John Raettig's my neighbor, a local developer and developer of the the Cawker Building in which I own a condo.
Today, I received an e-mail Raettig sent to Ald. Robert Bauman. It explains his ideas for Sydney HIH. It's posted below so I'll let it do the talking, and you can react to his thought via Facebook and the Talkbacks.
At the recent Zoning, Neighborhoods and Development committee meeting, I listened toDepartment of City Development and Milwaukee Economic Development Corporation officials present a spirited, but uninspiring discussion about the current economic development challenges at the Park East TIFF.
I am late to the Sydney HIH debate. Lack of bureaucratic transparency contributed to my delay.
Plus, I am a busy guy. But before you vote on whether or not to demolish these buildings, let me offer a private developer's perspective.
I hold a Bachelors & Masters Degree in Architecture from UWM. I have been redeveloping historic, architecturally significant and obsolete properties for my own account and with partners since 1995. For 16 years, I have been a licensed Commercial Real Estate Broker. I live in the 4th Aldermanic District.
A few of my past projects are near City Hall. If you walk down the 700 block of Milwaukee Street, between Wisconsin and Mason, you can experience the result of my work. About 10 years ago, I purchased and repositioned seven blighted properties on that once vacant block.
With a quick walk west down Wells Street, over the river sits the Cawker Building. It was the first Downtown loft condominium conversion project. When I started selling condos there in 1996, the Cawker Building housed more pigeons than Downtown Milwaukee did people. I was laughed at for predicting that the Condominiums would sell out prior to renovations. The pigeons are not laughing now.
The Sydney HIH properties are viable
Some at the City hope to demolish Sydney HIH to make way for bigger and better ... and I fear imaginary ... development. Historic or not, the Sydney HIH properties exist. Their future, whether they are to be renovated or demolished, is best determined by a private owner. Whatever connotations have been attached to the building's past is of little relevance to its future.
Perhaps Milwaukee taxpayers are best served if City Government encourages the redevelopment of all buildings that might be returned to the tax rolls, no matter the perceived condition.
I have learned that an MEDC affiliate paid $769,000 for Sydney HIH in November 2011. But they now contend the buildings are worthless. Milwaukee has many MEDC "development sites" cleared and waiting for action. The property at 4th & Wisconsin and the grass lot at 2nd & Wells come to mind. Each of these empty lots symbolizes a lost group of buildings, and a missed opportunity.
From an economic development perspective, Milwaukee's turn of the century architecture offers more than sentimental journeys. These buildings quietly serve an important role as the incubators and laboratories of small business innovation. They offer price conscience, informal space with inherent architectural character. The freedom to enterprise that fosters limitless job creation often begins in older buildings. Many of Milwaukee's dynamic young companies can attest to that fact. The Sydney HIH can offer the same vital opportunity at Park East to a new generation of downtown entrepreneurs.
Small business drives the economic traffic responsible for solid demographic statistics. Foot traffic, daily car counts, occupancy statistics, and sales figures can be enhanced by including a small business component in the Park East strategy. Large corporations use these statistics to make their site selections. Small business activity can affirm the economic viability of a neighborhood, or create it. Successful small business will attract successful big business. For the Park East, the attraction cycle can launch at Sydney HIH.
Here are the numbers
My financial analysis for each of the four Sydney HIH properties shows that, if saved from demolition and renovated, the four Sydney HIH buildings could together produce annual property tax revenue of $98,957.67 dollars per year. An empty MEDC owned lot ... produces nothing.
My property tax figure does not include other local taxes that a successful private redevelopment would generate. Building permits, parking meters, loading zones, sales tax, stadium tax, convention center district tax, BID district tax, occupancy permits, garbage fees, liquor licenses, sign permits, sidewalk permits, dumpster permits, dance hall licenses, outdoor seating permits, health department permits, personal property taxes on each tenant's fixtures and furniture, annual building inspection fees, sprinkler inspections, façade inspections, etc, and the interests and penalties if one tax is overlooked. This list is off the top of my head. If I've forgotten a tax that is near and dear to your heart, forgive me.
The bottom line – That's a lot of tax revenue! If DCD spends the $435,000 they say it will cost to demolish Sydney HIH, all the annual tax revenue listed above will be lost.
Dissolve the Old Divide
A pedestrian oriented sliver of street level commerce along the Park East's stretch of Third Street will help Milwaukee begin to dissolve the physical and economic separation between Old World Third Street and Dr. Martin Luther King Drive. After all, it is the same street.
A quasi-suburban style corporate campus, hotel, or big box retail development at this location can become a psychological barrier that inhibits new connections with downtown.
