When Brewers GM Dean Taylor dealt reliever David Weathers to the Cubs for starter Ruben Quevedo Monday, it hearkened back to last July 28 when he acquired Richie Sexson and Paul Rigdon from Cleveland (as well as Kane Davis and Marcos Scutaro) for pitchers Bob Wickman, Jason Bere and Steve Woodard.
Though Taylor gave up 30 percent of the team's pitching staff, the deal was clearly a good one for Milwaukee. In the year since, Sexson has hit .267 (159 hits) with 40 homers and 118 RBIs. Muse all you want on his 184 punchouts in 595 ABs, 40-homer, 26-year-olds do not come cheap.
Even if you don't like the Sexson deal, Taylor's prodigious nature is notable. On the current 25-man roster, only seven players (Chad Fox, Allen Levrault, Ben Sheets, Ron Belliard, Mark Loretta, Geoff Jenkins and Jeromy Burnitz) were on the club or in the system when Taylor took over in autumn of 1999. The team has not improved in the standings, but certainly not for a lack of trying.
What of the other moves? So far, they've been a mixed bag, and several key ones are still shaking out in the daily box scores. Let's look at Taylor's winners, losers and all the others.
Winners
RP Mike DeJean and P Mark Leiter and IF Elvis Pena for RP Juan Acevedo, P Kane Davis and IF Jose Flores (trade with Rockies, April 2001) - DeJean's effectiveness (57.2 IP, 2.03) is a big improvement over Acevedo's inconsistency. He also made Weathers even more expendable. Acevedo was originally acquired for Fernando Vina in Dec. 1999 in a deal with St. Louis, also under Taylor's watch.
OF Devon White for OF Marquis Grissom (trade with Dodgers, March 2001) - With
the team's uncanny injury problems, White has been a godsend. He has 28 extra
base hits and 10 steals in bench duty and still plays an effortless center field.
Grissom (16 HR, 44 RBIs) had a big contact and a bad history in Milwaukee.
Sexson, et al (July 200) -- Jury deliberations continue on Rigdon, who went
down with an elbow injury in early July after bouts of promise. But none of
the three players lost are likely to ever haunt Taylor.
{INSERT_RELATED}
RP Ray King for Doug Johnston (trade with Cubs, April 2000) - King has been
the Brewers' lone bullpen lefty this year, and was nearly unhittable in 2000
(1.26). If you can tell me who Johnston is, I owe you a drink.
Claimed C Raul Casanova off waivers (March 2000) - At times, Casanova appears to be the only Crew member capable of getting home a man from third with less than two outs. The former Tiger prospect has also shown good power (9 HR) in a part-time role.
IF Tyler Houston signing (FA, Jan. 2000) - Houston was team's most consistent
hitter this year before going down in mid-July. The affordable infielder belted
18 homers in 284 ABs in 2000. Losers
P John Snyder and P Jamie Navarro for P Cal Eldred and SS Jose Valentin (trade
with White Sox, Jan 2000) - Eldred benefited from getting out of town and Valentin
was eventually fully replaced by Hernandez, but Snyder and Navarro were absolutely
awful in their brief stints in Milwaukee. Taylor likely has repressed memories
of this one.
OF Mark Sweeney and Gene Altman for OF Alex Ochoa (trade with Reds, Jan. 2000)
- Ochoa (.292/7/42) was recently dealt to the Rockies for Todd Walker and Robin
Jennings, and he's certainly better than James Mouton as a fourth OF. Sweeney
never regained his impressive pinch-hitting form of 1999 and is at AAA-Indianapolis.
P Brandon Kolb and P Will Cunnane for SS Santiago Perez and OF Chad Green (trade
with Padres, Dec. 2000) - Kolb and Cunnane have been consistently bad, while
Perez could still become a decent major-league shortstop. The failure of high
draft pick Green is on Sal Bando's resume, not Taylor's.
OF Jeffrey Hammonds signing (Dec. 2000) - The oft-injured one has been injured
often. He may bounce back a la Hernandez in 2002, and his huge contract demands
it in order for Taylor and the Brewers to break even.
TBD
P Jamey Wright, P Jimmy Haynes and C Henry Blanco for 3B Jeff Cirillo (three-way
deal with Rockies and Devil Rays, Dec. 1999) - Taylor's major move until the
Sexson deal continues to teeter between success and failure. Wright (8-7, 4.13)
showed flashes of being a quality No. 2 man, but has struggled with injuries
and consistency; Haynes' Brewer career should be on life support after continuing
struggles (7-13, 4.85); and even Blanco's vaunted defense is starting to suffer
along with an inept bat. Cirillo (.307/13/58) hasn't completely panned in Denver,
but his consistent stick is precisely what the Crew lacks.
RP Curtis Leskanic for RP Mike Myers (trade with Rockies, Nov. 1999) - The
Leskanic move looked brilliant when he closed 11 of 12 save opportunities after
Wickman's departure in 2000, but he's blown several of his few chances this
season. Myers remains the lefty out-getter he was here, but King has filled
his role adequately.
Two-year contract with Jeromy Burnitz (March 2001) - At the time, this move
looked terrific, but Burnitz's numbers (.241/22/66) pale in comparison to would-be
Brewer Phil Nevin's in San Diego (.315/29/88), the guy Taylor tried to trade
for before the Pads balked at Burnie's money demands.
Miscellaneous
Had the Brewers wanted to badly enough, they could have re-signed Weathers.
But considering he was a waiver pickup in the Bando regime, Quevedo's youthful
promise is worth losing him. Taylor likes reclamation projects (Mike Buddie,
Lance Painter, Mac Suzuki, and Angel Echevarria on the current roster), and
his bottom-feeding pays off every so often. Taylor also decided not to re-sign
Hideo Nomo for the 2000 season (11-4, 3.86 with Boston) for financial reasons.
SS Jose Hernandez signing (FA, Dec. 1999) - Yeah, it looked awful last year,
and Jose will always whiff too much. But until a recent slide, his 17 homers
and 46 RBIs looked awfully nice and his defense at short has been exceptional.
Sports shots columnist Tim Gutowski was born in a hospital in West Allis and his sporting heart never really left. He grew up in a tiny town 30 miles west of the city named Genesee and was in attendance at County Stadium the day the Brewers clinched the 1981 second-half AL East crown. I bet you can't say that.
Though Tim moved away from Wisconsin (to Iowa and eventually the suburbs of Chicago) as a 10-year-old, he eventually found his way back to Milwaukee. He remembers fondly the pre-Web days of listenting to static-filled Brewers games on AM 620 and crying after repeated Bears' victories over the Packers.