I had lunch recently with my friend and former Milwaukee alderman Jeff¬†Pawlinski. ¬†
We discussed a number of things, and, of course, politics were included. ¬†He made an interesting point when we were discussing who could be Milwaukee's next Mayor? ¬†Who are the new young Democrats in the state? ¬†Wisconsin has a ton of younger Republican leaders, but the other side of the isle seems to be a bit old. ¬†
I told Jeff to blog his thoughts, and here they are. ¬†Enjoy, and react. ¬†
Former Milwaukee Alderman asks, Do Democrats have a hope?
Governor Scott Walker is a rock star. ¬†Congressman Paul Ryan is a rock star too. And opening acts in the Wisconsin Republican Party's version of The World Series of Rock include Lt. Governor Rebecca Kleefisch, Assembly Speaker and U.S. Senate Candidate Jeff Fitzgerald and his brother, current State Senate Majority Leader Scott Fitzgerald.
And what do these Wisconsin Republicans have in common? They are all in their political prime and they are all under 50 years old. Which begs the question: Who are the bright young Democrats poised for party leadership and capable of challenging this Republican fab five? Crickets. ¬†Anyone?
The fact is there are no young Democratic leaders that come close to rivaling these Republican heavy weights. The old guard of Herb Kohl, 77, Russ Feingold, 59, and 3-time gubernatorial loser, Mayor Tom Barrett, age 58, are retiring, retired and tired.
The Democrats haven't done a good job of cultivating new talent, particularly women. I personally like and voted for Kathleen Falk in the Democratic recall primary. But at 60 and with no constituency, the Democrats rejected her in favor of the Walter Mondale of Wisconsin politics, Tom Barrett.
Democratic Congresswoman and US Senate candidate Tammy Baldwin is probably the de facto party leader now. She's 50, has a significant Madison following but faces a tough November election - especially considering Scott Walker's recall triumph - which may have tilted Wisconsin red for the first time since Reagan's 1984 re-election. I believe Speaker Jeff Fitzgerald will be the Republican nominee for US Senate and if Baldwin loses to him, there goes another Democrat. Congressman Ron Kind, 49 has shown no interest in leaving his cozy La Crosse congressional seat. He twice passed on bids to run for Governor. Mahlon Mitchell, 35 acquitted himself nicely, garnering over one million votes for Lt. Governor. He's bright and articulate but with no base other than public employee unions, what are his prospects?
Locally, Milwaukee Common Council President Willie Hines, 47, is the Democrat's brightest, ready-made hope. He's a smart consensus builder but has shown no desire to grab the regional leadership mantle many want him to pursue. After 8 years in council leadership he has yet to separate himself from Mayor Tom Barrett on any issue of substance. State Senators Lena Taylor, 45 and Chris Larson, 31 are too polarizing to appeal to voters outside their legislative cocoons and their 21-day Illinois protest of Walker's budget will always irk many voters.
So strangely, and perhaps for the first time in decades, the future for the Democrats may reside in Milwaukee County Government. After all, Milwaukee County Government gave us Republican Governor Scott Walker. Is The County the new hotbed for developing party leadership? County Executive Chris Abele is 45, personally wealthy and hard to pin down as a moderate or a liberal. So far, in tax policy he's just a conservative as Walker was. He's raw but smart enough to surround himself with talented staff to offset his weaknesses. Is he even interested in partisan elective office though?
His chief rival on policy, as well as a potential Democratic Party destiny, seems to be Milwaukee County Board Chairwoman Marina Dimitrijevic, 30. Dimitrijevic is an interesting case. She's young but already an 8 year County Board veteran. She's driven and savvy enough to have established her own PAC to cultivate new comers to public office. Building personal and party loyalty with a singular purpose of political advancement separates her from her peers. She, in my opinion, is the only woman and perhaps the only regional Democrat on the horizon.
The fact is the Republicans have a loaded bench in addition to their starting five. The Democrats are the aging team looking for an infusion of youthful talent while having simultaneously neglected their farm system. It's a fatal combination.
