During the first half of the 20th century, there was no more popular sport in Milwaukee than professional boxing. In fact, this city has a rich legacy of great fighters -- Bob Moha, Gus Christie, Richie and Pinkey Mitchell, Joey Sangor, to name the best -- and great fights -- Jack Dempsey, Benny Leonard and Sugar Ray Robinson fought here -- that is about to be stomped by the so-called revival of the sport Saturday night at the US Cellular Arena after a dormant spell of 13 years.
Headlining what is being advertised as the "Brew City Brawl" are superblobs Eric "Butterbean" Esch and Harry Funmaker, of Fond du Lac. Going by their size, both are champions with a knife and fork; but in the ring it's a vastly different tale.
Butterbean, 400 pounds of vanilla pudding, is a veteran of the Toughman circuit who has lately also dabbled in Mixed Martial Arts fighting. He had a brief run in boxing in the 1990s when promoter Bob Arum (famous for once telling reporters, "Yesterday I was lying, today I'm telling you the truth") anointed him the "King of the Four-Rounders" and sent him out to battle against a vast array of forgettable palookas, some of whom later were discovered to not be who they said they were and/or were judged to have executed artless belly flops designed to enhance the PR myth that Butterbean was one bad dude in the ring.
The first time he lost, by knockout to a journeyman named Mitch Rose in 1995 at Madison Square Garden, Rose said afterwards that he had turned down a $5,000 bribe to join the motley crew of Butterbean's vanquished opponents.
Several months before his death in 2004, Pulitzer Prize winning investigative reporter Jack Newfield, who loved boxing, wrote a story about an FBI probe into fixed fights in which he said, anent Butterbean:
"The reputable BoxRec archive Web site names several fights in which Butterbean's opponent appeared to take a dive, including his matches with Marcus Rhode, Bill Johnson and Bill Duncan.
"Oklahoma suspended Duncan for faking his performance after he went down in two rounds. James Calvin Baker has admitted faking his 18-second knockout loss to Butterbean in 1996. BoxRec also says several of Butterbean's â€˜opponents' appeared under false names. Darryl Becker (0-7) lost to Butterbean under the alias of Jack Ramsey. James Holly, who had a record of 3-41, fought a â€˜no-contest' with Butterbean under the alias of James Robinson.
"(Bob) Arum often warded Butterbean prized, high-profile showcases on pay-per-view shows that gave him the status of a cult hero among unsophisticated fans. Artificial build-ups of â€˜white hypes' are a carnival staple of modern boxing."
Now, the carnival comes to Milwaukee, with boxing fans urged to "be a part of history in the making" by coming out to watch the Bean, in the final "fight" of his career, mix it up against poor Funmaker, whose 17 losses in 34 recorded bouts already include two to Butterbean and one to the equally absurd Peter McNeeley (the manufactured contender who promised to ensnare Mike Tyson in a "cocoon of horror" in their 1995 fight, and then lasted 95 seconds). According to BoxRec, Funmaker hasn't fought in four years. On top of which, Harry, whose last recorded weight was 262 pounds, is 46 years old.
This isn't boxing history, but rather a big, wet, brown debasement of it and the achievements of the fighters and promoters who once made Milwaukee a big-league boxing town.
Wisconsin used to have a boxing commission that regulated the sport here. In its early days, it was considered the best in the whole country when it came to seeing that boxing was conducted on a totally above-board and legitimate basis. Back in 1918, it even had the cajones to tell the famous Jack Dempsey to take a hike when the Manassa Mauler wanted to come here and bowl over some no-hoper nobody had ever heard of before.
The commission was put out of commission back in 1980, and since then boxing has been under the purview of the State Dept. of Regulation and Licensing, which demonstrated its expertise in the matter in 1990 and made Wisconsin a national laughingstock when the DRL famously permitted half-blind, cocaine-addicted Aaron Pryor to fight in Madison because to do otherwise would constitute discrimination against the handicapped. (Pryor "knocked out" his opponent, who turned out to be one of his best friends.)
As a boxing fan and writer about the sport for 47 years, come Saturday night I will do my part for the Sweet Science by doing anything but attending the circus at the US Cellular Arena.
The hosts of this event should be applauded. Giving Milwaukeeans a chance to see boxing again. Relive some memories from their childhood when fathers used to take sons to see a bout. No, its not Hollyfield VS Tyson but its $10 family entertainment. Good work fellas!
Belly on up to MMA then. Boxing is on life support and any attempt to revive interest should be applauded. If OMC is such a supporter where are the sponsored bouts with local fighters to drum up support?
Boxing is no longer a relevant sport in America...and for that matter around the world. Things have moved passed it...viewers have changed. For better or worse, the whole pack of MMA leagues (or whatever they are called) have ascended to the thrown that boxing once held. Maybe the hardcore fan still thinks that boxing is relevant, but it's not a main stream sport anymore.
And to believe this is what Dave Begal prefers over MAA/UFC.......................*sigh*.....................
The Boxing and Wrestling Commission used to get 10% of the gate as part of their license and regulatory aspects. Wrestling? Yep, even Wrestling. (Maybe Gov Doyle will bring back the Wrestling Tax). Boxing promoters got tired of the extortion and quit bringing cards to Wisconsin.
5 comments about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by OnMilwaukee.com Staff Writers
Published April 29, 2017
The great Milwaukee weekend is here ... and so is your Weekend Preview! Make it a great one!
Published April 27, 2017
After the Bucks split the first four games of their first-round Eastern Conference playoff series against the Raptors, the team travels back to Toronto for Game 5 and will again host a viewing party in Milwaukee to allow fans to come out and cheer the deer together on Monday night.
Published April 26, 2017
Now that spring is just about to kick off, you'll be able to raise the first of many steins at an area beer garden soon.
Published April 24, 2017
The 11th annual Milwaukee Italian Film Festival - which debuted in 2007 at Marquette's Varsity Theater - premieres eight acclaimed Italian films, April 28-30, at University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee's Union Theater, 2200 E. Kenwood Blvd.
Published April 23, 2017
Whether your kid is more bouncy or more craft-oriented, there's a Brew City birthday party that can accommodate his / her wishes - and hopefully your budget.
Published April 23, 2017
For the past 15 years, artist Nicolas Lampert has focused on connecting local artists to Milwaukee social justice organizations, such as Voces de la Frontera and ReciproCity, Milwaukee Neighborhood News Service reports.
Published April 22, 2017
Just choose a few containers or locate some spots in the garden where you can include these bold-leafed beauties. Before you know it, you'll be sipping your favorite beverage in your very own tropical garden.
Published April 20, 2017
Now that "Pet Sounds" is celebrating its 51st birthday, the Beach Boys are traveling the world and celebrating the album one last time. That included a stop at Riverside Theater on Wednesday night, where they filled the auditorium with their smooth, melodic tunes.
Published April 20, 2017
Your Milwaukee Bucks are in the playoffs! If you can't make it to the festive atmosphere at the BMO Harris Bradley Center pull up a stool at any one of these great options.
Published April 17, 2017
Despite some less-than-grand attempts by the FAA to educate the public, drones still remain an issue that most people do not understand, both in their functions and in the laws surrounding them. So let's dig into some of the basics.