Large developments alone without some amount of small scale development will perpetuate the unintended separation of neighborhoods, just like the old highway spur. The Sydney HIH stands ready to begin this process of rebuilding neighborhood connections.
A complimentary approach
While DCD does the important work of recruiting national business to the Park East, let Milwaukee's small businesses start to make important Park East selling points tangible at Sydney HIH. Complimentary economic development activities, a true private / public partnership, will produce the best long term results for the Park East and Milwaukee.
Maybe along the way, Milwaukee's entrepreneurs will plant the seeds of future, home grown corporate headquarters at Park East. After all, Harley Davidson started in a small garage.
Manpower was once a start-up too ... on the ground floor of the Cawker Building.
Your vote to save the Sidney HIH buildings does not signal that you are against new development. On the contrary, your vote to save the Sydney HIH says you support realistic, attainable development. Development that encourages all of Milwaukee's small business community. Development that will help Milwaukee attract large businesses. Development that creates jobs, revives a once vibrant urban fabric, and grows the tax base.
That new vision for vitality at the Park East TIFF can begin today by ending the Raze Order that is set to destroy yet another productive opportunity.
I just saw this article, what can I do to help John Raettig's cause. Its not in my alderman's district but any thing from letter writing to showing up at the common council meeting (not much of a public speaker) to show report. Please let me know.
I wouldn't be overly concerned about the cockroaches. People said the same thing about the Schlitz buildings before they were renovated, and they turned out great. The Sydney HIH buildings have a rich history. I think it would be a shame to tear them down and replace them with new, generic construction.
I think the renovation will remove the rats and crumbs also. The original structure is unique and given a good plan, can make it look wonderful. Its short sighted to say that "it was crap because look at it in the past" is short sighted.
Honestly, I had some very good times in the Sidney HIH building. I had many great Vietnamese dinners there and shopped in the head shops there. But truthfully, the entire time I was in that building, I wondered how many roaches were crawling on the floor and how many rats were waiting for the crumbs. I also wondered, if a fire started, how fast it would go up and if I would be able to get out before it did. I love the architecture of Milwaukee. I am a proponent of preservation when the building is sound. But Sidney HIH is not one of those buildings and it wasn't in the early 60's either. Please let it die a well-deserved death!
4 comments about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Jeff Sherman
Published Feb. 19, 2017
Milwaukee's made yet another list: Thrillist Travel's "Underappreciated American Cities You Should Totally Move To." Published today, the list highlights 16 "underappreciated cities" that are "all dark-horse candidates to help you author your best move ever."
Published Feb. 13, 2017
Lists are lists, but we should all be proud to share a new one from Inc., "3 Unexpected Places That Are Actually Amazing for Startups." Because, you guessed it, Milwaukee's on it.
Published Feb. 8, 2017
The annual U.S. News & World Report city rankings are out, and Milwaukee leaped up 25 spots in just one year, from 72 in 2016 to 47 this year - placing just ahead of Kansas City and behind Honolulu.
Published Feb. 7, 2017
Basketball legend-turned-author and political activist Kareem Abdul-Jabbar is coming back to Milwaukee on March 2 to give a speech and take questions at The Milwaukee Theatre.
Published Feb. 6, 2017
It's media. It's all media. Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, Rex, Twitter, LinkedIn, whatever platforms you use - you use them to read, interact, live, shop and make your life happen.
Published Feb. 3, 2017
Created by Dana Calvo and based on a nonfiction book by Lynn Povich, "Good Girls Revolt" is a great look into the drama of a news organization at a time when attitudes, mind sets and gender roles were changing.
Published Feb. 2, 2017
There are many amazing neighborhoods and streets in Milwaukee, all with unique flavor, personality and reasons to visit. But if you had to pick one, just one street, which would be your favorite? Here I make the case for mine.
Published Jan. 27, 2017
I was a bit taken Aback when I stopped at Goody Gourmets in Shorewood yesterday, and saw it closed. No need to worry, though, the space is just getting a facelift and ripping out some old carpet. The popcorn, in all of its amazingness, will remain the same.
Published Jan. 1, 2017
To begin 2017, I've compiled a few thoughts, inspirational nuggets and observations that may help power you to help make this the best year yet. It's a list I've kept for a while and refer to often. Figured it was time to share it.
Published Dec. 8, 2016
Milwaukee Downtown, the business improvement district in Downtown Milwaukee, is selling its annual ornament. This year, it's the Wisconsin Club, 900 W. Wisconsin Ave.