By Molly Snyder Senior Writer Published Jun 07, 2012 at 12:30 PM

On Thursday, May 17, Tricia O’Malley got a phone call that she will never forget. It was from her husband, Josh, and he told her that their dog, a 2-year-old Boston terrier named Briggs, was no longer on the porch where he had just left him minutes earlier.

Tricia came home immediately and the couple ran through the alley and streets yelling for Briggs. Once they returned home, their neighbor told them she saw a man take the dog, but she thought maybe it was a friend. She described the man as "Hispanic, stocky and in his 30s."

"We stopped and tried to register what she was saying," says Tricia. "I broke down, so did my husband. Then we called the police."

While waiting for the police to arrive, Tricia started the online effort. She posted stolen dog reports on every website she could think of, including the Wisconsin Humane Society, MADACC and more.

She and her husband printed 1,500 flyers – they would print 4,000 total throughout the course of the 17-day campaign to find their dog.

"We weren’t messing around," she says. "The first day was particularly insane. We had no idea what to do. We didn’t eat. We were in shock. I drove through neighborhoods with a baseball bat and mace looking for this dog."

The first batch of flyers had their address, a detail that could have been problematic, but in reality, brought strangers to their door to help. (They did not include their address on subsequent batches of flyers, only their phone number.)

The next day, the O'Malleys called television stations and Channel 4 did a story on the missing dog. Also, the couple started to receive phone calls with leads; all of them proved to be false.

"This became the pattern for the next two weeks," she says. "We chased every lead, we flyered every day."

Friends with a conversion van loaded up the O’Malleys, other friends and their dogs to canvass neighborhoods throughout the city.

"If it was daylight, I was out flyering. At night, I was doing the online campaign portion. Whatever we could do."

The community and the social media support was phenomenal. More radio stations picked up the story. Mexican restaurant La Perla tweeted about it, inspiring many more restaurants to retweet about the missing dog. Actress Rose McGowan even tweeted the flyer.

On the flip side to all of the support, because the O’Malleys' phone number was on the flyer, they received many awful calls from people claiming they had their dog or had killed their dog. Some just called to find out how much the reward was and others actually went so far as to set up fake meeting times and places, saying that they had their dog. Other callers made straight-up aggressive sexual threats.

"It was rough, but we just had to roll with it. We didn’t know which phone call might be legit," says Tricia.

During this time, the O’Malleys hired a pet psychic for $175. She said the psychic gave them good descriptions of what the people who took him looked like, and targeted a specific Harambee neighborhood, but could not be specific enough to really help them find Briggs.

"He renewed our hope, though, and helped us keep going," says Tricia.

Other pet psychics called her, offering information for free. One claimed Briggs was in Shorewood, "crying for his mom" and another said she saw him terrified and lying on a slab of concrete next to a chain-link fence.

"It was frustrating and emotional. How do you know if there’s any truth to what they’re saying or not?" asks Tricia.

Briggs is a special dog, according to Tricia. "He is an absolute sweetheart with a huge sense of humor," she says. "He’s brought light and joyfulness into our lives and our marriage."

The second week of Briggs absence resulted in even more support. Hal’s Harley-Davidson helped spread the word, as did Marilyn Mee from WKLH. Plus, a woman they had never met before, Meghan Sattler, showed up at the O’Malleys' door every day and flyered. (Sattler, who has three Bostons of her own, has continued to visit and text every day since Briggs was returned home.)

A young woman living at Pathfinders, a runaway shelter in Riverwest, thought she saw the dog and worked with police to help them figure out if it was Briggs. Turns out, it wasn’t, but the girl’s efforts moved Tricia and Josh.

"She tried so hard and was so sincere. There were so many young people who were giving us a hard time, and this girl from a group home was really trying to help us," she says.

A strange wrench in the ordeal happened during the second week when Tricia received a call from a man who said he had a Boston Terrier who wasn’t Briggs but that he thought they might like. Apparently, the man had other dogs in his house who did not like his Boston Terrier, who was malnourished, and he wanted to get rid of him for $100.

Tricia and a team of friends went to meet the guy and pick up the dog, but when they met him, he suddenly wanted $300, then $400, for the dog. Tricia said no, she wasn’t going to pay that amount of money for the dog, and left. The man continued to send her photos of the dog and texts, and finally agreed to meet again to sell the dog for $125.