So where do the Democrats go from here? The first rule of rehab is admitting you have a problem. And the Democrats have a huge problem. No more excuses, finger pointing, blaming, protesting and hoping the John Doe investigation eventually stings Scott Walker. It's time to get to work cultivating young adults interested in public service. Their future depends on it.
-Jeff Pawlinski¬†is a health care marketing executive and a former Milwaukee Alderman.
No rising stars in the Dim party? Come on how about bike lock girl, segway boy and everyone's favorite beer dumping cross dresser? Oh and more recently crying man! How are Walker, Johnson, Ryan and the Fitzgerld brothers going to stand up to that line up?
Maybe if you had policies that didn't only appeal to crazys (like a trolly to the land of make believe) you might attract some sane people!
Mark A Sity
Agreed with Dave - Clarke isn't a democrat
As a moderate bay viewer that leans left, there really isn't a democrat that I would hang my hat on. Simply put, the MKE democrats have not delivered - Larson, Richards, etc. Too much whining about the current regime at the expense of coming up with real solutions.
I don't have an answer for the democrats so I'm praying for some legitimate moderate conservatives....
Charlie Sykes made the best point on this issue when he said, "We have Paul Ryan and they have Gwen Moore".
To me the Democrats face a few problems. The first is that government spending finally reached a tipping point where I think many people understand that we can't keep spending money the way we have. Being fiscally conservative and a Democrat is not something we usually see. The things is, if there were fiscally conservative Democrats I think they'd be popular because economic conservatives like myself are often turned off by the Republicans on social issues.
The second is that there has not been any Democratic answers to the issues of today. You might not like Paul Ryan or Scott Walker, but what's the Democrat's plan? Tom Barrett never answered the question on how he would have balanced the State's budget. So the candidates seem to lack substance on their side of the aisle.
I think they have also let some of their worst people assume leadership roles. Lena Taylor does not represent her side well. Chris Larson is not the best guy to have as a leader. To put people like this at the forefront makes the party look bad. Again, compare this to Paul Ryan or Ron Johnson.
Show me the other Talkback
6 comments about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Jeff Sherman
Published March 18, 2017
I'm again calling for the creation of a new, Lake Michigan Milwaukee fountain. Milwaukee means water, and what better way to showcase our connections to fresh water than a giant fountain in Lake Michigan.
Published Feb. 19, 2017
Milwaukee's made yet another list: Thrillist Travel's "Underappreciated American Cities You Should Totally Move To." Published today, the list highlights 16 "underappreciated cities" that are "all dark-horse candidates to help you author your best move ever."
Published Feb. 13, 2017
Lists are lists, but we should all be proud to share a new one from Inc., "3 Unexpected Places That Are Actually Amazing for Startups." Because, you guessed it, Milwaukee's on it.
Published Feb. 8, 2017
The annual U.S. News & World Report city rankings are out, and Milwaukee leaped up 25 spots in just one year, from 72 in 2016 to 47 this year - placing just ahead of Kansas City and behind Honolulu.
Published Feb. 7, 2017
Basketball legend-turned-author and political activist Kareem Abdul-Jabbar is coming back to Milwaukee on March 2 to give a speech and take questions at The Milwaukee Theatre.
Published Feb. 6, 2017
It's media. It's all media. Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, Rex, Twitter, LinkedIn, whatever platforms you use - you use them to read, interact, live, shop and make your life happen.
Published Feb. 3, 2017
Created by Dana Calvo and based on a nonfiction book by Lynn Povich, "Good Girls Revolt" is a great look into the drama of a news organization at a time when attitudes, mind sets and gender roles were changing.
Published Feb. 2, 2017
There are many amazing neighborhoods and streets in Milwaukee, all with unique flavor, personality and reasons to visit. But if you had to pick one, just one street, which would be your favorite? Here I make the case for mine.
Published Jan. 27, 2017
I was a bit taken Aback when I stopped at Goody Gourmets in Shorewood yesterday, and saw it closed. No need to worry, though, the space is just getting a facelift and ripping out some old carpet. The popcorn, in all of its amazingness, will remain the same.
Published Jan. 1, 2017
To begin 2017, I've compiled a few thoughts, inspirational nuggets and observations that may help power you to help make this the best year yet. It's a list I've kept for a while and refer to often. Figured it was time to share it.