The legend of Brew City Barbecue comes to an ignoble end Thursday with the Mequon restaurant shutting its doors, most likely for the final time.
Dennis Eisenhauer, the current owner, notified employees on Wednesday that Thursday would be the last day. According to employees they were told that traffic at the restaurant wouldn't support the restaurant.
Brew City had an incredible history among Milwaukee bars and restaurants.
It was started in the mid-80s by legendary barman Tom Shepard and paved the way for the resurgence of Water Street as a mecca for revelers, cocktail hour and great barbecue. Shepard was a magic force in Milwaukee with successful restaurants throughout the area.
He modeled his ribs after those sold at Speed Queen, a legendary Milwaukee restaurant. They were Texas-style ribs, a little tough to the bone, not the fall off the bone so popular elsewhere in the area.
But tastes and time change lots of things and before long, financial problems forced Shepard to sell his Downtown location and move to a more serene location in Mequon.
That restaurant enjoyed minor success but never recreated the halcyon days of the Water Street spot.
Eisenhauer said Thursday morning that he just couldn't keep the place running after several bad months.
"November was about 50 percent from a normal November," he said. "Then the Christmas parties were much smaller, with so many companies laying people off. And that hurt a lot. We got to February and it was getting harder and harder to keep the doors open. It's a shame. I loved this place."
One of Milwaukee's best known and popular bartenders, he said he was going to spend a couple of weeks getting the place ready for the landlord to show, and then "I'm going to have to go get a job."
I stopped in there once after the new owner took over. There was nothing that made want to come back and I never did. Too bad, it could be a nice place. Mequon needs good restaurants.
My love for Tom Shepard aside, Brew City was so much more to me than a job. It was my home where I met some of the best people in the world. I never could have imagined way back in 1991 that this job I was starting would have such an impact on me. Now, all these years later, I can't imagine what it would have been like without it.
A restaurant can be a beautiful thing when done right. I'd like to thank Tom Shepard for bringing together a great group of people and doing it right.
RIP Tom. RIP Brew City BBQ. You'll both be forever in my heart.
I used to love the downtown BrewCity BBQ! I had no idea the one in Mequon was the same owner and I had no idea they were even still in business. I went there a few times once to sit down and a couple more times I got takeout. But there was just something off on the ribs. Quality had really gone downhill. So I didn't go back. I wish him well in the future.
5 comments about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Dave Begel
Published Dec. 17, 2013
Jon Ferraro, the operator of Silk Exotic, said Tuesday he had reached a deal with the Habib Manjee, the general manager and licensee of the troubled "Ladybug nightclub," 618 Live on Water, to take over the club and open a Downtown version of the Silk strip clubs there.
Published Dec. 17, 2013
There is nothing quite like the National Football League and because of that, it is overwhelmingly the most popular sport in America. And everything that goes into making it such a juggernaut was on display in the Green Bay Packers' remarkable and thrilling victory over the Dallas Cowboys.
Published Dec. 14, 2013
In the continuing efforts to locate a gentlemen's club in Downtown Milwaukee, the operators of Silk Exotic have begun negotiations to take over operations of the Ladybug Club, also known as 618 Live on Water.
Published Dec. 14, 2013
It is not often that you get a do over in life, especially in the world of theater criticism. Once you write something, it's as if it's chiseled in granite, there for the ages. I was fortunate to get a do over Friday night when I saw the opening performance of "It's a Wonderful Life: Live Radio Show" at Next Act Theatre.
Published Dec. 12, 2013
What we tend to do is look back at the things that we wished had gone differently, or not happened at all. Then we turn our attention to the new year and our hopes for what's to come. As the song says, "regrets, we've had a few." My top 10 (or bottom 10) things and people that were on the wrong side of the ledger with me during 2013.
Published Dec. 11, 2013
It was 188 days ago that I made "The Promise" that may well turn out to destroy my self-image, mourn a milestone, make me afraid to ever show my face in public again. Or it may well be "The Promise" that fulfills my dream, celebrates a milestone, gives a little bit of pleasure to a lot of people, provides a few laughs and a chance for cocktails, and turns out a lot better than I thought.
Published Dec. 10, 2013
The Bucks seem almost to be like a car stuck in the mud. The wheels turn and they move forward a little and then they fall back. Over and over. But if there is one thing I've learned over a long time it's that when you try to fix things like an educational system or a professional basketball team, there is no silver bullet.
Published Dec. 7, 2013
We all know what a "Scrooge" is: a bitter, hateful penny-pincher with not an ounce of fun, joy or charity in his cold, cold heart. Well, watch your opinion change if you are lucky enough to see the Milwaukee Rep's 38th consecutive production of that classic holiday tale, "A Christmas Carol," at the glorious Pabst Theater.
Published Dec. 5, 2013
'Tis the season to be jolly. But what does it mean for something ike a city or a county? What makes the Milwaukee family jolly or happy? As the old year leaves at the end of holiday season Dave Begel is trying to get a handle on what we need to be a happy place.
Published Dec. 3, 2013
Has football changed so much that when your starting quarterback goes down you might as well toss your chips on the felt and walk away from the table?