest inspirations (Jim Morrison) was pretty cool.
The diatribes against the karaoke version of The Guess Who were kind of a buzzkill. But I understand how they are taking bread off his table as well as tricking casual fans, such as Andy, into seeing a fake version of the band. It must be infuriating.
Jack | July 10, 2012 at 9:00 a.m. (report)
Pretty sure the album version doesn't start with a 10 minute long instrumental where Cummings channeled the voice of Jim Morrison in Roadhouse Blues. This is pretty much what he did: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jRjcd_-5f_Y
3 comments about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Andy Tarnoff
Published June 2, 2017
In an industry where positioning a brand as retro vintage is suddenly new and trendy, Milwaukee's Lucky Tiger doesn't even need to even try. Trademarked in Kansas City in 1935, the iconic men's brand actually stretches back to a barber shop from the 1920s, when it was a very large line of tonics and hair products.
Published May 13, 2017
Such an unlikely pairing. The blue-eyed soul of Hall & Oates, or the Brit pop of Tears For Fears? Who was better Saturday night at the Bradley Center? Depends who you're asking.
Published May 11, 2017
Milwaukee artist Ava Herrider is an animal lover, but it took her a few career changes to settle upon pet portraiture as her full-time job. Last year, she decided to do what moves her: "paint things people love," as she says. In other words, their pets.
Published May 5, 2017
TIKI torches, the outdoor oil lamps synonymous with beach parties and backyard barbecues, aren't made in Maui or Malibu. Nope, the company is based in Menomonee Falls, a city slightly less frequently associated with Polynesian party ware.
Published April 28, 2017
VW built 21 million Beetles up until 2003. Thousands of those iconic Bugs are still on the road, and one Milwaukee company exists solely to build and rebuild their air-cooled engines. Mofoco, started by Randy Henning, is now owned by his son, Roy, and quietly services VW customers around the world.
Published April 25, 2017
While planning next week's trip Up North, I started wondering just how much of Wisconsin I've seen over these last 37 years. So, I downloaded a map and started drawing on it, including the route I have planned for next week.
Published April 14, 2017
Milwaukeeans love our 414, the area code covering the city, the county and parts of Muskego and Brookfield. It's been since 1947, when Bell Telephone established it, along with 715, in Wisconsin. But why did they pick 414?
Published April 12, 2017
Maybe it was all the hard living back then. Maybe it was all the mustaches. But how old was this motley Brewers Crew back in '82?
Published April 3, 2017
The Brewers lost 89 games in 2016, finishing 30.5 behind the Cubs. Then they got rid of Chris Carter, Martin Maldonado and Tyler Thornburg. Is there anywhere to go but up?
Published March 14, 2017
In a market with plenty of big box stores, how does owning a neighborhood Ace Hardware store in this era make sense? Easy, says owners Bob and Kristin Nell. It's about customer service.