So, we're spammers, eh?
There's nothing like get nailed for having good intentions.
I got an e-mail the other day from a reader who was blocked from visiting OnMilwaukee.com because his corporate firewall used a product called siteadvisor.com to determine which sites are work-friendly. Apparently, siteadvisor.com, a McAfee product, has deemed OnMilwaukee.com as "somewhat spammy."
Awhile ago our "e-mail this to a friend" feature had a bug in it. This bug would randomly cause some people to get many identical e-mails over and over. It was a tough bug to fix but we eventually re-wrote the whole system to take care of it.
Unfortunately, there's no way to change that rating on siteadvisor.com. There's a link for the owner of the site to leave a comment defending his or her Web site, but that doesn't resolve the problem. It also doesn't update the rating once the problem was rectified (in our case, months ago).
Quite literally, this Web site is interfering with our business operations, since we rely on visitors to drive page views that display ads. If it's not illegal, it's certainly unethical to brand us like this. We don't serve funky cookies, we don't display third-party pop-ups or pop-unders anymore, and most importantly, we NEVER send spam.
That's not to say we don't send e-mail to our nearly 38,000 registered users. But they must double opt in for newsletters like the Weekend Preview, Daily Digest, Sports Digest, Movie Newsletter, Movie Update and Kids & Family Roundup. They opt out with a single click of "unsubscribe" at the bottom of every newsletter. This couldn't be anything farther from spam.
But apparently, it took just one surly user, "GrandpaShaggy," to make us "somewhat spammy." Gramps, apparently, has posted 46 other ratings on Web sites, from porn sites to MSN. He seems to be a bit of a conspiracy theorist, or at the very least not very Web-savvy, for if he thinks we "ettempted [sic] to place 99 cookies" on his machine, he's just plain wrong.
What can you do? Post your own comment at this disturbing Web site, letting other users know that we're not spammers -- we're just trying to tell great Milwaukee stories to our 1.2 million monthly readers.
If you like getting the Weekend Preview and our other great free offerings, please do chime in. Because if siteadvisor gets its way, you may find yourself blocked from OnMilwaukee.com in the future.
As always, thanks for your support.
I have seen sites with worse ads than yours get rated green from SiteAdvisor. I am considering getting a siteadvisor reviewer account then going to their website and rating them bad.
I still run siteadvisor in one browser but I now pay very little attention to its yellow and even red ratings. Many times I post a good rating for good website where I find siteadvisor has mis-categorized it with a yellow or red rating. That is pretty much the only reason I keep sideadvisor running at all and I certainly know better now than to buy any of that company's other web or computer security products. I just went over to the other browser and left a good comment at SideAdvisor for On Milwaukee...to ad to several others ahead of mine.
Many sites are rated incorrectly by siteadvisor. Sometimes the problem seems to be receiving emails after signing up for emails. Sometimes I see a notation that popups occured or malware was added where this is simply not the case and nothing like happens at the site or at the most there is one popup and only the cookies needed for cookie-based functions to run.
Maybe a reviewer clicked through an ad on the site in question and had a negative experience on a different site (at the other end of the ad) and blamed the first site. Or maybe the reviewer's computer was already malware infested so every site seems to serve pernicious popups. I don't know either how siteadvisor gets away with continuing to damage the reputation of so many website owners, even non-profit website owners who simply offer the chance for visitors to sign up for an email list
I spent a day following up on SiteAdvisor after I caught on to its tricks and found its ratings are wildly inconsistent. After investigating sites I came across in search results marked yellow and red I have not found one yet that is deserving of being marked down this way. And it is true that at first I always (needlessly) avoided search results showing anything other than green! Of course I am referring to an array topics where only a small percentage of websites are likely to be ill intentioned - I don't search for adults-only material or gambling or cheap this or that.
Anyway I am happy to see someone else has noticed that SiteAdvisor is part of the problem(s) - aroundcomputer and website security and safety - rather than any effective solution.
Your website used to have online ads that that opened up if you accidentally scrolled over them and pop-up and pop-under ads all a little sneaky. Things have improved recently, but you really need to make sure you dont have any ads that appear to be Windows error messages telling you your computer needs to be optimized, or that you are the one-millionth visitor and will win something.
3 comments about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Andy Tarnoff
Published Jan. 12, 2017
I'm very concerned about the problem of "fake news" and what it means for journalists, politicians and the media-consuming public. But, really, this isn't a new concern of mine. For many years, I've battled with the concept that the internet is always right.
Published Jan. 9, 2017
On Dec. 8, Larry Hansen was injured in a horrendous and freak accident by a presumed drunk driver. While working on his car in his Okauchee garage. Five surgeries and 42 pints of blood later, Hansen has lost a leg, has a broken back and faces more surgeries.
Published Dec. 20, 2016
Last week, I was bragging about the airfare deal of a century: a $66 round-trip ticket from Milwaukee to Ft. Myers. Yesterday, I was eating my words, since my flight home was delayed from Saturday to Monday, then cancelled completely on Monday, with no reasonable option on how to get home.
Published Dec. 8, 2016
Every few years, we remind you about Chief, the hard-rocking Milwaukee band that you should check out. Why? Not because frontman Chris Tischler compares Chief to Van Halen and Judas Priest, although that's a pretty good reason to give them a listen, since they're excellent musicians.
Published Dec. 5, 2016
I wasn't really in the market for a new TV, but like so many others, I got suckered into buying a huge one on Black Friday. I was lured by the low, low prices, but also the idea of having a super-sharp 65-inch television that would be ready for 4K.
Published Nov. 30, 2016
Margaret Gintoft knew there was a chance she'd run into a Clinton after jogging near her daughter's home in Chappaqua, N.Y. Last Sunday, Gintoft and her family were hiking in Rockefeller State Park when she saw the former president and former Secretary of State.
Published Nov. 28, 2016
With almost everything available on-demand online, cable and satellite TV are pretty archaic. Today, AT&T acknowledged this by unveiling DIRECTV Now, a streaming service that will go head-to-head with cable (and its own soon-to-be-discontinued U-Verse), for $35 a month.
Published Nov. 16, 2016
Even though Cedarburg is so close to Milwaukee, when you're in its little downtown, you feel far away. And, while plenty of Milwaukeeans visit the Stagecoach Inn Bed & Breakfast for a staycation, this charming old hotel attracts plenty of people from out of town, too.
Published Nov. 15, 2016
House of Harley-Davidson announced today the expansion of its territory with the purchase of Racine Harley-Davidson.
Published Nov. 9, 2016
In this darkest moment in modern U.S. history, I'm looking for a silver lining. This is the best I've got: The president is not a king. Donald Trump cannot tear up the Constitution and keep his job.