By Lori Fredrich Senior Writer & Dining Editor Published Dec 13, 2017 at 4:03 PM

The Tony-nominated musical "Waitress" will enjoy a brief Milwaukee engagement at the Marcus Center Jan. 2-7. In celebration of the musical’s Cream City debut, the Marcus Center teamed up with radio's B93.3 to host a pie-making contest for area bakers.

The contest resulted in a face-off between four finalists on Wednesday, Dec. 12 in the Marcus Center’s Green Room. Judges included TV and radio film critic Ryan Jay, myself and B93 radio personality Joe Krauss.

Dana McCormick, a piano teacher famous for the holiday truffles she makes around the holidays, went all out with her "Little Guy Likes Peanut Butter Pie," a pie featuring peanut butter pudding filling and chocolate ganache topped off with peanut butter buckeyes. She says was named for her youngest son, a pie lover who also once owned a helmet that she says "looked just like a peanut butter ball."

Meanwhile, Jamie Wallner – an environmental health and safety manager by day and baker by night – presented a pie for which she’s gained acclaim among her family and friends: Kentucky derby pie, complete with sweet chocolate, crisp pecans and a boozy bourbon zip.

And then there was Bridget Rhode’s perfect pear pie made with Bartlett pears layered atop creamy custard in a maple walnut pie crust. Rhode, who’s known for her desserts, says it’s a pie she often brings to gatherings. And it’s one her daughters encouraged her to enter into the competition.

And while each pie was sweet and delicious, there was one that stood out from the crowd: the sugar plum pie with vanilla brandy sauce from Allison Cebulla. And Cebulla went home with the grand prize, which included four tickets to "Waitress," a copy of "Sugar Butter Flour: The Waitress Pie Book" and inclusion of her recipe in the cookbook during the Milwaukee performance.

The pie, which is rife with holiday spices, features a filling of spiced plums, a cardmom streusel and an ultra flaky pie crust. Meanwhile, the lily is officially gilded with a topping of vanilla brandy sauce.

"Among all the things I make, pie is my signature item," notes Cebulla, who says cinnamon rolls come in at a close second. "I’ve been baking since I could stand on a chair next to my mom in the kitchen," she adds, noting that pie crust was actually the first pastry she ever learned to make.

And just in case you’d like to taste it for yourself, Cebulla has generously shared her recipe.

Sugar Plum Pie with Vanilla Brandy Sauce

1 9-inch prepared single crust (unbaked, recipe below)
1 recipe Sugar Plum filling (recipe below)
1 recipe Cardamom Streusel (recipe below)
1 recipe Vanilla Brandy Sauce (recipe below)

1. Position oven rack to the middle of the oven. Preheat oven to 375F. Line a sheet pan or cookie sheet with parchment paper.
2. Place the filling in a heaping mound in the pie crust. Top with approximately 1½ cups streusel.
3. Bake pie on parchment line cookie sheet for 30 minutes. Reduce oven temperature to 350F and baked for another 30-45 minutes, or until filling is bubbling and crust is golden brown.
4. Allow pie to cool for 2-3 hours before slicing and top with Vanilla Brandy Sauce, as desired.

Sugar Plum Filling
Makes 1-9" pie

5 cups diced plums, pits removed
1/3 cup granulated sugar
½ tsp grated fresh ginger
1 tsp orange zest (approx. ½ orange)
1 tbsp cornstarch
½ tsp ground cinnamon
Pinch ground nutmeg
Pinch ground cloves
¼ tsp Kosher salt
½ tsp vanilla extract

1. Place cut plums in a large mixing bowl. Set aside.
2. In a small mixing bowl, rub fresh ginger and orange zest into the sugar, releasing the fruits’ natural oils. To the sugar mixture, add the cornstarch, cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves, salt, and vanilla extract. Stir until a light paste forms.
3. Transfer sugar and spice mixture to the large mixing bowl with plums and toss until the plums are evenly coated.
4. The filling is now ready to be transferred to a prepared pie shell.

Cardamom Streusel
Makes approximately 1½ cups

½ cup all-purpose flour
4 tbsp brown sugar
2 tbsp granulated sugar
¼ tsp Kosher salt
½ tsp ground cardamom
¼ tsp ground cinnamon
¼ tsp ground allspice
¼ tsp ground ginger
Pinch ground cloves
4 tbsp unsalted butter, softened
1/3 cup chopped walnuts

1. In a small mixing bowl, combine all ingredients. Rub the butter into the dry ingredients until the mixture is the consistency of graham cracker crumbs.
2. Set aside until ready to assemble pie.

Vanilla Brandy Sauce
Makes about 1 cup

1 tbsp unsalted butter
1 tbsp cup all-purpose flour
1 cup heavy cream
1 tsp vanilla
Pinch Kosher salt
2 tbsp granulated sugar
2 tbsp Korbel brandy

1. In a small saucepan over medium heat, melt butter. Once butter is melted, whisk in all-purpose flour and cook for about 2-3 minutes, stirring constantly, until mixture is light golden brown and smelling nutty.
2. Whisk in heavy cream, vanilla, sugar and salt. Stir until thickened, about 1-2 minutes. Take pan off heat.
3. Stir in brandy and refrigerate until ready to serve.
4. When ready to serve pie, gently warm the brandy sauce in a small saucepan over low heat.

Flaky Pie Dough
Makes 1 9-inch crust

1 cup plus 2 tbsp all-purpose flour
2 tsp granulated sugar
Pinch salt
1/3 cup unsalted butter, cubed and chilled
2 tbsp shortening, cubed and chilled
¼ cup ice water

1. In a medium mixing bowl, combine dry ingredients.
2. With a pastry cutter, fork, or your fingers, cut in the butter and shortening until the fats become pea-sized or slightly smaller.
3. Mix in ice water with a spatula or wooden spoon until the dough is ragged and just about to come together.
4. Gently press together dough, making 3-4 folds. (It’s okay if the dough isn’t completely damp or it feels like it’s too loose.) Form the dough (as best you can) into a round and tightly wrap with plastic wrap. Allow the dough to rest in the refrigerator overnight.
5. Once chilled, roll out dough on a lightly floured surface. Roll dough into a circle approximately 12 inches across. Carefully transfer to a 9" pie tin and crimp edges as desired.
6. Refrigerate until ready to use.

Tickets for "Waitress" are still available and can be purchased at the Marcus Center Box Office, 929 N. Water St., online at marcuscenter.org, or by calling (414) 273-7206.

Lori Fredrich Senior Writer & Dining Editor

Lori is an avid cook whose accrual of condiments and spices is rivaled only by her cookbook collection. Her passion for the culinary industry was birthed while balancing A&W root beer mugs as a teenage carhop, fed by insatiable curiosity and fueled by the people whose stories entwine with each and every dish. She’s had the privilege of chronicling these tales via numerous media, including OnMilwaukee and in her book “Milwaukee Food.” Her work has garnered journalism awards from entities including the Milwaukee Press Club. 

When she’s not eating, photographing food, writing or recording the FoodCrush podcast, you’ll find Lori seeking out adventures with her husband Paul, traveling, cooking, reading, learning, snuggling with her cats and looking for ways to make a difference.