A nearly perfect dining experience in Door County
On a recent trip to Door County, Scott and I enjoyed one of the best restaurant meals we've had in awhile.
We came upon this meal at a little place in Fish Creek called The Cookery.
The place, while pretty, is really nothing to look at, and it kind of reminded me of a fancy school cafeteria when we walked in. There was an all you can eat soup and salad buffet set up frilly lunch-lady style with a big tureen of whitefish chowder and big bowls of salads with various containers of toppings, and at the end of the table was an assembly of tiny sweets.
The menu was nothing fancy, and everything was reasonably priced and simple. In fact, we settled in to two lemonades and we split a perch sandwich with French fries and a grilled ham and cheese with homemade potato salad and applesauce.
But from the second we walked in the door until the moment we left, everything was perfect.
We were greeted at the door, and immediately seated by a server who seemed happy we came; our lemonades and our sandwiches came quickly and correctly. The food was hot but not too hot, the bread perfectly toasted, the fish wasn't remotely greasy, and the fries were crisp. When our drinks got low, the server came over, smiling, and refilled our glasses and when we were finishing up our plates, they were cleared. She brought our check promptly, and thanked us for coming.
It was such an all around wonderful experience. It was simple, well-thought out, and perfect. And when I left, I literally had a smile on my face and a skip in my step.
It's amazing how the little things, like a friendly greeting, a cold drink, and a basic, but extraordinarily executed sandwich and a handful of salty fries can mean so very much.
Talkbacks
jkashou | Dec. 8, 2009 at 8:04 p.m. (report)
I couldn't agree more! we visited there this summer and had a delicious dinner, they have a great wine selection and wonderful ambiance. I love the second floor wine bar.
| Rate this: |
readalot | Dec. 8, 2009 at 7:39 p.m. (report)
We've regularly dropped in at The Cookery for over 22 years and found their food, especially their whitefish chowder, delicious. Since they have remodeled and reopened, they now have both the space and the ambiance to match their service and homey food.
| Rate this: |
LegallyBlonde | Dec. 8, 2009 at 5:55 p.m. (report)
Been dining at the cookery since I was 4. My grandpa used to send the owners packers tickets for their amazing service as a thank-you. Went this summer for the first time since before the fire and I thoroughly enjoyed my dinner. Sat outside. Great wine/beer choices too, and a little swankier with the upstairs option now available.
lb
| Rate this: |
junkcafe | Dec. 8, 2009 at 3:24 p.m. (report)
Nice review. It is such a gift to enjoy the simple pleasures in life. Good to read reviews where the establishment fires on all cylinders.
| Rate this: |
jthom | Dec. 7, 2009 at 3:44 p.m. (report)
It is the same restaurant that burned down - it has been rebuilt.
| Rate this: |
Show me the other 3 Talkbacks
![]() |
8 comments about this article. Post your comment/review now |
Facebook comments
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Amy L. Schubert
Triskele's offers fall specials
Published Oct. 21, 2010
Triskele's is gearing up for the changing seasons with a fresh batch of specials.
Calderone Club has Italian cuisine and hospitality down to a science
Published Oct. 18, 2010
As far as restaurants go, few deliver the consistency of Calderone Club, the family-owned Downtown Milwaukee hangout known for terrific pizza and more.
Can change be good at "new" Trocadero?
Published Aug. 30, 2010
Trocadero, 1758 N. Water St., underwent a major facelift earlier this year which not only changed the interior and patio, but pulled out much of the French influence from the menu and pulled in the trademarks that Diablos Rojos Restaurant Group has built into its Café Hollander and Café Centraal locations.
Prime rib done right at Ward's House of Prime
Published Aug. 16, 2010
Ordering prime rib can be hit or miss when dining out. At Ward's House of Prime, 540 E. Mason St., there's little need to worry. The upscale but low-key steakhouse gets things right.
Mixed visits show Port of Call still finding sea legs
Published Aug. 9, 2010
A first weekday lunch visit brought excellent sandwiches, but a weekend stop at Port of Call had different results.
The Dubliner quashes skepticism
Published Aug. 2, 2010
It may not be a true gastropub, but The Dubliner offers diners a meal that's well above average bar fare.
Pork is the star at Jerry's Old Town
Published July 26, 2010
A trip to Jerry's Old Town in Germantown won't leave patrons confused; ribs are the featured attraction.
Surreal peacefulness of a stormy night
Published July 23, 2010
The Thursday-night storm brought childhood memories to Amy Schubert.
Limited non-alcoholic choices
Published July 19, 2010
Those looking for a non-alcoholic offering out on the town don't have many choices.
Emperor of China still one of the best
Published July 19, 2010
Sometimes when you visit a restaurant after being away for some time, you run into the "not what I remembered" curse; you remember places and food as being far superior to what you actually experience upon your return visit. That was not the case upon visiting Emperor of China.
Like Us
Follow Us











