Milwaukee's Daily Magazine Sunday, Nov. 8, 2009
Today
Hi: 72
Lo: 46
Sun
Hi: 61
Lo: 50
Mon
Hi: 58
Lo: 41
Section Sponsor
Article Tools
Print this Article
Make text larger
Related Twitter Posts

  • DeadHead513:
    Check out palomino or zelo in downtown mpls. Good food. Please win tomorrow. Redeem the packers RT @flintstone14: About to grab a bite in MN

  • Spurleyesque:
    AWESOME! RT @sskurnick RT @news2bz: love #farve or hate him, this is pretty funny: link #packers #vikings #nfl

  • sskurnick:
    RT @news2bz: love #farve or hate him, this is pretty funny: link #packers #vikings #nfl

  • news2bz:
    love #farve or hate him, this is pretty funny: link #packers #vikings #nfl

  • c2cashwell:
    @SI_PeterKing Mike McCarthy=Hot Seat, Yes or No?


Follow us on Twitter ...
In Sports Commentary
Does Rodgers have the intangibles of a champ?
Can Aaron Rodgers lead the Packers to a championship?  
By Dave Begel RSS Feed
Special to OnMilwaukee.com
Photography by Allen Fredrickson
E-mail author | Author bio
More articles by Dave Begel

Published Dec. 9, 2008 at 5:25 a.m.
Tags: packers, dave begel, aaron rodgers, mike mccarthy,barry sanders, fran tarkenton

Today's subject is the Packers' quarterback.

Not who used to be quarterback of the Packers. Not who we think should be the quarterback of the Green Bay Packers.

Nope. Today we are going to talk exclusively about Aaron Rodgers, the four-year veteran who is now, and for the near future, the quarterback of the Packers.

There are three games left for his team this season. And make no mistake about it. This is his team. He didn't necessarily earn it, but the bosses gave it to him and so it's his team.

We can take some measure of this quarterback and I have a growing suspicion that he may end up falling into a worrisome class of athletes.

This is a class that includes such luminous names as Allen Iverson, Fran Tarkenton, the other A-Rod (Alex Rodgriguez), Jim Kelly and Barry Sanders. All are athletes who had statistics good enough to call them great. All are athletes who never won a title.

I wonder about that with Aaron Rodgers. Great numbers. A little short on the win side of the ledger.

Rodgers now is the quarterback of a team with a 5-8 record. He has great stats. After signing his huge contract Oct. 31, he proceeded to lose five of his next six games.

The hints were present when Rodgers was in college.

During his final year, he led California to a great season. The Golden Bears won everything except a game against USC. In that game, Rodgers set a record by completing 26 consecutive passes. Cal had first and goal with just less than 2 minutes left. With a chance to win the game, Rodgers threw three incomplete passes and Cal lost. Then the team went to the Holiday Bowl and was beaten by Texas Tech.

We will never forget that draft day when Rodgers, who some people had talked about being the first overall pick in the draft, slipped all the way to Green Bay at No. 26. Could all of those general managers have been wrong?

There are concrete things to worry about with Rodgers. He doesn't seem willing to stay in the pocket and work his way through his receivers. He'd rather take off and either run or throw on the run.

He's made some bad throws at moments that demanded a good throw. People say he's got happy feet, a little too jumpy for a top-flight quarterback.

It's not all bad. Certainly, Rodgers seems to be a lot tougher than people thought he might be. He also seems to have a great mental grasp of coach Mike McCarthy's offensive philosophy.

But there is one thing that may be missing, the thing that the great ones have that drives a team to a title.

I don't know if Rodgers has the ability to inspire.

Don't scoff. Football, more than almost any game, depends on a measure of inspiration for success. And look at those guys who haven't won a title.

Barry Sanders was almost a recluse. Iverson is a street thug. Tarkenton was a flake. The Yankees' A-Rod is wrapped up in his own celebrity. Kelly didn't have a sense of humor. All were great, but the didn't help lift their team to championship heights.

You can tell things about an athlete by watching carefully. And when I look closely at Rodgers, I see an ability to play but no ability to inspire beyond the expected. And if that's the case, this team better start looking for another quarterback right now.



More Information ...
Green Bay Packers
1265 Lombardi Ave.
Green Bay, WI 54304
(920) 496-5700
http://packers.com

23 comments about this article.
Post a comment / write a review.

Recent Talkbacks ...

Posted by more_cowbell on Dec. 22, 2008 at 1:40 p.m. (report)

I only know of one device used to measure the heart of someone, I saw on the How the Grinch Stole Christmas and I seriously question the scientific accuracy of the device. (I mean 3 sizes bigger is a medical impossibility) Arguments like this are easy to make because they can't be challenged. By your judgment Jim Kelly didn't do a good job of inspiring his team since they went to 4 consecutive Super Bowls and won none. Did he fail to inspire the Norwood kick 5 feet to left? Too much credit is given to this intangible of "inspiration" because people want to believe that there is some magic force out there. Players need to execute and get the occasional break to win games. Make Brett Favre the QB of a High School team bring Vince back from the dead to coach the team and they still lose to a pro team 100 out of 100 time because better players win games not inspiration. Even if Rudy delivers the pre-game speech.