"I think, at the time, I just really wanted the dog to be Briggs even though I knew that it wasn’t. And I wanted to save this dog, too. What are the chances of searching for your Boston Terrier and finding another Boston Terrier who really needed your help?" says Tricia.

The second meeting was successful, and the O’Malleys paid $125 for the dog they named Blue. They took him to the vet to see if he was microchipped, which he wasn’t, and received confirmation that the 10-pound dog was severely undernourished at 10 months old.

Although the plan was to re-home Blue, he immediately started to attach to the O’Malleys, to the point that he suffers from severe separation anxiety and even cried until he threw up when he had to be separated from Tricia for a long period of time.

Shortly after, Tricia spent the day at the parking lot of El Rey, 1023 S. Cesar Chavez Dr., and set up a booth and handed out flyers in English and Spanish for the entire day. She says she went home that night, exhausted.

The next morning, Tricia was awakened at 6:30 a.m. and again at 6:35 and 7 a.m. by phone calls from people who were calling with false information about Briggs. She turned off her ringer and went back to bed, frustrated by the bogus calls.

At 8 a.m., the doorbell rang, but when she went to the door, no one was there. So she let Blue out and listened to her voicemails, expecting to hear more unhelpful information. Instead, she received a message from a woman saying, "I think your dog showed up at our church today."

Tricia ran over to the nearby Lake Park Lutheran Church and yelled to the groundsperson in the church's yard, "Do you have my dog!?" The groundsperson said yes, the dog had been sitting in front of the church shortly before the 8 a.m. service and was let into the church for water. The pastor identified the dog as "the missing dog" and held him up in front of the congregation which gave the dog a standing ovation.

A very good friend of the O'Malleys caught wind that Briggs was at the church so he picked up the dog and tried to call Tricia, but at that time, she still had her ringer turned off.

Soon after the conversation with the church groundskeeper, Tricia ran back to her house, screamed "He's back, he's back!" and she and Josh ran out of the house.

And then they saw her friend walking down the street toward her, holding Briggs.

"I started running down the sidewalk, sobbing. I was holding Blue, who I handed off to my friend, and grabbed Briggs and just sobbed into him," says Tricia. "Then my husband came out, and he started sobbing, and neighbors came out and people came out of the church and it was amazing."

Tricia says there are no signs of Briggs having been mistreated. His personality is the same and he has no physical signs of being in a violent situation. The only change is that he gained a pound, which might be because he wasn’t exercised and / or fed unhealthy food.

Because Briggs is neutered and microchipped, Tricia thinks someone took him, perhaps, to be a family pet, even though many people suggested he was stolen to bait fighting dogs. In fact, she received more than five calls a day from strangers warning her that Briggs was probably being used in dog fights. She knows now this was not the case.

Tricia says during the 17 days Briggs was missing she never gave up hope. During the second week, friends started to suggest to her she might need to eventually move on, but she was certain Briggs would come home someday, somehow.

"Our mantra during the search was ‘relentless.’ We were going to be relentless until this person could not go anywhere without seeing some mention of Briggs. We wanted to put a value on Briggs to make sure people cared," she says. 

Tricia says Briggs' abduction made her marriage stronger and allowed her and Josh to pool their talents and support. "I was the communicator and the marketer and he was the strength, the muscle, the footwork and the stable base to support me," she says.

Tricia and Josh cannot thank Milwaukee enough for the community support.

"Milwaukee stepped up big time. And beyond Milwaukee too. The state was going through so much these past couple of weeks and was so divided politically, but really came together to bring home Briggs," she says.

Molly Snyder started writing and publishing her work at the age 10, when her community newspaper printed her poem, "The Unicorn.” Since then, she's expanded beyond the subject of mythical creatures and written in many different mediums but, nearest and dearest to her heart, thousands of articles for OnMilwaukee.

Molly is a regular contributor to FOX6 News and numerous radio stations as well as the co-host of "Dandelions: A Podcast For Women.” She's received five Milwaukee Press Club Awards, served as the Pfister Narrator and is the Wisconsin State Fair’s Celebrity Cream Puff Eating Champion of 2019.