Of all the ailments that plague the human species, age is the most trusted, diligent and effective soldier in deathâ€™s army. When deathâ€™s other agents â€“ cancer, war, human callousness and cruelty â€“ fall short, age is called in to finish the job. And though he takes his time, thereâ€™s no arguing with his success rate. No matter how much you try to dodge or avoid or fend him off, age comes for us all.
But what if it â€¦ didnâ€™t? Thatâ€™s the obvious yet unanswerable essential question driving Bill Andrews and Aubrey de Gray, the two scientists at the center of "The Immortalists," the thoroughly compelling new doc currently showing at the Milwaukee Film Festival.
Forget fountains of youth and holy grails; Andrews and de Gray are using genuine science, not mysticism or miracles, to tap into manâ€™s potential for eternal life. Though their missions are the same, the two men and semi-rivals (a doctorâ€™s visit can only be described as a health-off) share little else in common.
Straight-laced long distance marathon enthusiast Andrews thinks heâ€™s found the key in telomerase, a substance that could potentially keep the little caps on the end of our chromosomes from deteriorating away â€“ and therefore keep a human being from deteriorating away. The only, teeny tiny problem with his solution: Some believe it might cause cancer.
On the other hand, the sprawlingly bearded de Gray is one of those vehemently against Andrewsâ€™ solution. In fact, de Grayâ€™s theory involves the complete opposite: cleaning up human cells entirely of telomerase, plus any other junk and damage that clogs it up.Â
While the two of them hunt for answers â€“ and funding, namely in Andrewsâ€™ case â€“there are those against their mission to solve the great mystery of human aging. For instance, thereâ€™s Dr. Leonard Hayflick, who uncovered a massive breakthrough back in the earliest days of cellular aging research but sees the current research into eternal life and essentially stopping time as a foolâ€™s errand (think of him as a kind of scientific version of 1972 Miami Dolphins). Plus, for him, death gives us a chance to celebrate life. Considering the cold funeral footage that follows that statement, though, it seems clear where the film stands.
The filmâ€™s leanings are made only clearer with the introduction of Dr. Colin Blakemore, a skeptic nicknamed on screen as "The Old Guard" (de Gray and Andrews get noble titles like "The Crusader" and "The Marathon Man"). Blakemoreâ€™s concerns, however, are valid, echoing the scientific and ethical concerns of a fellow â€“ albeit fictional â€“ doctor, Ian Malcolm. Are these scientists so preoccupied with whether or not they could that theyâ€™re not stopping to think if they should?
Coming in at a brisk, bite-sized 78 minutes, "The Immortalists" doesnâ€™t particularly stop too long to ask itself those questions either. Still, even when given only the quickest nods, the ethical and philosophical conversations are fascinating. Can humanity survive its enhanced survival, a world of the hungry, thirsty neverdead? What will people do when their internal countdown strikes zero but then keeps going? Do scientific breakthroughs need to wait for the world to be ready for them?
These are big, complex ideas, surrounded by equally complex science, yet little in "The Immortalists" feels like a lecture or weighed down by import. Itâ€™s a sharp, swift, compulsively watchable doc that nicely brings the audience into the world of those who will, as their motto says, "live forever or die trying."
It helps that co-directors Dave Alvarado and Jason Sussberg have two subjects as complex and as interesting as the breakthroughs theyâ€™re trying to develop. Andrews and de Gray arenâ€™t only great in relating their big concepts and biological theories â€“ not a small feat â€“ bringing the ideas down to a laymanâ€™s level with clarity and energy with the help of some nifty little graphics. Both men lead fascinating lives, inside and out of the lab.
Andrews is the filmâ€™s real pathos figure, a man driven to fight lifeâ€™s limitations while witnessing them all around him â€“ his Alzheimerâ€™s-ridden father, his cancer-struck colleague and even himself, nearing 60.
de Gray, however, is the real star. Brash, bold and rocking a beard that could make the cast of "Duck Dynasty" reach for the Rogaine, heâ€™s a man of such odd character and droll wit â€“ something that pleasingly infects the rest of "The Immortalists" as well â€“ that he could support a whole film on his own. He drops fascinating scientific and biological ideas in between swigs of a tasty brew (even in the midst of a typical talking head interview). He participates in naked picnics with his significantly older wife. His idea of a pick up line? "Justify your existence."
Heâ€™s a great character visually and intellectually, one who grows even more complex as the doc goes along. By the end, itâ€™s uncertain if he is simply doing this because, well, why not, or if perhaps itâ€™s to create a future and worldview similar to his own â€“ one involving multiple girlfriends spread across the country (with his wifeâ€™s approval).
Though its brevity (especially in a festival) is welcome, "The Immortalists" could stand to go another 15 minutes or so to go deeper into the bigger ethical and philosophical questions briefly touched upon. A public debate, for instance, between Blakemore and de Gray seems to end as quickly as it begins, unfortunate since itâ€™s a great opportunity to address those questions and add some extra dramatic heft.
Maybe itâ€™s fitting, though, to want more time from a movie about wanting more time.
"The Immortalists": ***1/2
"The Immortalists" shows one more time at the Milwaukee Film Festival on Monday, Sept. 29 at 7:15 p.m. at the Times Cinema.
No Talkbacks for this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Matt Mueller
Published Sept. 20, 2017
October may be the month of Halloween, but Netflix's freshly announced lineup of new additions is nothing to be scared of. From familiar names to new seasons of Netflix hits, here's everything you'll be watching in October.
Published Sept. 20, 2017
I hope you finished your Netflix binge of, well, pretty much every television show out there, because the streaming service is losing a lot of your favorite TV programs next month. Here's everything leaving next month.
Published Sept. 19, 2017
Monday night's premiere of "Dancing with the Stars" marked the reality competition show's 25th year of existence. But why did this quarter-century extravaganza feel so stripped down? Here are our thoughts on the show - and the dances!
Published Sept. 18, 2017
Gather up your quarters, Milwaukee. Hot off the news of one arcade bar, Up-Down, moving into town, the fittingly named 1983 Arcade Bar also announced its plans to bring a blast to the past to the city.
Published Sept. 16, 2017
The only thing better than Milwaukee Film Festival tickets? Free festival tickets - and that's exactly what Milwaukee Film, Associated Bank and Stone Creek Coffee want to give you next week, Sept. 18-20.
Published Sept. 14, 2017
Wait no longer, fellow film fanatics: Today, Milwaukee Film officially cracked open its box office to the public. Here's how to get your tickets - plus some recommendations and program book Easter eggs to help fill out your schedule.
Published Sept. 13, 2017
The Milwaukee Bucks sent out an official call today, inviting all singers and musicians - individuals or groups - to audition for the chance to perform "The Star-Spangled Banner" at a regular season home game this season.
Published Sept. 13, 2017
For those who can't get enough of the Brewers' current playoff push, bonus baseball is headed to Milwaukee this weekend, as the Brew Crew's three-game series against the Miami Marlins has been moved to Miller Park.
Published Sept. 12, 2017
It takes a lot of nerve to adapt Stephen King's monolithic "It" for the big screen. Unfortunately, save for coulrophobics and globophobes, the final product takes far less nerve to watch as a potent horror movie.
Published Sept. 12, 2017
Maybe it was because Chris Harrison was having a bad night, or maybe there was a gas leak in my house, but Monday night's season finale of "Bachelor in Paradise" was a honest-to-god hoot - a laugh riot even!