I’ve been hearing about Tenuta’s, 2995 S. Clement Ave., in Bay View from a few friends over the past few years, so I thought I’d finally pay a visit.
My friend and I stopped in around 4:30 on a Sunday afternoon. There were a couple of guests at the bar and a few tables already occupied, a good sign considering they opened merely 30 minutes before.
Warm colors on the walls, stained glass above the entrance, and plenty of natural light from the large picture windows provided a comfortable setting.
Owner Frank Tenuta was on site, but General Manager Brenden Fuerstenau kindly took some time and filled me in on the history of the restaurant.
Frank Tenuta’s parents moved here from Italy in 1966. His father worked for DeRango’s in Racine and later took ownership of the restaurant. There are currently several DeRango’s pizzerias in the Racine area, and they’re owned by at least three different families, including the Tenuta family, represented by Frank’s brother Dan.
Frank Tenuta, meanwhile, worked in his parent’s restaurant along with his brothers. Tenuta moved to the Bay View area when he married his wife, Jodi. He opened the Tenuta’s restaurant in Bay View on Dec. 19, 2003.
Most of the staff has worked at Tenuta’s for over five years. Fuerstenau has been there more than nine years and has been general manager for the past two years. Since he started out making pizzas, he was a great resource without giving away their secrets.
I peeked at the menu on the website before visiting and was surprised to see so many variations and options for pizza. Even with the preview, I still hadn’t come up with a strategy. Luckily, I had some help.
Pizza crust options include thin, virgin, deep dish, and stuffed crust, all available in 12- and 16-inch sizes.
The virgin crust is barely touched, just stretched a bit, topped and baked. The deep dish is baked in a round pan and removed before serving. The stuffed crust is the deep dish pizza topped with an extra layer of cheese and sauce.
Cheese pizzas range from $9 for thin crust to $15 for the stuffed crust. Toppings are $1.25 and $2 each, including meatballs, giardiniera, anchovies, sun dried tomatoes, artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers and cream cheese, as well as the standards.
Specialty pizzas include the margherita, diavola, meat lover, veggie and house special, which comes topped with ham, pepperoni, tomato, garlic and olive oil instead pizza sauce.
We started out with a meatball appetizer. Five large meatballs in a homemade marinara sauce arrived in a bowl. The meatballs were moist and lightly seasoned, and the marinara was thick and slightly sweet.
The first pizza we took on was a 12-inch sausage, mushroom and pepperoni on thin crust. The crust was much to my liking: very thin with a cracker crisp texture throughout, not just around the perimeter. I was impressed at how the center slices maintained a crispy crunch and held the toppings really well. I was also pleased that there were no traces of cornmeal on the crust. To my eyes, this crust was nearly perfect.
The only characteristic I didn’t notice was the light airy layer separation I like to see when I look at the side of a slice. That, however, would have been tricky with a crust this thin.
Most of the pepperoni slices were placed under the cheese, as were most of the toppings, so they didn’t get a chance to curl and crisp up. However, they did have a great spicy flavor. Tenuta’s uses fresh mushrooms on their pizzas, and they complemented the pepperoni and sausage instead of dominating over them like canned mushrooms typically do.
The sausage was moist and tender with a bit of a hot kick. Fuerstenau told me the sausage is made for Tenuta’s by a butcher in the Racine area using an old Tenuta family recipe.
The sauce is made fresh daily, starting with a canned paste which gets the secret family seasoning blend added to it. My friend thought the sauce was on the sweet side. I tasted more of a spicy sauce. Either way, we both thought it was delicious.
Tenuta’s has a garden in the back, so they grow many of their own herbs and vegetables that are used in the restaurant and try to source locally whenever possible.
Next up was the house special on a 12-inch virgin crust. Fuerstenau later told us we made the right crust choice for this particular pizza. We had no idea what to expect this crust, but I certainly was not expecting what arrived.
The crust was well over an inch thick and somewhat uneven around the perimeter. The crust was crisp, yet soft and chewy. The oil was applied enough to taste without running off the slices. The garlic was also perfectly applied and complemented the olive oil very well.
The other toppings included diced tomatoes, diced ham and pepperoni. I probably would have left the ham off of this pizza. It was slightly salty and not overwhelming, but it seemed out of place on an olive oil and garlic topped crust. It was a good pizza, but I’m just not a fan of thick crusts, so I will likely try the house special on thin crust next time.