Rate this:
  • Average rating: 0.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


Posted by sugarcreekboy on Dec. 10, 2008 at 3:55 p.m. (report)

Joe Montana was 2-6 in his first 8 starts with the Niners. Troy Aikman started 0-11 Terry Bradshaw started 8-13 Steve Young started 3-16 You're right, Dave, a bad start will translate into being a loser your entire career. Oh wait, Those four guys have what, 15 or so NFL titles under their belts? Bart Starr's start to his career? 3-15-1 Seriously, Dave, I thought I respected people who typed more than the people who rambled into a mic all day, but you're inane ramblings have me ranking you below the hacks at 1250. Now that's a career loser.

Rate this:
  • Average rating: 0.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


Posted by brbutler on Dec. 10, 2008 at 12:43 p.m. (report)

Must not do too much research since you put in the in accurate draft position. Also, if you listen to a lot of the ex-players and close followers of the NFL you would find out that Rodgers at times holds on to the ball TOO long and does not move enough. You have to remember he is mobile QB unlike the tired legs of Favre that we are used to. Just make sure you check into factually accurate info before posting.

Rate this:
  • Average rating: 0.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


Posted by tomjulio on Dec. 9, 2008 at 10:19 p.m. (report)

Don't forget to read Dave's other insightful OnMilwaukee.com articles: 1. "I imagine the Kool-Aide at Jonestown actually tasted good." 2. "Lee Harvey Oswald was a horrible shot" 3. "Milwaukee, home of the 2018 Winter Olymipcs" 4. "My wife looked chubby in the dress she wore to work today" 5. "The darkness in here where my head is makes me think better"

Rate this:
  • Average rating: 0.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


Posted by Broner on Dec. 9, 2008 at 7:28 p.m. (report)

Ah, how I look forward to Dave's weekly ramblings and everyone's weekly smackdowns. I can't wait until next week's article titled, "I Effin' Hate Aaron Rodgers for No Real Reason Other Than He's Not Brett Favre!!!!!"

Rate this:
  • Average rating: 0.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5




Show me the other 18 Talkbacks
OnMilwaukee.com is part of the In Click Network. Other In Click sites include: 30RockReport.com | Behind The Scenes at OnMilwaukee.com | BetterRecipes.org | Bimmer Digest | Brain Brawn & Body | BrewCityBeats.com | Brewcitybigscreen.com | britneysnation.com | BritPop Rocks | Brooklynbanter.com | CactusLeagueReport.com | Caffeinateddigest.com | Culinary Piedmont | Cycling Chainring | Daily Lost Update | Daily Milwaukee News | Daily Spa | DannyGokeyMilwaukee.com | Dogs Blogs | EarthFueled.com | Edible Wisconsin | FanaticPhotog.com | Gadget Deals and Steals | GolfLinksWisconsin.com | H1N1 Alerts | H1N1 Blog | H1N1 Prevention | H1N1 Reporter | H1N1 Tracker | HogEnthusiast.com | Informed Runner | iPhone Daily Report | Man United Nation | Milwaukee Brewers Nation | Milwaukee Bucks Blog | Milwaukee Dad | Minnesota Wild Nation | MomMilwaukee.com | My Super Stocks | MyGayMilwaukee.com | MyHangoverHelper | News on Draught | NY Mets Nation | OnAtlantaGA.com | OnAustinTX.com | OnBaltimoreMD.com | OnBirminghamAL.com | OnBostonMass.com | OnBuffaloNY.com | OnCharlotteNC.com | OnCincinnati.com | OnClevelandOH.com | OnColumbusOH.com | OnDallas.com | OnDCmetro.com | OnDenverCO.com | OnDetroitMI.com | OnDoorCounty.org | OnFortLauderdale.com | OnGreenBay.com | OnHartford.com | OnIndianapolisIN.com | OnKansasCityMO.com | OnLakeCountry.com | OnLosAngelesCA.com | OnLouisvilleKY.com | OnMadison.com | OnMemphisTN.com | OnMiamiFLA.com | OnMilwaukee.com Cars | OnMilwaukee.com Metro Headlines | OnNashvilleTN.com | OnNewOrleansLA.com | OnNYCny.com | OnOrlandoFL.com | OnPalmSprings.com | OnPhiladelphia.com | OnPhoenixAZ.com | OnPittsburgh.com | OnPortlandOR.com | OnProvidence.com | OnRichmondVA.com | OnSacramento.com | OnSaltLakeCity.com | OnSanAntonioTX.com | OnSanDiegoCA.com | OnSanFran.com | OnSanJose.com | OnSeattleWA.com | OnSinCity.com | OnStLouis.com | OnStPetersburg.com | OnTampaBay.com | OnTucsonAZ.com | OnTwinCities.com | OnWichita.com | OnWindyCity.com | Packers Posts | Porsche 911 Fans | PriusFans.com | Roller Derby Network | SnuggieFans.com | SummerfestRocks.com | Swine Flu China | Swine Flu Reporter | The 24 Reporter | The Barack Obama Fan Club | The Brilliant Manager | The Comic Book Reporter | The In Click | The Office Fan Blog | TheHDTVReporter.com | TheNetbookBlog.com | TheNewParentBlog.com | Trueguitarheroes.com | Vintage Mets | VW Busses | WaukeshaWeekly.com | Weekly Media News | Wisconsincustomhomenews.com | WisWomen.com | Woodworker Digest