Nomad under fire for World Cup favela, owner vows to keep the art on display
Gallery: World Cup on Brady Street
The world's focus has turned to Rio de Janeiro and Brazil, which host the 2014 FIFA World Cup with matches beginning on Thursday.
Like many communities around the globe, Milwaukee has sought to capitalize on the intense interest in the matches by creating a soccer-friendly vibe across the city.
One local business owner, Mike Eitel, decided to construct a "Nomad Favela" alongside his Nomad World Pub, which is located at 1401 E. Brady St., but his idea drew a firestorm of criticism on Wednesday through various websites, blogs and social media outlets.
"We're not going to change the name, change what it is or tear it down," Eitel said. "That's not going to happen."
He then addressed some of the direct complaints about the idea, many of which leveled racist charges at him.
"These are people who didn't know what a favela was a week ago, much less what the word was, much less that there was even strife associated with the World Cup," he said. "There's a lot of discussion that can be had about not just what's going on in Brazil. There's a lot going on Brazil. Nobody up here gives a (expletive) or knows about it. Now they're talking about it. So we got that far, and that's what art's supposed to do, is create the discussion."
Eitel said The Nomad always creates "iconic" imagery of the host site of the World Cup, and it was impossible to build a mountain, create a beach, or replicate the Christ the Redeemer Statue in Rio de Janeiro.
So, it made sense for The Nomad to "pay tribute" to the favela, because "that's the birthplace of street soccer," Eitel said. "It has a great passion for the game, the spirit of the people, the music, the art, the culture. We're celebrating that stuff."
The plan was to construct a bar and taco hut, along with a viewing area large enough to house six televisions. It wasn't a singular effort, as Eitel enlisted the help of local artists and craftsmen to paint and build the enclave.
BelAir Cantina tacos were to be served, too.
"We're not diminishing it, we're not belittling it, we're not exploiting it or trying to profiteer off it it," Eitel said of the favelas in Brazil. "If I was trying to profiteer, I wouldn't have built the thing. I could've just put a bar back there and been like any other Milwaukee bar and just slapped something up and made loads of money."
Of the many who took exception to what Eitel is doing, EdgeOfSports.com Sports Editor Dave Zirin, who credited the blog ginandtacos.com for bringing The Nomad to his attention, was perhaps most the critical.
Zirin recently published a book entitled "Brazil's Dance with the Devil: The World Cup, the Olympics, and the Fight for Democracy," in which he illustrates the victimization of the Brazilian poor to make way for such global sporting events.
I'll be in a Rio favela in 48 hours. Maybe we'll construct a tribute to the ignorant ugly Americans of @NomadMilwaukee.— Dave Zirin (@EdgeofSports) June 11, 2014
Dear @NomadMilwaukee: The poverty, police violence, & conditions of military occupation in favelas are no joke & it's not a samba frat party— Dave Zirin (@EdgeofSports) June 11, 2014
"He's not Brazilian. He wrote a book and he mentioned his book on the radio show, so it's like OK, you're accusing me of exploiting people for profit, and then you're mentioning your book about the favela," said Eitel, who appeared on WTMJ 620-AM along with Zirin earlier in the evening on Wednesday.
"Are you manufacturing that to sell a book? Who's the one profiteering on the favela? I would make more money if I didn't build the favela.
"So I don't see us changing course. We feel good about what we did and the intent of what we're doing and the fact that a lot of people donated a large mount of time and energy to it."
"I think it's good," Eitel said of attention, good and bad. "It created a constructive conversation and if it ends up being educational for people who don't know about what's going on in Brazil or don't know what life is like in a favela, that's great. My job is to create a really awesome space for my customers and art's job is to create a conversation. I feel like we did that."
"I stand by what we did. I feel it's a really cool thing and I think the people who come are going to think it's a really cool thing and enjoy themselves there."
The Fédération Internationale de Football Association, or FIFA, has come under fire for its practices in determining the host countries for a World Cup, and Brazilians have protested its arrival.
"They're placing these World Cups in developing countries. Is it a good thing for those countries," Eitel asked. "It's showing in South Africa and Brazil that it's probably not. So there's a discussion about that.
"What my role is, is to put the art up, create a stage for my customers, make a statement. There was absolutely no intent to offend anybody."
A Co-worker brought this up to me. How come when Nomad puts up Favela-based art as a theme for the World Cup they are criticized, but when Google puts a picture of a young boy playing soccer against a wall in a Favela on their front page for half the world to see nobody bats an eye? Also, I agree the tacos are not that great, but they are cheap and extremely conducive to eating at nomad.
I love how Mike Eitel is somehow able to spin this into "I could have made a lot more money if I didn't do this". Eitel is one of the smartest business people I've seen in Milwaukee and he knows exactly what he's doing here. For some reason his group and the Alterra guys have managed to construct an image where it seems they don't care about money when in fact they really care about the money. There's actually been a ton of talk in the media about the favela issue and whether or not Brazil is going to be better off spending all this money on the World Cup/Olympics, so Eitel should give the general public a bit more credit especially if he thinks serving tacos is culturally accurate.
Whaaaaaa Boooooo - Whaaaaaaa Boooooo... here come the PC police. Sigh. I say congrats to Nomad. Like the owner said, people were going to come there anyways. He could have set up a 6 foot long portable bar and just raked in cash. Instead he spent his own money and built a creative atmosphere. Good for him. Unfortunately for him, the last... ehhhhh, 6 or so years has done nothing but empower whineyassed babies like Dave Zirin who live life to be offended by something.
How about identifying a way to help the people in the slums/favela through doing the party and put a charitable twist on the art and game watching in that environment? Maybe that's already planned to happen though and is being left out of the reporting (hoping)? Would make a difference - more meaningful, educational and philanthropic while thematic. Just a free idea for ya - food for thought.
I agree with the last comment about the serving of those horrible tacos. Also, isn't everyone just too sensitive these days?
Show me the other Talkback
6 comments about this article.
Post a comment / write a review.
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.