Finally, we chose the deep dish crust over the stuffed pie, but struggled with how to top it. The diavola eventually caught our eye. It probably would have been great on a thin crust, or maybe even the virgin crust, but we ordered the diavola on the deep dish.
The pie is baked in a round pan but served on a tray instead of in the pan it was cooked in. The crust was pushing two inches around the edges and didn’t have a layer of oil on it when served.
Usually this style has a prominent buttery outer texture and flavor from the amount of oil used, but this crust was dry on the outside, yet the dough in the center was somewhat moist, so the slices were easy to eat.
The diavola is typically a spicy pizza at pizzerias that feature it on their menu, and Tenuta’s did not disappoint. The hot giardiniera is the key. We ordered it on the side so we could control the heat.
Pepperoni, pineapple and cream cheese round out the toppings. The cream cheese worked really well with the mozzarella and provided a cooling contrast to the hot giardiniera. The pineapple was likely applied for the same reason, but I would leave it off of this pizza.
This was a good pie, but I would have preferred a touch more oil in the baking to provide a buttery flavor on the crust. Maybe the stuffed crust is baked with more oil. If you order it, be sure to let me know.
Thick crust and deep dish lovers should enjoy the options at Tenuta’s. Chicago pan style fans may be disappointed, but thin crust connoisseurs should be very happy.
Tenuta’s thin crust easily makes my top ten thin crust pizzas. It will be difficult to figure out which pizzeria will get replaced. Then again, the Big Ten athletic conference has more than ten schools in it, so maybe I’ll just use their methodology. I think I can probably come up with a better logo too.
Enjoy the games this weekend with a pie from one of our local pizzerias. On Wisconsin!
No Talkbacks for this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Rick Rodriguez
Published Feb. 9, 2017
Milwaukee loves pizza. Our neighborhoods are filled with pizzerias - all unique, bursting with flavor and filled with storied histories. One Milwaukeean has eaten his way through the lion's share. His hard work translates into your guide to great pizza in greater Milwaukee.
Published Oct. 11, 2016
Rick Rodriguez has been blogging about his search for the perfect pizza for four years. Now that he's retiring from his post, he shares some favorite spots from the past few years as well as parting words for readers who've followed his adventure.
Published Sept. 7, 2016
In his 100th pizza blog, Rick ventures out to Waukesha where, upon the recommendation of a friend or two, he tries pizza, garlic cheese bread and ponza rottas from Jimmy's Grotto. What's a ponza rotta? Well, you'll have to read to find out.
Published Aug. 3, 2016
Rick Rodriguez says he doesn't think he's ever written about a pizza place as new as Fixture Pizza Pub. In this installment of his pizza blog, he gives the lowdown on the space, the food and a few other interesting facts about the owners and offerings.
Published July 15, 2016
Rick Rodriguez is often asked "who makes the best pizza?" or "who makes your favorite pizza?" The latter is a difficult question to answer, and the former is nearly impossible to answer. Still, here are some his top picks for Milwaukee pizza.
Published July 6, 2016
Sometimes Rick Rodriguez looks in unexpected places for pizza - like Shaker's Cigar Bar, for instance. But does this venue that regularly gets onto lists of the most haunted bars in America make the cut when it comes to delicious pizza?
Published June 1, 2016
Despite a sizable menu that includes hand-tossed pizzas, pizza blogger Rick Rodriguez dings Zayna's Pizza for the dense crust and a Mexican pizza on which the toppings "could use a little tweaking."
Published May 4, 2016
The folks at Carini's La Conca D'Oro have a long and storied history, with roots in Italy. They serve up authentic Neapolitan pizza, along with other Italian dishes including a variety of seafood entrees.
Published April 6, 2016
It's not often Rick Rodriguez writes about reader-selected spots. But the words "thin crust," "good pizza" and "small bar" were repeated by enough people that he felt a visit to Scotty's was warranted.
Published March 2, 2016
In addition to pizza, Albanese's offers a slew of specials, including wings, Sicilian style pork chops and Italian style fish fry on Fridays. They also happen to have gluten free pizza that's worth seeking out.