Anyone with more than four Facebook friends is well aware that New Order – some of whose members were previously in Joy Division – gigged on the BMO Harris Pavilion stage at Summerfest tonight. (Were my five selfies with an empty stage behind me too much?)
Currently, New Order is on a mini tour promoting, well, nothing at all, really. The band released a B-sides compilation, "Lost Sirens," in 2013 but its last album came out in 2005 – and although it didn’t spawn coke piles of hits like records past, it has its share of addictive tracks without sounding dated.
It had been 25 years since New Order played in Milwaukee – in 1989 the group shared the stage with PIL and The Sugarcubes – a fact that New Order frontman Bernard Sumner reminded us of tonight.
If memory serves, the word-of-mouth reviews of the ‘89 show were not flattering. I remember a friend saying she would have been more entertained by a boom box blasting "Blue Monday" in front of a collection of cardboard cut-outs.
But that wasn’t the show we got tonight. Sumner, who is 58 years old, stood in the shadows with his bandmates for much of the performance, but delivered enough enthusiasm to fulfill a potentially once-in-a-lifetime concert opportunity for long-time fans.
Sumner is a resilient character, a survivor who has managed to keep his sh*t together despite the suicide of former Joy Division bandmate / friend Ian Curtis and the downward spiral of Peter Hook, bassist in both bands.
It was inspiring to see him so strong tonight. Uncharacteristic of his younger self, he even clapped his hands over his head and offered genuine sentiments of gratitude to the crowd.
Oh, how age changes us.
But fans had to wait for the goods, both old and new, to be delivered by Sumner and company.
Billed as an 8 p.m. show, New Order did not take the stage until almost 10 p.m. DJ Whitney Fierce opened the show for almost two hours and her beats seemed to drag on, at least for those of us who didn’t drop ecstasy on our way through the gates.
Once on stage, New Order played a mix of new and old material – as well as several Joy Division "covers." New songs included "Singularity" and "Plastic" – a slick, seven-minute dance-pop number that debuted at the Chicago show last night.
"It’s important as a band we continue to write new songs," Sumner said.
And even though philosophically most of us in the audience would agree with that effort, let’s face it, we were there, mostly, for the hits. We came to dance, but more so, we came to remember.
Drunk or half drunk or not, long ago we let these songs serve as anthems for overly romantic notions of failure or the overly exciting love adventures that we would someday hopefully experience and even though we have more answers now, the painful hopefulness of the songs continue to be alluring.
And indeed, the memory-triggering hits were plentiful tonight: "Ceremony," "Age Of Consent," "Bizarre Love Triangle," "True Faith," "Blue Monday" and "Temptation" all made the cut. (Considering the parade of oldies, "Loves Vigilantes" felt left out.)
Also, Joy Division songs "Atmosphere" and the fan fave "Love Will Tear Us Apart" contributed to the well-rounded set list. Although, something was a bit off about "Love Will Tear Us Apart," the second encore song, which surprisingly didn't have quite the clamoring effect live. I missed the dramatic opening and, I admit, Curtis' voice.
But overall, it was a compelling show – with some muffled-sound issues at times – but having the chance to dance and sing with a thousand or so other dark souls was worth its weight in gold. Or, at the very least, it allowed many of us to cross one more must-see concert off the bucket list.
New Order set list:
Age of Consent
Your Silent Face
Bizarre Love Triangle
5 8 6
The Perfect Kiss
Love Will Tear Us Apart
The wait was painfull with the same beat blasting forever. Agree with chadomac that the show should have been listed as 10pm. After 1.5 hour delay, we bailed at 9:30 and went to other stages. BMO and Summerfest screwed up big time. FYI, same thing happend at REO show.
Summerfest did a horrible job planning and promoting this show. Why not advertise it as 8 PM DJ Whitney Fierce, 10 PM New Order? By advertising it the way they did, they had a lot of people expecting New Order to start no later than 8:45ish. Although it wasn't her fault, the crowd turned on the DJ several times when it just wouldn't end. Nobody expected her to play 2 hours of thump-thump-thump and it became mind-numbing to those of us waiting for the headliner to start. All of this could easily been avoided. Also, having two dance acts play at a seated pavillion as opposed to one of the other more open stages seemed like a curious decision as well. Horrible experience.
2 comments about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Molly Snyder
Published Oct. 28, 2016
PC LAN is a minority-owned small business - Rexx Igunbor is the founder and CEO - that's been located in Downtown Milwaukee for over 10 years. The company moved from the East Town area to the City Center in early September.
Published Oct. 26, 2016
Almost every Milwaukeean knows about the "I Closed Wolski's" bumper sticker. But did you know there are also free "I Closed Wolski's" women's panties?
Published Oct. 26, 2016
The words "lunch" and "buffet" generally bring joy to people's hearts and stomachs, and the Bollywood Grill, 1038 N. Jackson St., has a particularly pleasing one.
Published Oct. 25, 2016
Anyone who knows John Dye or has been to his bar, Bryant's Cocktail Lounge, knows that he is a vintage lounge visionary who works vigilantly until he gets it right. Such is the case with his second project, The Jazz Estate, 2423 N. Murray Ave., which re-opens to the public on Thursday, Nov. 3. OnMilwaukee got a sneak peek today.
Published Oct. 24, 2016
Silver City, one of Milwaukee's most diverse neighborhoods, is home to some of the city's best Thai restaurants. It also offers Mexican, Laotian and American fare. Wondering where exactly Silver City is located? Keep reading.
Published Oct. 21, 2016
Shortly after arriving from Chicago, Kelsey Cano got a job at Who's On Third and has been pouring libations and connecting with people ever since. Recently, we stopped by to talk to Cano about whiskey, eye injuries, getting hit on, having a Sept. 11 birthday and more.
Published Oct. 19, 2016
Margaret J. Henningsen, a community activist who has run The Women's Fund of Greater Milwaukee since 2011, will retire on Friday. But first, she will be recognized for her rad-ness.
Published Oct. 19, 2016
It's the season of comfort food, and Milwaukeeans need to look no further than Daddy's for delicious sweater-weather eats from fried chicken to mashed potatoes to macaroni and cheese. Just say yes to gravy.
Published Oct. 18, 2016
"The Last of the Bohemians," a new show at Grove Gallery in Walker's Point, will feature 10 of the late Bob Watt's paintings. Artist and writer Jimmy Von Milwaukee owns all of the paintings and curated the show.
Published Oct. 17, 2016
Carmen Pitre is the president and CEO of Sojourner, Wisconsin's largest service provider for families dealing with domestic violence. Pitre leads a staff that provides crisis housing, system advocacy and individual support to thousands of women, men and their children.